Vacation rentals in Fire Islands

Home in Fair Harbor, Fire Island

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay/Sunset Views!

Charming, Classic Beach Cottage right on the BEACH! with Panoramic Views & Sunsets on the Great South Bay! Summer on Fire Island is truly paradise. The ocean is sensational, the weather is perfect, the sunrises & sunsets are spectacular, the residents are friendly & creative, & life is WONDERFUL. Our Cottage has 5 Bedrooms with 8 beds that sleep 11. Like Fair Harbor, it has a casual, laid back vibe that is comfortable & enjoyable for people of all ages. * KAYAKS are AVAILABLE! Ask Roberto

5 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Home in Fire Island

Fair Harbor, Fire Island sunny 3 bedroom

Newly renovated home steps from the beach, the bay and the ferry. Extra high ceilings with sunlight streaming into every room. After a day at the beach, enjoy the large outdoor shower, grill and lounge area. Take a glass of wine and portable speakers to the clawfoot tub or indulge in the rain shower. Get some exercise with four new bikes and beach games or ping pong, foosball, air hockey and darts under the house. Two extra twin mattresses for guests with crisp white linens. Fast Wifi.

Apartment in West Babylon

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

Comfy 1st Floor Convenient Abode

Our Main Street West Babylon home, located on the 1st floor, is perfect for all guests. Perfectly situated for exploring Long Island's best attractions, minutes from Belmont Lake State Park, Babylon Village & a short drive to Jones Beach, Robert Moses State Park, and the Hamptons. 2 comfortable bedrooms with plush beds & 2 bathrooms with fresh towels & essentials. Cozy living room with smart TV & Wi-Fi. Fully equipped kitchen with appliances and cookware. Backyard with a patio and parking.

Apartment in Central Islip

5 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

Cozy studio w/ private entrance

Perfect for solo travelers or couples.This new, cozy studio is part of a larger home but fully self-contained w/ its own entrance. Inside, you’ll find: - A comfy living area with a pull-out twin bed and seating - A kitchen with essentials for light cooking - A private bathroom with shower, towels, and toiletries - High-speed Wi-Fi and a flat-screen TV Though attached to our home, your space is private. Located in a quiet neighborhood, close to attractions, restaurants, and transportation.

Apartment in Islip Terrace

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Near all! - Full Kitchen, Backyard & Fire Pit!

Come enjoy this beautifully renovated full 1 bedroom apartment with a full kitchen, living room with sofa/futon for a 3rd guest, bedroom, bathroom, and a sun-soaked backyard. Separate, Private entrance and off-street parking available for 1 car. Well-appointed for long-term stays or quick trips. This is a first-floor, ground-level apartment that gets lots of natural light. It is not a basement! :) Located in a quiet neighborhood and near all major highways. SmartTV. No cable TV :)

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 271 reviews

Guest suite in Bay Shore

Bay Shore's Private Guest Suite

Welcome to our cozy guest suite nestled within walking distance of the Fire Island ferries and conveniently close to local amenities! This private unit, attached to the main part of our home, offers a comfortable retreat for your stay. Step through your own private entrance into a welcoming living room, where you can unwind after a day of exploration. The bedroom features a queen-sized bed, providing a restful night's sleep, and an adjoining bathroom offers convenience and privacy.

Apartment in West Babylon

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 196 reviews

Loft 36 | King Sized Spacious Apartment

Welcome to Loft 36. A modern *private upstairs apartment* in a safe residential Long Island Neighborhood. Spacious and fully furnished with a private keyless entrance. Centrally located in the heart of WEST BABYLON. We are a quick trip to Babylon Village shops, bars, and restaurants, Tanger Outlets, Jones Beach, Robert Moses, and Marina Beaches. Ferries to Fire Island also close by. About an hour drive to New York City via nearby expressway or a 65 minute railroad ride.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Home in Commack

GOOD VIBEZ HOUSE! MiniGolf-Pool-HotTub-GameRm!

STAY. SOMEWHERE. DIFFERENT. This isn’t just a stay—it’s an experience. Welcome to THE GOOD VIBEZ HOUSE, your private escape in the heart of Long Island. Nestled in a SAFE, QUIET neighborhood, this one-of-a-kind spot blends smart home comfort with tropical resort vibes. From the moment you arrive, it feels like vacation. As Superhosts, we go beyond hosting to deliver a true vibe—with warm hospitality, thoughtful touches, and a five-star atmosphere you won’t forget.

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Home in Fire Island

45 Broadway Fair Harbor.

Our home is a two minute walk to the beach. Minutes from a grocery store and island restaurant! There are bikes to go to other towns bars and restaurants. We have a summer grill and a surfboard! We don't host parties and quiet time is 11 considering neighbors across the road. Fire island is only accessible by ferry. Parking is at fire island ferries. On the off season months we recommend shopping on the main land for food, as the island pioneer hours are few.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Home in Kismet

Kismet Beach House

Tranquil Beach Retreat in Kismet, Fire Island Welcome to our serene beach house in the beautiful neighborhood of Kismet. This peaceful 4 bedroom retreat is just a stones throw away from the ocean, offering you a tranquil getaway surrounded by the soothing sounds of the waves. The Holiday House is designed with relaxation in mind, where you can unwind after a day at the beach. Spend lazy afternoons in the sun, outdoor showers and BBQs await when you return.

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Home in Bay Shore

Kismet Fire Island Beach House (2025 upgrades!)

60’s modern/retro, award-winning (design) house. 45 secs to beach. Spacious, clean, social- well suited for groups and families (up to 10 max please, 8 is ideal). We've been doing a lot of improvements this winter! Fabulous retro mid house, open-roofed porch. BBQ, Outdoor shower, Hardwood floors, lots of light. 3 minutes from the ferry/ restaurants, but on a quiet street. Appliances and mattresses regularly replaced. Professionally cleaned weekly

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Apartment in Lindenhurst

2BR Gem/Private Driveway Entry

Welcome to our cozy 2-bedroom apartment located on the first floor of my home, in Lindenhurst, NY, 45 miles from Manhattan. Enjoy a private entrance and driveway parking. Perfect for families, near Long Island's beaches like Robert Moses and Jones Beach. Relax in the living area, cook in the kitchen, and sleep comfortably. Explore local shops, restaurants, and parks. Ideal for Long Island adventures and city trips to NYC.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Fire Islands vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Fire Islands

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Apartment in Stamford

Sunny 1BR Apartment

JoanRating, 5 stars5 months ago

Clean , modern apt. Very easy to navigate with the technology. Staff very friendly and helpful. A bit noisy on street outside with traffic. Will definitely rent again with URBY, but request a courtyard side unit

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Cabin in Shirley

A-Frame cabin with private beach & epic sunsets

NickRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Amber and her home were beautiful! Looking forward to staying there again next time I'm in the neighborhood!

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Home in Baldwin

Clarissa's Paradise

DarnelRating, 5 stars2 months ago

Great place will deff be staying again! Host was very understanding and helpful 10 out of 10

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Home in East Patchogue

Bay's Edge Vacation Get a Way

BillRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Earl, was great to work with. We were only there for few hours. However I would recommend highly and will look to stay here again should work bring me back out that way.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 490 reviews

Cabin in Rocky Point

Great little place just for a couple

JillianRating, 5 stars2 days ago

This was the perfect, quaint little spot—clean, cozy, and thoughtfully stocked with everything you could need. The neighborhood was beautiful and peaceful, and having a safe, designated parking space was a huge plus. The host was incredibly sweet and respectful of privacy, making for a seamless and relaxing stay. Highly recommend!

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

Home in Valley Stream

Luxury and Comfort at Another Level.

ShaniRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Communicative host, beautiful space.

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Apartment in Rocky Point

Cozy and Quiet space to Relax

NicoleRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

This was a great stay. It was clean and in a very cozy area. The bedroom was very cute as it was extremely comfortable and had all the amenities I needed for my stay. The kitchen was extremely clean and had everything down to even ice cubes in the freezer. You don’t need to buy anything for the kitchen use. The water pressure in the sink was quite intense too! The bathroom was clean, but I will say if you are on the bigger side don’t stay here because it is quite small but if not it’s perfect. The living room is very clean and spacey and perfect for snuggling up and watching tv. Keep in mind this is a basement so there are people upstairs and you can hear them quite a bit. But to me it wasn’t a bother Regarding the area it is pretty dense over there, but I did find some amazing food. I was celebrating my anniversary and we went to sea basin and we also went to inferno burger. Inferno burger was the BEST! Patrick was wonderful/ responsive and respectful of our privacy. WOULD STAY AGAIN!