Vacation rentals in New Holstein

Excellent stay quick communication Very nice and clean . I would rate it #1 . It has everything you you need and makes it feel right at home. I would never stay no where else when visiting Green Bay . Very good for families with kids . From lotion to seasoning for food they had it. Top tier Hosting. They definitely should recieve an award from how comfortable they made there place to host guest. Was definitely home away from home

Our stay at the Old Schoolhouse was great! The house was clean and well organized and had all the things we needed. The grounds were beautiful and we had a great time swimming in the pool, relaxing in the hot tub, and gathering at nights around the fire pit. Communication from Heather was fast and she thoroughly answered my questions. We had a great time at the Old Schoolhouse and would absolutely stay there again! Thank you, Heather!

We had such a great time! We loved hanging out in the fireplace room. The park across the river was perfect for walking the dog's. There was plenty to do and having restaurants and bars within walking distance was a huge plus.

A great little house. would be perfect for a football party, but I stayed there for the holidays with my kids and it was great for us, too!

Such a beautiful sanctuary, packed with everything you need for a vacation. The home is cozy and well appointed. We had a wonderful time, would love to go again.

Excellent place, I was there for almost 2 months and is very peaceful, the place is exactly like photos, everything was great, Thank you Chris

This is the second year in a row that we have rented Carrie's place for our family Christmas. It is a great property along the bay, with enough room to get together!

My kids loved all the ‘hidden’ spaces. I made great use of the exceptional kitchen/dining space. Our dogs were welcome and enjoyed watching the wildlife out on the lake expanse. Plus my husband (a disabled veteran) felt peaceful, safe & at home. We all enjoyed watching several eagles (at least one mated pair with a nest) bring nature into a wonderful up-close view for us. Bonus: after we’d arrived home we discovered a Kindle (pw) got left behind. We felt foolish and like a total pain. No worries! Jay went above and beyond to utilize its retrieval and ensure it was returned, despite our four-hour travel distance away. He was clear, respectful, and kind during our entire stay. We hope to return to this rental again. And would highly recommend any of Jay’s properties. They’re gorgeous, classy & clean but still feel like a home away from home.