Cottage vacation rentals in Keuka Lake

Our stay at this cottage was nothing short of perfect. From the moment we walked in, we could tell the owners had gone above and beyond to make this a true home-away-from-home. The house was not only spotless and cozy, but incredibly well-stocked with everything we could have possibly needed. The kitchen was a dream—fully equipped with quality cookware, plenty of utensils, coffee supplies, and even a few unexpected extras like a slow cooker and a blender. The bathrooms were supplied with plenty of fluffy towels, extra toiletries, and even a hair dryer. You can really feel the care and attention to detail here. It’s rare to find a rental so beautifully maintained and so well-equipped. We can’t wait to return!

Absolute perfection!! From the easy check in and communicative hosts, to the stunning location and gorgeous home. We felt at home right from the start and every small detail in the home was well thought out and created the most lovely ambiance. We had all types of weather during our stay and everything about this home allowed us to enjoy it all. We hope to be lucky enough to stay here again soon!!!

Thank you for our wonderful stay this weekend. Your place is the quintessential lake cottage. Everything we needed was supplied and at our fingertips, without being overrun with “stuff.” Well-maintained, clean, and comfortable. It was a cool, rainy weekend and we took full advantage of the bedroom fireplaces and extra blankets! Would love to come back to enjoy summer-time at your place. Thank you!

The Diane and Tom were very responsive and helpful from local attractions to helping provide tools when we had car trouble. The space was very welcoming and even had local coffee, s'mores makings, and other snacks. The hot tub was perfect for relaxing at anytime of the day and the lake was within walking distance. The only downside was an uncomfortable master bed, but the other 3 beds were like sleeping on clouds! The water is not drinkable due to taste, but we brought our own.

The house was absolutely beautiful with an even more beautiful view, the kayaks and paddle boards were easily accessible and were a ton of fun on the lake, Mary was a great host. We had some weather related incidents and she responded within minutes. The only negative thing I could say is, we should’ve booked it for longer, we didn’t want to leave. It was very fun weekend!

Great spot close to the lake! Fit 6 of us comfortably. Weather was rainy for the holiday weekend but Jennifer's place was a great place to hunker down, cook, and hangout with our family. House was clean and Jennifer was a great communicator. Would stay again!

Beautiful home right on the lake. The weather was a bit cold and rainy while we were there so we didn't use the outside space as much as planned, but the spacious living room and dining room were perfect for our 8-person group plus a 7 month old! Tons of space to spread out, play games, read, and play with baby. There were mega blocks, a play mat, a high chair, a changing table, a crib, and everything we could need for our baby. The hot tub was also fantastic for the colder days. We used the firepit as well and there were plenty of Adirondack chairs for our group our there. Two of our cars are electric, so the charger was a big plus! This is a wonderful find and we would love to book again later in the summer! Perfect for the whole family. We cooked a few time while here, and the kitchen had the basics like toaster, cooking utensils, pans, knives, etc. Lots of cups and glasses for making drinks, too.

Great cozy cottage on the Keuka Lake. Garrett was a great host and the house was very comfortable for my family of 4. Got to enjoy taking our paddle board on the lake, sit by the fire pit during sunset and enjoy the hot tub after a cold rainy hike at Watkins Glen gorge.

Footsteps from the lake with a winery on the property, what’s not to love? The living space is even roomier than the photos imply, but you won’t want to be inside other than to sleep! The location is perfect for exploring the finger lakes if you feel the need to leave this little slice of heaven. Cannot wait to return.

Had a great stay. Interior of home was nicely aesthetic, comfortable, and well maintained.

This cabin is the perfect place to switch off from the world and relax. The lake is beautiful. The cabin is clean and well equipped. James and Renee are lovely people whose main aim is for people to enjoy the experience of staying at their properties. Jamie brought us fish from the river and kitted us out with bikes to save us hiring some. A lovely stay.

Highly recommend the Little Blue Cottage! It was the perfect size, layout and location for our stay, which included four adults, two children and two dogs! We had plenty of space and the proximity to the lake from the cottage was fantastic and a short walk to Lodi Point State park for playground access and walkability was great. We really appreciated the ability to have our dogs with us during our stay. We'll be on our list of favorite stays within the FLX! Thank you!

Michele and Andy were friendly, helpful, hospitable hosts, and their farm is beautiful! We enjoyed a relaxing weekend surrounded by their horses, cows, fields and forests. The house itself has rustic, unpolished, handmade charm and is decorated very tastefully. The bed was comfortable, the wood stove was easy to use and helped us stay warm for our winter visit. Michele was accommodating of our arrival and departure times, going out of her way to try to help us adjust plans to match the weather. She was also very helpful in providing restaurant recommendations and information about the area. We highly recommend staying here!

We loved the cabin spent Mothers Day weekend with my family and Grandkids...we definitely would stay again the view is beautiful and the sunset everything meant all our needs

We usually don’t spend much time at the house on vacation—we’re all about being out and about—but this lake house completely changed that. It’s right on the water, and absolutely stunning. The views, the layout, the cozy yet rustic feel… it was all just perfect. We found ourselves lingering in the mornings with coffee on the dock, hanging out in the evenings playing games, and just enjoying every bit of the space. It was exactly what we were looking for, and it was especially great for our dog, who had the best time exploring and relaxing with us. It felt like home, only better. We’re already planning our next trip back and can’t wait to share it with more friends and family! Dustin was great with communication and responded quickly when recommendations were needed! Highly, highly recommend!

The Little House is in a perfect location, near scenic trails and some of the best restaurants, wineries, and breweries in the area. Communication with Hannah and Dustin was great, and they recommended some local spots and even places in another nearby town we were staying in the night before checking in.

Roy and Molly are great host. Very friendly and helpful. Roy even had a fishing pole rigged up for me. Cottage was clean and helpful notes of instructions were left to aid your stay. Would definitely stay again. Thanks Roy and Molly.

Very cozy cabin, right on the water. Beautiful area and dog friendly! Would definitely stay again!

We have been staying at Back-Acres for 6 yrs now. We love it so much we bring our closest friends and family. It’s such a gem

We had an amazing stay at “The Lake”! The house was spotless, and the quiet atmosphere made for a truly relaxing getaway. The neighbors were friendly and welcoming, and the games provided endless fun for both kids and adults—Scrabble nights and life-size Jenga were highlights! It was the week before Labor Day weekend, and the lake was incredibly quiet and peaceful. Renting a boat made it feel like we had the whole lake to ourselves, which was a fantastic bonus. We loved the short drive to Harriet State Park for stunning views and hikes, and Mill Street Cafe became our go-to for breakfast and evening ice cream. The thoughtful welcome gift and note from our hosts made us feel right at home. We even spotted bald eagles and enjoyed breathtaking views of the Milky Way on clear nights. Highly recommend!

Wow - what a fantastic lakeside retreat! There must be 6 different places to sit/gather outside - the fire table was especially nice for sipping some Riesling on a chilly night. Well equipped kitchen, and lots of amenities (including kayaks if so inclined). Very quiet surroundings (we were there during the week-end, too), but you have to watch out for the seagulls - they like to hang out on the deck. Great location is within 1/2 hour of many excellent wineries and restaurants. Would definitely return here the next time we are in FLX!

Absolutely a perfect location. Beautiful little house right in the heart of the wineries AND right on the water. Couldn’t ask for a better spot. Host is very responsive and had lots of recommendations along with times to go (and not go because of crowds)

What a fantastic place! Perfect for our family! Franks had alll the amenities we needed at the right price! Lakefront, plenty of space, boats to play in, and a hot tub with a great view!!!!!

No frills, but exactly what you need for a relaxing stay on the lake in FLX. Cabin is well equipped for whatever weather you encounter- plenty of fans, heaters, blankets, and windows. There are many lighting options, portable lamps, and tons of outlets. There are 2 wineries walking distance from the property, and dozens of wineries, breweries, cideries, restaurants, stores and more within a 20 minute drive. Just a little further gets you to Geneva, Ithaca, Watkins Glen and more- the scenery can't be beat. It is incredibly dark and quiet around the property, so rain, wind, falling branches, etc. can seem a bit alarming, but just know that going in and don't let it deter you! Bruce was available for check-in and checked-in to make sure everything was going well. I would definitely return!