Vacation rentals in Potter

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Potter

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Two Adirondack chairs in green and purple are situated in a spacious backyard, facing a view of Keuka Lake in the distance. A small table is placed between the chairs, surrounded by trees and a gravel area, offering a tranquil outdoor space.

Apartment in Penn Yan

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 513 reviews

Crows nest lake view flat

Crows Nest is located on the Keuka Lake wine trail. It is next to Red Jacket Park and Morgan Marine on one side, Seasons on Keuka Lake on the other. Very close to Penn Yan/Yates County Airport and between the Main Deck restaurant and Route 54. The property is NOT water front. Keuka Lake is accessible thru Red Jacket Park and visible from the property, but not directly on the water. There is a sidewalk from the property to town for Guests who prefer to walk, approximately 1 mile to Village center

Guest favorite

A spacious great room features wood paneling and a combination of comfortable seating arrangements. A large sectional sofa in dark upholstery is complemented by a coffee table, while a dining area with a round table for four is visible. Natural light filters through multiple windows.

Guest suite in Bloomfield

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 378 reviews

Farm House Suite 15 minutes from Canandaigua Lake

Country location on a quiet road just minutes from Canandaigua Lake, and Bristol Mountain. Large farmhouse, with private suite including a huge great room (450 sf), wrap around screened-in porch. Please note that bedrooms and bath are upstairs. Geothermal heating/cooling. No full kitchen or downstairs sink available, only toaster oven, mini fridge, coffee maker (Keurig) with seating for 4 in section of great room. TV, fast Wifi for all your devices. Plenty of privacy and room to spread out.

Top guest favorite

A grassy area features two Adirondack chairs, one pink and one dark green, positioned on a slight incline. Surrounding vegetation includes trees, showcasing a mix of green and autumnal colors, creating a natural, serene environment.

Guest suite in Penn Yan

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Overlooking beautiful Keuka: Sunrise to Sunset!

A self-contained apt right in the heart of the beautiful Finger Lakes. Close to Keuka College, parks, restaurants, museums, trails, wineries, and kayak/bike rentals. Room for boats/trailers. Self-check in with lock box Super clean, lower apartment features a private entrance. It has a large bedroom with a comfortable king size bed, convertible to two twins, upon request. Twin/mattresses on floor can sleep up to 2 children ($15 ea) or 1 more adult($40)per night Private bathroom with shower.

Superhost

The interior of the tiny home features a rustic wooden design with tongue-and-groove paneling. A lofted sleeping area is accessible by a wooden ladder, while a cozy seating area is positioned below. Ample natural light enters through windows, enhancing the inviting ambiance.

Tiny home in Penn Yan

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

Hollow Hills Tiny Home

Brand new double lofted Tiny Home on wheels located upon a private country hillside. Overlooking the hills of Keuka Lake, guests can enjoy radiant sunrises, knowing they are just minutes from the local wine trail/ breweries, Crispin Hill Wedding Venue, Apple/ Grape picking, the list goes on! While enjoying a cup of coffee, guests can take in a quiet and tranquil morning, all while being just a half mile from the Village of Penn Yan. Stay connected with our wifi, or just relax by the fire!

Guest favorite

Apartment in Penn Yan

4.7 out of 5 average rating, 182 reviews

2nd Fl. Studio Walkable In town no cleaning fee

1870 Historic Victorian 2nd floor studio with separate kitchen. No smoking or vaping inside of the unit please. No parties. Guests need to climb deck stairs and inside staircase to access apartment. Steps from downtown, near wineries, breweries, restaurants. Locally owned family home with pets. Stove, microwave, blender, toaster, refrigerator, coffeemaker. Propane BBQ grill Queen, single day bed trundle underneath (all beds in the same room) Free wifi, Netflix, Roku tv, YouTube tv

Top guest favorite

Guesthouse in Naples

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 255 reviews

Hawks Landing - Your Romantic Getaway! New Pricing

Welcome to Hawks Landing Cabin… your holiday romantic getaway! Located in the heart of the Finger Lakes, this extraordinary property perched above Canandaigua Lake with its spectacular views is within minutes of all the region has to offer. Hiking, fishing, boating, cycling, kayaking, snow many opportunities our guests can enjoy locally or just simply unplug and relax in the quiet of this cozy cabin. Come celebrate your holiday special moments in the privacy of this beautiful cabin!

Top guest favorite

A neatly arranged sleeping area features a quilt adorned with intricate floral patterns. Two pillows provide support against the headboard, while a decorative pillow displaying a dog illustration rests in the center, adding a subtle decorative touch.

Home in Canandaigua

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 367 reviews

Maiden Lane Charm

Cozy updated cottage within walking distance and access to a private community beach. 2 bedrooms, fully equipped kitchen, bath and living space. This charming 800 sq foot home features a gas fire place to keep you cozy in the winter and an upper deck with lake view for relaxing in the warmer months. Large yard, partially fenced in, with play house for children. The storage shed houses outdoor games and wagon for the short trip (.3 miles) to the beach. 4 miles from CMAC.

Top guest favorite

A panoramic view of rolling hills is captured during sunset, with vibrant orange and pink hues highlighted by clouds. Lush greenery surrounds the scene, creating a serene natural landscape that invites relaxation.

Guest suite in Naples

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 378 reviews

Naples Escape: Artistic & Serene w/ Magical Views

Escape to a peaceful, artistic haven surrounded by nature’s beauty! This 10-acre gem offers sweeping views, a tranquil pond, and leisurely strolls. Just 2 miles from the heart of Naples, explore waterfalls, wineries, charming shops, and local dining. Perfectly situated for seasonal adventures, with Bristol Mountain and Cummings Nature Center both under 20 minutes away. Whether unwinding or exploring, this cozy sanctuary offers a harmonious balance of comfort and creativity.

Top guest favorite

A charming guesthouse is set amidst a grassy landscape, framed by trees and shrubs. A gravel path leads to the entrance, with a sunset sky visible in the background. The structure features large windows and a clean, simple design.

Guesthouse in Penn Yan

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Quiet Guesthouse near Keuka Lake and Penn Yan!

Welcome to our cozy guesthouse! Nestled in the Fingerlakes Region of New York, it's the perfect place to rest after a day spent exploring our beautiful lakes, wineries, hiking trails, and so much more. Our guesthouse is located 2 minutes away from the Keuka Outlet Trail, 5 minutes from Penn Yan and Keuka Lake, and just minutes away from several local wineries. In the winter, we love to visit Bristol Mountain Ski Resort, 45 minutes from us! We can't wait to host you!

Guest favorite

The main living area showcases a spacious layout with wooden logs accentuating the walls and ceiling. A dining table is placed near large windows that invite natural light. The kitchen is visible, equipped with essential appliances, while a cozy sofa is positioned in the seating area.

Cabin in Naples

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 575 reviews

Hi-Tor Hideaway. The Cure for Cabin Fever.

A beautiful log cabin in the woods with an incredible view, that sleeps 5. There is a queen bed downstairs, a double in loft and then a roll-away twin in living room. Peace and quiet, discovering nature and resetting yourself. Life has been a challenge and it is good to step back sometimes. Our peaceful retreat is centrally located near many parks and waterfalls. Located between beautiful Canandaigua, Keuka and Seneca Lakes.

Top guest favorite

A snow-covered deck features two adirondack chairs blanketed in white. The landscape beyond is obscured by snowfall, with trees standing bare in the background, creating a serene winter atmosphere. The view conveys the peacefulness of the surrounding woods during the snowy season.

Cabin in Bloomfield

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 304 reviews

Relaxing Getaway Cabin...Explore The Finger Lakes!

Just 11 mile from Bristol Mountain, this unique cabin sits on top of a hill overlooking 100 acers of woods and fields. Relax and enjoy everything the cabin and property have to offer with 2.5 miles of walking trails, a large back deck, two fire pits and much more. Located in the Finger lakes Region offers easy access to many wineries, breweries, distilleries, antique stores, and shops. Rochester is 25 miles away and Victor is 8 miles.

Top guest favorite

A welcome sign is displayed prominently on the wall, featuring a rustic design with a wood-like finish. The text encourages guests to take pictures and leave footprints, while suggesting a focus on spending time in the woods. A dining space is visible in the background.

Guest suite in Naples

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Warren Hill~The Peaceful Place in the Woods~

The Peaceful Place In the Woods is an apartment suite nestled in ten acres of woodlands just five minutes from the quaint; historic village of Naples, NY. Enjoy the fresh air and changing colors of the season from your cozy hideaway or explore many adventures that Naples has to offer. Stellar cuisine, theater, music, fine arts, festivals, and a truly rich array of activities will leave you wanting to return again!

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Potter vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Potter

Top guest favorite

A laundry area is presented with a stacked washer and dryer, positioned on a wooden platform. A white laundry basket is placed nearby on the concrete floor, accompanied by a sturdy wooden bench. The walls are composed of gray cinder blocks, creating a simple and functional space.

Bungalow in Keuka Park

5 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Stone's Throw

LynnRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

We had a great weekend celebrating our daughter’s graduation from Keuka College. The house is walking distance to the school and was very clean. The beds were great and everything was provided to make the stay very comfortable. I would definitely stay here again.

Top guest favorite

The image captures a serene view of the property, featuring a winding gravel pathway surrounded by lush greenery and trees. A cabin is visible on the right, along with a covered porch and seating. The open landscape conveys a tranquil atmosphere, inviting exploration.

Cabin in Dundee

5 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Timber View At Timber Trails

SatyaRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Beautiful, compact, private place to stay! Thoughtfully designed property. Excellent hosts with friendly pets. Thoroughly enjoyed the quietness surrounding the property.

Top guest favorite

Farm stay in Canandaigua

5 out of 5 average rating, 68 reviews

CMAC 420 Friendly Horses Private Romantic Quiet

TimRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Outstanding location. Easy check in / check out, positive vibes and everything that you could possibly want out of an Airbnb. We will be back for sure!! Thanks again for a great stay!

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area features a brick fireplace with an electric insert and a large TV mounted above. Two blue upholstered chairs invite relaxation, while a small bookshelf stocked with games and books adds a homey touch. Light streams in through nearby dark curtains.

Home in Keuka Park

5 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

Home near Keuka is Sweet as Pi

KariRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

This is the second year in a row we have stayed here. Both time it was for kueka college graduation. Great location. 5 min walk to the college and the lake. If we ever need to go back to this location we will definitely look into staying here again.

Guest favorite

A stone fire pit is surrounded by a grassy area, with gathered sticks inside. A wooden bench offers seating nearby. In the background, a hammock is suspended between two trees, nestled among lush greenery.

Camper/RV in Rushville

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 79 reviews

Secluded camper with extra room to relax in

Christianah,AnnetteRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Beautiful place, loved how quiet it was and being in nature but still warm and comfortable in the camper. The covered porch is a huge plus, so you’re still able to sit outside when it rains and enjoy the fresh air and watching the animals outside. Tim was very helpful and proactive with instructions. Perfect place to stay and relax before our hike at Watkins Glen. Highly recommend and will be staying again!

Top guest favorite

A water slide extends into a pool, with water cascading down its surface. Green grass and a cornfield are visible in the background, along with a fence. A child’s lower legs, clad in orange swim shorts, can be seen descending the slide.

Home in Bloomfield

5 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

2 Bedroom pool house

SarahRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Great spot for a quiet retreat! Kenneth was great about communicating and being sure we had everything we needed! Beautiful view of the hills!

Superhost

A peaceful outdoor setting showcases a grassy area bordered by tall trees, with a tranquil river running through the scene. A small fire pit is visible in the foreground, surrounded by stones. The serene landscape features the gentle slopes of wooded hills in the background.

Cabin in Naples

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Little Red Cabin. Cozy and secluded retreat!

MageeRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

Our stay was great! So so quiet you can hear a pin drop. Being by the river was great, we got to see new baby goslings and watch people go by on kayaks. The place is very peaceful, and right down the road from a few different winery’s! The neighborhood wasn’t the most vibrant part of town, but it had its own atmosphere and views on the drive were breathtaking. Also good thing to note—the next door neighbor has a beautiful Great Dane who likes to pace the dividing fence and sometimes barks pretty loud and gets excited. Great dog, on an electric fence, but just for anyone who has reactive dogs or sensitive dogs, definitely something to consider.

Top guest favorite

A view from a window showcases a scenic country landscape. Red barns and small animal enclosures are visible along the gravel road. Green fields stretch into the distance under a clear blue sky, framed by the contrasting checkered curtains.

Farm stay in Penn Yan

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Barn Loft Living

HeatherRating, 5 stars2 months ago

We LOVED our stay! Kelli is such a sweet and helpful host! She had farm fresh sausage and eggs waiting for us. We love watching the turkeys every morning. If you are looking for a farm quiet Very clean place to stay this is it! We will definitely be back!

Show all

Vacation rentals in Potter

Top-rated vacation rentals in Potter

Vacation rentals for every style

Popular amenities for Potter vacation rentals

Other great vacation rentals in Potter

Destinations to explore