Apartment vacation rentals in Sister Bay

Jill has created an excellent opportunity for her guests. The convenient location is in town with a panoramic view of the bay, the unit is super clean with a nice vibe, and her attention to every detail is outstanding. The highest compliment that we can give her, is that we'll be back. In fishing terms, this place is a keeper.

From the minute we walked in, we felt so comfortable here! They had a nice essential oil diffuser that made the place smell great. The unit is set up beautifully. They have everything you need in the kitchen and bathroom. It was a really cool place!

What a great little gem! Great shopping and restaurants. Perfect location. We stayed the week of Christmas and one of the owners stopped by to give us a box of candy from their store. So kind!

We loved it and are planning our next trip to go back. Great location, quiet and nice neighbors.

Logan’s place is a lovely comfortable house with all basic needs catered for a getaway to Door County & surrounding places. Everything was perfectly in order and we thoroughly enjoyed our stay. The collection of books for guests was amazing and people can read to their children as well. I give this place 5 stars

Kathleen was great from the start. I surprised my wife for her birthday and everything went great. Not only would we recommend to others but we would love to make the trip again. The location was easy to walk to get to great drinks and a variety of food. The place was quiet and very clean. A great way to spend a weekend in Egg Harbor!

Charming finished lower level of this home (walkout basement) decorated nicely, lovely forested area, peaceful surrounds. Beds firm which we appreciated. We were a bit chilly and Helen was quick to respond and offered to adjust the heat or have us opt to use the portable which was absolutely great. Nice stay.

Wonderful place to stay near Peninsula State Park and Fish Creek. Great restaurants, coffee shops and exploring!

We had a great stay for the weekend with 3 adults, 1 toddler and our dog! Krissi made everything so easy, and was responsive when we had a quick question during our stay. This is the ideal location in Algoma, easy walk to everything while also feeling quiet and secure. The place is nice and updated, and I loved the extra little touches that made it feel more personal!

We really enjoyed our stay at Mike’s apartment! It was a great location and walking distance to the local shops, restaurants and park! The apartment was just as shown in the photos and very modern and up to date! We will be coming back and hope to stay there again.

This place was amazing! It was clean and had beautiful updates. It appeared brand new! It was spacious and perfect for our girls weekend. 3 Comfy beds and two large bathrooms suited the needs of our group of 5 and All the amenities you need for a weekend getaway!

We had a great stay!

This is our second time staying with Joseph. He’s a great host with clean, modern accommodations. My wife and I felt at home, the apartment was clean and minimalist while still being comfortable, and Joseph was proactive in providing us all of the information we needed for our stay. Joseph is our preferred host any time we come to Algoma. Highly recommend.

Great spot in Algoma, perfect for a brief stay with our dogs. The apartment is clean and spacious. It’s right in town, so many things are walkable (including a beautiful beach!). What stood out the most, though, was Sara’s clear and friendly communication and responsiveness.

We just had the best time staying at Heavenly Stay. It was incredibly clean. So many rooms and each of the 3 couples had their own bathroom. Staying in an old church was so charming and it was decorated to perfection. We interacted with the owners on a few occasions and their assistance and suggestions helped make our stay in Sturgeon Bay filled with so many great memories. We will definitely be booking another stay here and bringing more of our family to enjoy. Thanks Al & Shannon

This was exactly what we were looking for. Comfortable, clean, and close to everything. The price was fantastic for this lovely space and the convenience of being able to walk everywhere. The best mattress I've ever slept on and I would love to have the bath towels! We came before the busy season, so Algoma was quiet, but that's what we wanted. We've been to Algoma many times but never stayed overnight, and I would return to stay in Haley's place. Thanks!

We really enjoyed Jon’s place. It’s located in a quiet area yet within an easy drive to all the attractions of Door County. The place is very spacious and could easily accommodate 6 people, but had plenty of room for the 4 of us. The beds were very comfortable, there were plenty of towels and other amenities. We appreciated the provided coffee and the coffeemaker, as well as all included kitchen accessories. The grill on the balcony was a great addition as well and we enjoyed cooking dinner on the night of our arrival. Thank you again for a great place to stay!

This was a spacious and beautiful place to spend some time with family just after Christmas. The indoor pool was a great amenity!! Thank you, Mario : )