Lake house vacation rentals in Conesus Lake

Absolutely Beautiful! There was every amenity and beautiful decor! The house was prestine! One of the best airbnb’s we have stayed in! Looking forward to going again , hopefully staying longer this time! Highly recommend!!!’

Denise our host was absolutely warm and accommodating.. she went out of her way to drop off an extra heater when the place got colder (upstate NY in Oct). I’d happily recommend this to everyone! The kitchen was well stocked and we didn’t have to go anywhere to find Cuttery and dishes

Christopher and his team were great to deal with. Since we live locally we had requested a pre- booking visit to see if the property would meet the needs of our group, Christopher was very responsive and accommodating of our request. Our stay was off season and did not involve lake activities therefore the area was very quiet. There was ample parking, we were able to park 7 vehicles ( small to mid size SUVs) in the driveway with ease. The lower level family/game room with the lake view was amazing, we spent most of our time in this space. We loved the house are looking forward to scheduling another visit.

We had one daughter graduating from UB and one from Brockport, and we rented Mandy's place as a midpoint location for our family to stay. Mandy was great to work with and the house is wonderful! Very comfortable and homey, with beautiful views. It had everything we needed/desired. The pictures really don't do it justice, especially in terms of the spaciousness of the place! We enjoyed the various large spaces to all be together, as well as the ability to find a quiet place to be on your own. The pool table was a big hit with everyone, and we really enjoyed watching a movie together in the home theater one night. It's a very private, but also very convenient location. Harrington's produce market and cafe is a great place to get a sandwich and/or a bowl of soup, and is literally 2 minutes away. And downtown Batavia is only about 10 minutes. Our only problem was that we didn't have enough time to fully enjoy all that Mandy's place has to offer! We would love to get back sometime!

This Airbnb was the perfect fall getaway! We visited the lake to soak in the autumn vibes, and this spot exceeded our expectations. There was plenty of room for our group of five, and the host’s recommendations made our trip even better. While the area is known for summer fun, I think fall might be the best time to visit. We had an amazing time exploring the charming shops, cozy restaurants, and stunning waterfront spots, plus the nearby vineyards are a must-see. Can’t wait to return next year when the leaves are changing again—absolutely loved our stay!

Marisa’s place was absolutely beautiful! It was so much better than expected! Plenty of space for our large group, the kids were obsessed with the secret room and we all loved the views. It was rainy most of our stay but we were still able to hang by the lake and make some s’mores! So convenient to town and all the other things to do in the area, would definitely stay again!

Beautiful home right on the lake! House was clean and spacious.

Our family wanted a special place to celebrate our Mom's 70th birthday and this place was AMAZING. It has charm, convenience, comfort and a spectacular lake front. We will definitely be back, so grateful for such an enjoyable weekend!

This was a great opportunity for me and my siblings to remember the time when our parents had a cottage at Conesus Lake. I was only 2 so I enjoyed hearing their stories. It was great to connect and what a fantastic atmosphere! The weather was a little cloudy and rainy but when the sun came out it was beautiful. Inside the cottage was very welcoming and comfy too. The neighbors were kind too!

The host was very friendly and accommodating when we had a bump in the road with our reservation. Everything worked out perfectly and we were very happy with our stay.

We stayed with extended family at this beautiful lake house for my daughter’s RIT graduation. It was the perfect place for us to hang out, entertain and celebrate her accomplishments. The common rooms were spacious which made it nice for conversations. The view of the lake was better than the photos. Everyone loved it.

This listing was all we could’ve asked for and more! We booked Toby’s lake house for a last minute MDW getaway and it exceeded our expectations. The property is steps away from beautiful Conesus Lake. There is so much natural light in the living room — drinking coffee in the morning looking out onto the lake was a dream. We were having difficulty figuring out how to use the grill and Toby responded right away. Can’t say enough good things about our stay! Would love to come back again.

By far, a fantastic place to stay! Would stay again. Immaculate, provided amenities not expected, modern & quiant, Immaculate & comfortable beds! Beautifully decorated!

We had a beautiful and peaceful stay on the lake. Fishing off the dock was a wonderful experience for the family. The rooms were cozy and everything we needed was stocked in the kitchen and throughout the house. Easily one of our best stays on Honeoye Lake thus far!

We had a wonderful time staying at this cozy lake cottage! It was perfect for our party of 9 and we would definitely stay again! Highly recommend!

I really enjoyed my stay. Host was welcoming and attentive. The home was sparkly clean! ❤️ I would definitely stay again and try one of his other properties.

Jody's place immediately gave us the comfort of home, with beautiful decorations and eccentric pieces. I've been in many empty-feeling, hotel-esqe Airbnbs, but it felt like Jody was inviting me over as a friend. The patio was lovely. Highly reccomend.

I had a fantastic three-night stay at this charming, up-to-date cottage. It was cozy and welcoming, with a spotless bathroom with a roomy walk-in shower and stocked with plenty of fresh towels. The bedroom was comfortable, and I slept great each night. The location is easy to find, right off the main road, which was super convenient. I also enjoyed the fast Wi-Fi, nice TV, and the thoughtful touch of a Bose Wave radio with a selection of music CDs. Highly recommend for a comfortable and enjoyable getaway!

Beautiful view and nice, comfy home! We all enjoyed the pool table and punching bag in basement. It was really wonderful waking up to the view of beautiful Keuka Lake and we made some great family memories here. Thank you!

Our family absolutely loved our weekend at Justin's retreat! It was comfortable, peaceful and relaxing, with lovely views! We are hoping to come back this summer!

We had a wonderful stay and would recommend to anyone looking for some solitude and a beautiful place to enjoy a peaceful getaway. You can be in Naples, NY in 10 min or less for a few restaurants, etc. and Canandaigua is only 25 min north. Everything was lovely and just as advertised.

The home was just beautiful and the views from the deck were spectacular. The host was more than accommodating and very friendly. We would definitely rent again.

Just returned from our 4th visit to Jill and Mario’s absolutely beautiful house, and had another fabulous experience! Three things really stand out. First, the view of the lake and backyard is stunning. Second, the house is immaculate. And third, it is very thoughtfully well-stocked with necessities and kitchen items. We loved kayaking and enjoyed a fire and making s’mores out back. Jill and Mario are great hosts!

Our family of three* had a wonderful time and were quite comfortable here. The lake was beautiful; husband caught fish everyday; boat was fun. House was nice and quite clean; beds were comfortable. Batavia has good places to eat; drive to Rochester was pleasant. The piano was playable (though not tuned). Saw chipmunks and swimming muskrats. The only actual irritation with the home is the poor lighting in the common area (literally half the kitchen is unlit, and dining area is barely lit). It's lovely during the day because of skylights, but at night, it's annoying. * Requiring more privacy, personal space, and organization than most, I would not have been able to stay here with another family because: a) the second full bathroom is miniscule and opens into the common area, which would have caused huge anxiety for me, b) the kitchen had no space for unrefrigerated food storage, so the limited counter space would have always been a disaster area. But for the three of us, it was great.