House vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Had a great time! The area was nice, place was spacious, the amount of towels provided is great. Overall a nice stay!

This was my second time staying at this space by Amy with my entire family. Once again, we had a blast. When anything came up, Amy was responsive and quick to resolve it. The place is beautiful and accommodating and I will def be returning again with my family in the future.

Nice spacy place. The house was clean, the foosball table and air hockey table both worked. The pool is bigger than your typical above ground. The house is located is on a dead-end street which is nice, because there was no through traffic. It is located about 10/15 min from sports force and cedar point. The only downside is that you can hear the train from the house.

Maribeth was a great host. she gave clear, easy to follow directions, answered any questions promptly and had everything well supplied. the condo was very nice, private and peaceful, right on the bay. I loved everything about I t it.

Had a wonderful week vacation at Island Club at Putin Bay. Nichole was a wonderful hostess!! Made everything about our reservation, check in and entire stay very easy and smooth and terrific communication. Highly recommend.. thanks Nichole!!

We had a nice stay at Baypoint, The golf cart was key to have to go over to Bay Point amenities. The parking is tight when you have a truck, but we made it worked. The workout room and sauna was very nice.

great place to stay it was very clean with all of the amenities listed.. host lives upstairs in the unit and is very responsive.

We ended up at Barb's AirBnB after a last-minute cancellation elsewhere, and we’re so glad we did. This welcoming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home was just what we needed. Barb is a fantastic host—her guidebook of local activities and attractions is the best we’ve seen, and I’ve stayed in many AirBnBs (and grew up in Ohio). She truly goes above and beyond to help guests enjoy their stay. The house was comfortable, well-equipped, and felt like home. One note: there’s a nearby freight train line that runs throughout the day and night. Light sleepers may want to bring ear plugs, but we wouldn't let that stop anyone from staying here. Highly recommended.

This place is awesome. So many things to do in the house to keep kids occupied when it’s cold or rainy.

Hands down the nicest place I have stayed in. Tim was very responsive and quick to fix an issue we had during our stay. We will try to rebook this place next year.

The location and Airbnb were fantastic! The pictures truly don’t do it justice, it’s even more beautiful in person. The space was clean, extremely spacious, and perfect for a large group. Ted and the property manager were both kind, attentive, and quick to respond to any questions we had. They also had a wide variety of cooking utensils, pots, pans, and more, which made our stay even more comfortable. We didn’t need for anything! I would highly recommend staying here and would love to come back.

This home is beautifully decorated, clean and well stocked with everything you would need. We loved our stay and if we return to Sandusky, we’ll definitely stay again!

Joe and Kelly's " Our Happy Place" is a perfect getaway! Our family of 3 truly enjoyed our 6 nights there. We plan to make this our stopping place when we visit Cedar Point. Pros: close to everything, comfy furniture, fluffy large towels, extras, luxury living, beautiful surroundings, a stone's throw from the beach! our hosts were super friendly and helpful, more like a concierge service than anything else! Negatives: We had to leave & go home! Thank you both for a lovely visit. Looking forward to our next one.

Beautiful house in a quaint and quiet beach town. Easy instructions and access to get inside. The home was decorated beautifully and everything seemed to be in nice condition. The max guest count is 10 people and the pictures did make it seem larger than the listing. It was smaller than expected for 10 people to stay but we were still able to have a great evening and instructions for leaving were clear and easy as well. The private beach access is just a quick walk down the street but we were not able to stay because of lack of parking because of having the max guest count of 10. However there was a public access beach just a short drive away with a small parking fee. Overall it was a nice stay with very friendly hosts!

Very grateful that Amber was able to let us check in a couple hours before our check in time. House was clean and comfortable. We were there a little out of season for a lot to be open, but we still had a great time. Thanks Amber!

This home was clean, beautifully decorated and comfortable. It was larger than it appeared in the photos. The home had everything you’d need, from kitchen dishes, glasses, Keurig & and reg coffee pot to extra blankets and pillows. The host was responsive and considerate, ensuring our stay was comfortable from start to finish. And she provided clear check-in/out instructions. Fully recommended. We’re looking forward to our next visit.

It was a great time, perfect room for 8 people to stay a couple of nights. Fair price and great instructions, safety, and presentation of the house. Already planning to be back again same time next year !

We had a wonderful time. Kitchen was well stocked and organized! We had plenty of towels and extra blankets that came in handy on those cold days. The kids were endlessly entertained with all the backyard activities. The host was very nice and able to answer our questions. Our families had a pleasant stay!

One problem! Check in at 4, but check out at 11. Not a full two days. A lost of 5 hours. Check in should have been at 11.

Absolutely beautiful location, I stayed here with a couple of friends and we all loved it. looking forward to book it again maybe next year.

Location, location, location!!! The beach was just a 5 minute walk (even with loads of beach toys, chairs, and floats- all provided by Cindy!) All 5 of our children (ages 1-18) enjoyed their time- fun for all ages! Cindy was overly accommodating for us throughout our time there. We have officially fallen in love with Lake Erie! 😍

We really enjoyed our stay at The Rock House! The home has a very unique natural rock exterior and an updated and very comfortable interior. We can't recall staying at a place that provides so much for the guests. We didn't have to buy any supplies for our stay. We literally had everything we needed. And the home is full of windows so you can take in the beautiful neighborhood, the quaint park across the street, and even a good view of Lake Erie. The appliances and furniture were in great shape and the mattresses were very comfortable. Also, the checkout process is probably the easiest we have ever experienced. We can't say enough good things about this place. We loved The Rock House and would stay here again if we ever return to the area.

This is the second time I’ve stayed at Steve’s place - it rocks! Steve is a GREAT host - very responsive, flexible, and honest. The accommodations are exactly as described - everything is very modern and extremely clean. I can’t wait to come back!!

Great place to have the whole family come join in. The driveway is the star of the show because we can fit our 21 ft ranger on there. & it’s nice an hidden from the right side of the road.