Cottage vacation rentals in Sodus Bay

Sally & Gard were great Hosts. Their home was beautiful and homey, with many comfort details not typically found in other Airbnbs. The pond and wooded setting were specular with the fall foliage on full display during our stay! The Kitchen had everything we needed for our long-term stay and the beds and linens were very comfortable. We enjoyed our stay and would love to return. Thank you Sally & Gard for making our stay special with your lovely home.

Nice setting easy to get to all activities we were looking to do like Watkins glen and wineries. Tony provided detailed instructions and gave good recommendations!

Absolute perfection!! From the easy check in and communicative hosts, to the stunning location and gorgeous home. We felt at home right from the start and every small detail in the home was well thought out and created the most lovely ambiance. We had all types of weather during our stay and everything about this home allowed us to enjoy it all. We hope to be lucky enough to stay here again soon!!!

beautiful place to stay very friendly hosts great family atmosphere

The host was extremely friendly and informative. Their website includes so much info that you literally find everything you need for your stay. Location was amazing and can only recommend.

Heidi’s place was great! Incredible views from all three floors and literally right on the water. The house was clean, nicely designed, and just as nice as the pictures! Thanks for the awesome stay!

Cozy Clark Cottage was all we could have wanted for a long stay at the lake. The location was the perfect mix of privacy and convenience. Set far back on a secondary lane and not visible from the main road, but only a couple minute drive into town for groceries, a pharmacy, a huge wooden playground, a library, bank, post office, bakery (amazing!), the quaintest brewery, and more. The region itself is breathtaking with tons to do! We thoroughly loved playing in the large yard. The lake is beautiful and we went to the water’s edge every single day - rain or shine - to skip stones, wait (& wait) for fish to bite, and search for tiny shells and “fairy glass.” The fire pit provided welcomed heat on chilly evenings, as did the wood-burning stove inside. One of our favorite features was the climb up nook with a double bed where my kids rotated who would be the designated occupants. Beds were comfortable and we all woke well-rested for each day’s adventures. This spot is a gem!

We have stayed at this house multiple times. It is our home away from home at the Finger Lakes. You can’t beat the location! The house is absolutely perfect. It is a wonderful getaway. I can’t recommend it enough.

We traveled to Sodus Point with a small group of middle school aged kids as part of a learning adventure. We loved the house! The kids especially loved fishing on the dock, using the paddle boards and enjoying the games (like Spike ball) that were in the shed. We lucked out with beautiful weather and these crazy kids even went swimming in the water which was only 41F!!! We used the grill, had a fire outside and even made time for a movie night in the living room together. The house was also close enough to other things for us to make many day trips around the area. We even ventured to Niagara Falls from there - 2 hours away. We really enjoyed our time there. Michelle was very responsive to my questions and helpful when I needed it. Thank you!

Footsteps from the lake with a winery on the property, what’s not to love? The living space is even roomier than the photos imply, but you won’t want to be inside other than to sleep! The location is perfect for exploring the finger lakes if you feel the need to leave this little slice of heaven. Cannot wait to return.

Had a great stay. Interior of home was nicely aesthetic, comfortable, and well maintained.

This cabin is the perfect place to switch off from the world and relax. The lake is beautiful. The cabin is clean and well equipped. James and Renee are lovely people whose main aim is for people to enjoy the experience of staying at their properties. Jamie brought us fish from the river and kitted us out with bikes to save us hiring some. A lovely stay.

We loved the cabin spent Mothers Day weekend with my family and Grandkids...we definitely would stay again the view is beautiful and the sunset everything meant all our needs

We were celebrating our 34th wedding anniversary and family graduations! This location was close to family, nostalgic in that we used to have family reunions on the lake, and very relaxing and comfortable. Aside from the unseasonably cold weather, it was nice to explore the town, enjoy delicious food and enjoy scenic sunsets on the lake! Would love to return with family in the future! Brian and Melissa were very responsive and we didn't have any issues!

We loved our stay! The house was awesome, very comfortable, and had everything we might need during our stay. Those rocking chairs on the porch were the icing on the cake. So lovely - hope to come again during the summer or fall.

Our family enjoyed our stay. It was comfortable and spacious with beautiful surroundings. We are looking forward to a return stay.

We highly enjoying our stay at Samantha’s cottage. It was a beautiful weekend getaway and the fall foliage made it even better!! The kitchen was extremely clean, and had everything we needed to cook meals during our stay. We weren’t there long enough to use the washer and dryer but I was grateful to have it if needed. The house has lots of natural sunlight, and the covered porch was great when it rained or when we didn’t want to make the walk down to the lake.

Vicki is a great host and very attentive to guests needs. she checks in and asks if you need anything. Also had some extra care items in case you forget something. The lake and view are outstanding!! the location is very easy to get to. My only critique is: it's listed as a 2 bedroom, when really it's a 1 bedroom with a small loft with a bed... however, it was perfect for the 2 of us, and we really enjoyed out time.

Very cozy cabin, right on the water. Beautiful area and dog friendly! Would definitely stay again!

We had an amazing stay at “The Lake”! The house was spotless, and the quiet atmosphere made for a truly relaxing getaway. The neighbors were friendly and welcoming, and the games provided endless fun for both kids and adults—Scrabble nights and life-size Jenga were highlights! It was the week before Labor Day weekend, and the lake was incredibly quiet and peaceful. Renting a boat made it feel like we had the whole lake to ourselves, which was a fantastic bonus. We loved the short drive to Harriet State Park for stunning views and hikes, and Mill Street Cafe became our go-to for breakfast and evening ice cream. The thoughtful welcome gift and note from our hosts made us feel right at home. We even spotted bald eagles and enjoyed breathtaking views of the Milky Way on clear nights. Highly recommend!

Our family had a fabulous time. (A little nerve wracking with the parking situation, but we managed) The set up of the home was perfect for a family of 4, two decks with a view; felt as we were in a tree house. Easy check in, easy to navigate around and clean. We swam everyday, nice swim spot for kids. Our son fished morning and evening, ended up catching 2 and half in total. Marine near by, for a boat rental. Grilled homemade pizzas, overall great way to end the Summer- thank you for sharing your home with us.

Beautiful lake house! Quiet and well stocked with everything we needed.

This is a lovely, tranquil spot south of town. Great location if you plan to explore around the area and right on the lake. Had everything we needed!

No frills, but exactly what you need for a relaxing stay on the lake in FLX. Cabin is well equipped for whatever weather you encounter- plenty of fans, heaters, blankets, and windows. There are many lighting options, portable lamps, and tons of outlets. There are 2 wineries walking distance from the property, and dozens of wineries, breweries, cideries, restaurants, stores and more within a 20 minute drive. Just a little further gets you to Geneva, Ithaca, Watkins Glen and more- the scenery can't be beat. It is incredibly dark and quiet around the property, so rain, wind, falling branches, etc. can seem a bit alarming, but just know that going in and don't let it deter you! Bruce was available for check-in and checked-in to make sure everything was going well. I would definitely return!