Vacation rentals with lake access in Kelleys Island

Great place and host! Would definitely stay here again.

This home was so enjoyable to stay at! The location is gorgeous. We loved the sunrise over the water and the sound of the waves in the evening. The house was so perfectly clean. The layout and furniture arrangements are very family friendly. The property is large and plenty of room for outdoor hanging. We will definitely return!

Ted's place was awesome! Excellent place to spend a relaxed weekend with family and friends. You feel at home. The house is really spacious, the rooms are impecable! We were a family of 10 and were really comfortable. Everything was provided by Ted, you really don't need to bring anything extra but your clothes and toiletry. You can fish from the porch right on the beautiful Lake Erie. Ted was very responsive and polite. I would definitely be staying at his place again.

Very clean and awesome lake front location! Enjoyed my entire stay with friend.

Great home and decor. Clean and comfortable. Location wonderful. We were off season so not a lot open, but there was plenty to do. We took the ferrie over to Put-in-Bay and had lunch at the winery along the way on Catawba Island - so nice! PIB was adorable but again off season - we missed by a week. But JJs was good food as well. Worth the stay!

We loved it here! It’s actually even better than the pictures. It was perfect for us. Thank you!

This little house was comfortable, clean and convenient to everything we wanted to see. We took a small walk to the end of the street and were on the beach of Lake Erie. About a 15 minute drive and we were at Cedar Point. There was a gas station close, a Dairy Queen if you prefer burgers and 2 nice dine in restaurants for the more mature palates. It was fully stocked and we lacked nothing during our stay.

Hoping to stay again some day in warmer weather! Great house, very quiet location, incredible views out of both sides, and great to be able to just cross the street to enjoy the lake, even on a cold day! Unlike so many Airbnbs I've been to, it a feels like a place you can actually live in, and has everything you find yourself opening a cabinet or closet to look for! Side note for those with kids: There are a lot of stairs and random steps all around the house, which my very responsible almost-2-year-old really enjoyed, but it would have been hard with a younger mobile kiddo. It was great to have a crib and some toddler puzzles there!

Dodge House is a historic property that has been in the family for generations. Weather and age takes its toll, but it has been carefully modernized (central A/C!) for the comfort of guests without it losing its Victorian charm. Wonderful people with lifetimes of stories about the island. Great location just around the corner from downtown, yet far enough away from the fray for a peaceful stay.

We were extremely satisfied, and Lisa answered all of our questions promptly. It worked well for our short stay and hopefully we’ll be back again next year.

Such a cool spot — you immediately feel transported to a different place. We found ourselves forgetting we were even in Ohio anymore! It’s also close to everything and there’s a bike path right at the end of the street. Highly recommend!

Easy to find, instructions were spot on. Furnishing were super nice. Great place to stay if you want to walk the sites in Sandusky, or walk to the jet express for put in bay. We very much enjoyed our stay. Sandusky is very underrated.

Beautiful property on the marina! Perfect location for the Burning Snowman Festival! Very tentative and friendly owners. Highly recommend!

Cozy and comfy place to stay with plenty of amenities! The hosts were wonderful and communicated promptly. We would stay here again!

This was our second time at Torrie's place in 4 months - that should tell you everything you need to know! We came once for a little bachelorette trip and again with our young kids. The location was perfect for both trips! Could not ask for a better spot to catch the ferry quickly. The house is incredibly spacious and welcoming. The only warning I would give is that this area is full of great night life, so there are live bands playing each weekend night in multiple bars/restaurants. You will hear music until midnight - so bring noise machines or ear plugs if that's an issue for you. Depending on the bedroom, the AC units cover a lot of that anyway. But that's a minor detail in an otherwise wonderful spot - we hope to be back next summer!

Plenty of great things to say! There was a mistake with scheduling and Bill was out of town. He found a way to keep my booking alive, no idea what phone calls he needed to make but he worked it out quickly. The place was clean, amenities were all available, love the location and view. And again, Bill was an absolute pleasure to work with. I will be returning very soon!

Katie’s cottage was the perfect girls weekend away! We enjoyed relaxing on the front porch looking out at the water. Everything was nice and neat in the house and we felt right at home!

Brad and Kelly place was very nice and close to everything that we needed. This place is all about the little things. They have a guest book that’s so cute and they provided a bottle of wine at check in which was well needed after a 6 hour drive with 5 kids.

It was a great place to relax and enjoy peace and quiet. The only thing i missed was the chance to read a bit about the history of this mini-mansion! If only the walls could speak!!

Absolutely loved staying here with family for my dad and I bday week. The views are worth it. Highly recommend and would come back!

The place matches everything about the description and the hosts were very easy to communicate with. We stayed during the late fall so it was quiet and peaceful and the lake view is amazing.

We had a great two-night stay at Joan’s Airbnb “Once Upon an Island”. I was a bit concerned at first about staying on an island with limited access to stores during the off-season, especially with our baby who was under two months old. But the house had almost everything we needed, and Joan was quick to respond to all our questions. It’s a perfect place to relax—the lake views and the surrounding little islands are absolutely beautiful, especially when the weather is nice. The price was also very reasonable. Highly recommended!

Pretty tiny boathouse, quiet neighborhood, close to everything. We enjoyed our stay, thank you!

Sarah is very easy to work with and she was able to be flexible with how many days we could book, we very much appreciated that and how easy she made everything. The space is well kept and cozy, we love staying there!! Very highly recommended, definitely stay if you get a chance. :-)