Skip to content

House rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

SUPERHOST
Home in Lakeside
Adorable Lakeside 1 bed w/ year-round hot tub!
3 NIGHT MIN JUNE 15 - END OF AUG! ADORABLE HOME IN LAKESIDE WAS RECENTLY REHABBED & OFFERS A SUPER CLEAN AND MODERN FEEL IN THE HEART OF HARBOR COUNTRY. GUEST HAVE ACCESS TO PRIVATE BEACH WHICH IS A 7 MIN WALK AWAY - NO CROWDED BEACHES! YEAR ROUND HOT TUB, A SUPER COMFY KING SIZE BED AND ONE PULL-OUT COUCH FOR 4 GUEST (MAX). FIREPIT SUPPLIED WITH WOOD, AN OUTDOOR PATIO AND WEBER GRILL COMPLETE THIS LOFT LIKE HOME. FULLY STOCKED KITCHEN, HIGH DEF TV, STREAM MUSIC, ETC! YOU WILL LOVE IT!
$249 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Steps to Beach & Starbucks! Private Yard, Firepit!
Walk to Starbucks! Walk to beach, restaurants, shops, ice cream, grocery! 2 queen bed 2 bath home is perfect to enjoy fenced yard, grill, fire pit, & yard games offered. Take a few days to explore wineries/breweries, art galleries, antique stores, kayaking, casinos and more! Live bands Fridays/Saturdays till 11:30 pm Memorial Weekend to Fall at Casey's (behind property). Noise machines in each bdrm. Pet fee $100, 2 dogs MAX. Exterior areas have video/audio cameras w/ live feeds. Wp#bcnbwmech22
$220 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
In-town Lovely Home! Steps to Starbucks & Beach!
Spacious 3 bed/1.5 bath home in-town! Walk to beach, Starbucks, Stray Dog, grocery! Enjoy the fully fenced yard playing outdoor games from the shed, and a sand box for the kids! Grill and enjoy fire pit after a day of wineries, shopping in the local shops, galleries, antique shops, and casinos. Outdoor live music starts Memorial Weekend on weekends till 11:30 pm to Fall at Casey's behind property. Noise machines in each bedroom. Pet fee $150, 2 dogs MAX. Wp#acnbwmech22
$283 per night

House rentals with a pool

SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Farmesque with a splash of modern
$315 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Union Pier
Heated pool walk to Townline Beach
$244 per night
Home in Bridgman
Brand New , Dog-Friendly, Firepit,Hot Tub, WBFPL,
$211 per night
Home in Bridgman
Epic Indoor Pool w/slide & hot tub close to beach
$387 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Lakeside
Sunny Cottage in Lakeside w/ year round hot tub!
$464 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Three Oaks
Luxe Heated Pool (Still Open)| Hot Tub| Fire pit!
$289 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
DESIGNER LUXURY COTTAGE w/ HEATED POOL
$254 per night
Home in New Buffalo
4 Bedroom Wooded Lake Retreat - POOL and HOT TUB!
$577 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Secluded Pool Playhouse: Hot Tub, Games, Fire Pit
$318 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Lakeside
Private! Warren Woods Pool Retreat
$854 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Union Pier
Modern 5 bedroom farm home , hot tub , pool
$516 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Michigan City
The Frost House
$452 per night

Weekly house rentals

SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Square Toe's Last Resort
$204 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Michigan City
The Little House In the Big Woods
$182 per night
Home in New Buffalo
Newly Renovated City Escape with a private hot tub
$140 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Eagle’s Beach Nest II
$223 per night
Home in New Buffalo
Lux home w hot tub, firepit close to town + beach
$222 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Sawyer
The treehouse at Warren Dunes
$350 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Michigan City
Lake Michigan Farm Retreat w/ Yoga Shed & Hot Tub
$138 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Michigan City
Bright pup friendly retreat +hot tub
$166 per night
Home in New Buffalo
3BR Dog Friendly | Hot Tub | Fireplace | Deck
$292 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Three Oaks
Dog Friendly Downtown Three Oaks Cottage! Fenced!
$161 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
The Pump House Downtown New Buffalo
$110 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Cozy Vintage Cottage Near the Lake
$216 per night

Private house rentals

SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Eagle's Beach Nest
$197 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Lakeside
Cozy, modern getaway perfect for all seasons
$312 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Anna's Cottage
$193 per night
Home in Three Oaks
Stylish retreat with hot tub and outdoor sauna
$261 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Union Pier
Barn & Beach - main house ( front)
$349 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Captain's Quarters - Walk to Downtown New Buffalo!
$200 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Walk to Town, Pet Friendly, Fire pit, Fenced yard!
$171 per night
Home in New Buffalo
New Buffalo Charming Lake House CR23-0079
$286 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Michiana
House of Lotus- Chicago getaway
$314 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in Union Pier
Alex Cottage-Lake Michigan beach access!
$113 per night
Home in Union Pier
Modern Beachfront Home With Hot Tub , The Nest
$575 per night
SUPERHOST
Home in New Buffalo
Debs Michigan hot tub house, open all year
$203 per night