Cottage vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Karen’s place is a beautiful location right on the lake! The space was pristine and Karen was so kind and accommodating!

The apartment was beautifully done - very nice decor that made you feel right at home! Amazing views of the lake from every room inside including the bedroom, livingroom, and kitchen. Pictures don't do a justice! The icing on the cake was seeing a bald eagle flying along the lake while we were using the hot tub in the morning. Karen had some excellent recommendations for us and was very friendly and helpful during check in. This place was top notch and we will eventually stay again!

Loved the placed wish the weather wasn't so bad wouldve enjoyed the hot tube but ill be back to do that lol house was amazing really liked it made me feel at home

Was a perfect weekend getaway. The hot tub was amazing and private and the place was so cozy and comfortable.

The home was absolutely beautiful, and we had a wonderful stay! Would 100% book this Airbnb again!

We arrived late and left early on our trip cross country, so didn't get to enjoy to beauty of being on this lake, but appreciated the location and the comfortable accomodations.

Karen was a wonderful host! We had a great time. The place was very nice and very clean. I would definitely go back!

The house was perfect for us traveling back to the Utah Mtns. for the winter. It was super clean and had everything you would want including Debra being the best host. Property had some special features will old growth oak trees and a far view of Lake Erie. Will be back in the spring. Thanks Debra.

Very clean, well stocked kitchen, games to play, quiet at night, beautiful scenery with the park across the street and you could see the lake out the window. Walkable to restaurants. My granddaughter and I really enjoyed this Airbnb. I would for sure stay here again.

I’ve stayed in many VRBO’s throughout the US and this has to be my absolute best experience. David has gone over and above to make you feel right at home. I loved the “coffee bar”. I’m a tea drinker and he had me covered. I usually have to bring my own portable tea kettle and forgot it this time. He totally had me covered from a variety of teas and coffees. I will be back again next year and know exactly where I’ll be staying. What a great little place. Next time I won’t have to pack as much! As a host, David nailed it! Thank you David for the Ohio hospitality! We had such a great time!

Right by the public beach area on Lake Erie by the lighthouse park and another park was in between that beach and the house. Also very close to ferry. Staying here made me feel the vibe of Port Clinton. We love going to the African Safari Wildlife Park (the walk thru part is as amazing as the drive thru part!) and the Lagoon Deer Park was a great experience, so glad we went there!

The home was beautiful and well maintained. Corrie, the host, was very informative for everything regarding the care of the home and check-in and check-out.

5/5 stay, 100% booking for next year’s Pelee hunt again!

Amazing spot! Went fishing on Lake Erie with 2 other people. Close to downtown (walking distance). More than enough room for 4 people. Place was clean and presentable. Host was responsive, accommodating and kind. Couldn’t have been better. Will definitely be back.

My stay at the cottage was for the annual Pelee island Pheasant hunt and this review will likely only be applicable to others using the location for the same purpose. We were overall very happy with the accommodations. They were clean, well maintained and very comfortable. For future hunters staying at this location, there was plenty of room outside to clean birds and ample parking for at least two trucks. Overall, our stay was very enjoyable and I would book with Shelley again without hesitation. Thank you again Shelley

We enjoyed our stay here! Brian was incredibly responsive and helped us work through rescheduling our stay when unforeseen circumstances popped up on our original dates. The house was located close to what Catawba Island has to offer. We would stay here again!

Beautiful little place overlooking Sandusky Bay. Will definitely be back.

Was a perfect fit for our weekend getaway. Excellent and prompt communication. I captured some amazing scenery photos! Thank you!

We loved our get away at Lakeside Love. We were in need of some relaxing quiet time and the cottage was perfect for that. So charming and cozy. Everything was immaculately clean and Tara thought of everything we could possibly need. We certainly hope to make a return visit.

Joel's place is a charming little cottage. Everything is very simple but you'll find everything you need. Joel went over and above for us, and left beautiful ripe tomatoes from his own garden in the kitchen for us. I was doing some family research on the Island, and Joel himself had some stories about people who had known my family. The volunteers at the Historical Society were super helpful and friendly, too. I had a great weekend on Kelleys Island.

It had everything we needed. We enjoyed our stay there. In a great location close to the beautiful beach and pier and restaurants.

We had two families that stayed at Karen & Jeff’s for our annual trip to Marblehead. It is a gorgeous home, perfect for kids to run and scooter the neighborhood, swim in the pool and play at the beach. Cannot wait to go back!