Sign up
Log in
Vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

  • The Cedar Chalet
    Entire house · 6 guests · 7 beds · 3 baths
    The Cedar Chalet

    Three bedroom, three bath vacation home on quiet residential street on Kelley’s Island, OH. There is a large living room, with cathedral ceiling, and a balcony leading to the second floor bedrooms. A large, first floor deck, with table, seating, and Sunsetter Awning is attached. Gas grill, backyard fire ring, and bicycles are present for renter use. A spacious, full kitchen, with utensils and cookware, is provided. A washer and dryer are in the utility room.

    What guests are saying:

    “If you are looking for space, comfort, and a unique set up to enjoy the beautiful island, then look no further! This place is amazing! From the affordable price to the extensive amenities and peaceful environment, what more could you ask for?! This was perfect and plenty of space for our family of four. Linens are provided, which is not always the case on the island. Wish we could have stayed longer to spend some time around a fire or grill out! Thank you for letting us enjoy your beautiful home!”

  • The Boathouse on East Harbor
    Entire cottage · 3 guests · 1 bed · 1 bath
    The Boathouse on East Harbor

    Welcome to Rock Harbor Cottages. "The Boathouse" spent the last 50+ years as a waterfront storage shed. We were faced with a tough decision, tear it down or rebuild it. We rebuilt it into an amazing cottage, not on the water but IN the water. The view is second only to the over sized 2+ person whirlpool tub. Nothing better than waking up in bed and opening your eyes to the amazing view and hearing the sounds of the water. Close to dining, shopping, beaches, Cedar Point, fishing, and Lake Erie

    What guests are saying:

    “This little cabin is immaculate. It’s so clean and freshly decorated. My daughter (8) and I stayed for two days in November and while it was cold and snowing outside, we stayed nice and cozy warm in the cabin. The bed is comfy and my daughter slept on the futon. We loved sitting in bed and watching the lake move right outside. At night it was so pretty to watch the lights dance across the water. The kitchen is lovely and has everything you’d need. Brad was a fantastic host- very good communication, great recommendations for eating out - The Tin Lizzie at the airplane museum was a fantastic breakfast diner. The cabin would be a great romantic weekend for a couple too. We’ll come back in the summer when we can enjoy some boring and fishing. Thank you Brad! You have a gem on Lake Erie.”

  • Wake On The Lake
    SUPERHOSTEntire condominium · 6 guests · 4 beds · 2 baths
    Wake On The Lake

    Within walking distance of the Marblehead ferry and the downtown area with great shopping, restaurants and entertainment! Newly renovated! In the summer months, the private pool can be enjoyed. Includes WIFI & Hulu live TV. 2 bedrooms (1 queen master, and a 3 tier bunk-bed: 1 queen and 1 full-sized bed and twin), full kitchen, dining room (big enough for 6 people) and 2 full baths, fireplace & deck overlooking a beautiful reservoir. Laundry and essential oils are available. 724-355-6132.

    What guests are saying:

    “Wake on the Lake was a great place to stay. The location is perfect and it was super clean and well decorated. The master bedroom was comfy but the 2nd bedroom with the 3 tier bunk beds didnt work well with 2 couples. Our third couple had to sleep on the couch. Also the bunk beds are very close together so you cannot sit up at all and my friends snacked their head a couple times. However the rest of the house and stay was well worth this very minor setback!! I would definitely stay here again!! Thanks again!!”

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Popular amenities for Kelleys Island vacation rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wifi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Cottage for Two
Entire guesthouse
Cottage for Two
Price:$176 / night
Top Floor at the Back Bay Condominiums
Entire condominium
Top Floor at the Back Bay Condominiums
Price:$220 / night
Beautiful Lake Home on the Water
SUPERHOSTHouseboat
Beautiful Lake Home on the Water
Price:$151 / night
Cozy Cuddy Downtown Put-in-Bay
Hotel room
Cozy Cuddy Downtown Put-in-Bay
Price:$96 / night
Kelleys "Island-Time" Condo
Entire condominium
Kelleys "Island-Time" Condo
Price:$250 / night
The Dellwood's Lavender Room
SUPERHOSTPrivate room
The Dellwood's Lavender Room
Price:$123 / night
Beautiful & Relaxing Lake Erie Waterfront Condo
SUPERHOSTEntire condominium
Beautiful & Relaxing Lake Erie Waterfront Condo
Price:$129 / night
Executive Home on Kelleys Island !
Entire house
Executive Home on Kelleys Island !
Price:$479 / night
Conti's Cottage-Lake Views
Entire cottage
Conti's Cottage-Lake Views
Price:$315 / night
Waterfront paradise
SUPERHOSTEntire house
Waterfront paradise
Price:$450 / night
Lakeside Love
Entire cottage
Lakeside Love
Price:$125 / night
(#2) Elegant Lakefront Suite w/ Private Bath
Private room
(#2) Elegant Lakefront Suite w/ Private Bath
Price:$94 / night
Show all