Beach house vacation rentals in Mantoloking

This was one of the most memorable and meaningful events and Ashley's gorgeous home was the perfect centerpiece and the warmest most wonderful place that we could've ever found. We are so greatful! The decor, the furniture, the rooms, the beds, everything available for us to use, I can go on and on and on. The pictures don't do it justice. Wow if you are on the fence of where to go, THIS IS IT! We hope to come back again!

So glad we stayed at John's beachfront home. We wanted a way to escape the noise and chaos of a large city and this was the perfect fit. Granted the commute is longer, but we couldn't get enough of the amazing ferry ride from Rockaway to Manhattan/Wall Street. Such a great way to explore NYC.

We had a wonderful weekend staying at Ami’s! You couldn’t ask for a better location if you want to be close to the beach. The home was exactly as pictured and we enjoyed the large front porch for our early morning coffee and late night conversations. If we return to Seaside, we would book this home again! Thank you!

The house looked exactly as it did in the pictures. It was perfect for my family. The bedrooms were perfect and clean. The location was great as it was so close to the beach. And finally, the host was lovely and accommodating.

Welcoming and responsive

Our family had a wonderful time in this comfortable, beautifully decorated home. We were made to feel welcome with a gift basket of goodies and other little touches. The views of the bay and beach were amazing, along with a boardwalk right off the front yard for wonderful walks. The kitchen is fully stocked which enabled preparing our Thanksgiving dinner very easy. My only recommendation would be to have a Keurig available for ease. We highly recommend Juliana and Eloy as first rate and would return. Thank you for a memorable stay!

My bridesmaids and I stayed here for my wedding in April 2025. The place was extremely clean and spacious, especially downstairs where hair and makeup set up the morning of my wedding. There is a ton of natural light throughout the home, which was great for my photographer. The home is conveniently located about two blocks from the PPB boardwalk, as well as center of town (Arnold Ave) where there are many restaurants, and was close to my venue Clark’s Landing. Brian was very responsive and was so sweet to leave my now husband and I a bottle of wine to welcome and congratulate us. We used Coastal Linen Service to provide towels and sheets as they are not included (Brian recommended) and we had no issues with delivery or leaving them for pickup. Overall, was a great stay and memorable weekend! I will advise there are large stairs leading up to home, I would not recommend for the elderly or those with disabilities. Also, TV downstairs does not have streaming, but king bedroom TV does.

Stephanie’s house was even more beautiful than pictured! The location was ideal, only 1 block to the beach and a short walk or very short drive into town for great food and mingling! Stephanie responded immediately to all questions we had and was wake and helpful! The house was tremendous with tons of open space, room for storage and an awesome stocked kitchen for cooking and entertaining guests! The small but functional backyard was great to enjoy some fresh beach air and relax while grilling and having a cocktail. Access the the driveway made coming and going super convenient. My family of 3 and our visitors had a wonderful week and will definitely return in the future!

The house is well designed to accommodate 12 people. We celebrated thanksgiving together here and it was perfect to all be in one area of the house to enjoy dinner, games, and conversation. The balcony has ocean view and the beach is right there. It’s a wonderful house with a very responsive and friendly host. We all had a marvelous time and felt right at home.

We really enjoyed our stay here! Having the pool was fantastic and the house was bigger than I anticipated when I booked. What a little oasis. Appreciated the parking at the house and the side street parking. Loved the quick access to other shore towns. A great find overall.

Timothy was a great host. Easy to communicate with. The house is very nice. The beds and pillows are comfy. The kitchen was well stocked with all the items we needed to make family dinners. Our child loved playing with the toys available. Timothy was extremely helpful in arranging pickup for items we forgot at the house after our stay. I would recommend this house and would definitely stay again!

Christine's home was perfect; clean, comfortable, all the amenities we could want. Christine went out of her way to make sure my daughter's prewedding days were lovely. She allowed us to check in early to accommodate our schedule and left a bottle of wine to welcome us. The weather did not cooperate and allow us to use the great outside features, but the views from the windows were beautiful. Would definitely recommend!

Stayed here with a few friends for a couple days. Great host, great place. Highly recommend!

We had a wonderful stay. The home was perfect for us and our 4 children with lots to do. Many attractions within 15-20 minutes and the kids enjoyed walking to the pier to fish. Can't wait to come back.

Jayne was wonderful. She made us feel right at home and was always available. Beautiful home in great location on the water. The pool was amazing and always warm. I would definitely stay here again next summer.

Tiffany has a wonderful home with a beautiful pool. The fenced in backyard is perfect for pets. The house is in an excellent location as you can walk to many stores and restaurants. We were extremely happy and had a great time staying for a few days.

Had a great time during my stay! Enough room for my family of 5 to sleep comfortably. The yard was a great spot to sit back and relax after a long day of walking around. And it is right down the road from the beach. Looking forward to staying again if in the area!

The place was as described and perfect for our needs. Brought my 94 year old MIL home to the Jersey shore for a birthday celebration with family in the area. Elevator addressed our access needs. Close to beach, easy to get in and out of the area and just plain charming. Made for a great trip and if she chooses to return, I know where we will be staying.

The Creamcake house was absolutely perfect for us! Had everything we needed! Towels, beach toys, wagon, umbrella plus all the inside goodies. Catherine & Scott were extremely nice and accommodating. They setup a slip & slide and baby pool for our toddler before arrival. That was such a sweet touch. The house was amazing and walkable to not only everything in ocean grove but also Bradley beach & Asbury park. This gave us many options of things to do and restaurants. Our friends with their toddler stayed a few days and it didn’t feel at all cramped with 4 adults and 2 littles. Overall I’d highly recommend the place! Our daughter said she wanted to live in the pink house forever. It was a hard goodbye. Thank you for everything & being great hosts!

Stephan's place was perfect for what I needed, I would stay there again if I find myself in Belmar again!

I really appreciated their prompt responses and kindness toward our many questions.

The house was in a great location. It’s within walking distance of many fine eateries and a 10-15 minute walk to the beach. The hosts were very responsive and helpful.

Eight of us very much enjoyed our week at the Shell Shack. Laura's home was lovely, clean, and spacious. Laura was easy to work with and always responded quickly. The sunset view was second to none! We also were grateful for a peaceful and quiet neighborhood/surrounding area. The bay view was relaxing and pretty from the front porch and we spent a lot of time eating our meals outside. We'd absolutely rent this home again.

The house is beautiful and the communication and service were excellent