Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Shelter Island Heights

This property was beautiful. The kitchen was perfect for cooking the dinner we had planned and the backyard was a beautiful scene to sit in and relax.

Spent a guys weekend at Ashley's place, and it was a perfect stay! Very much enjoyed and would highly recommend for a larger group of people looking to enjoy the area as a group

We stayed here for a week for our daughter’s graduation from the Coast Guard Academy. It was perfect. Great walk from the academy, all sidewalks, very safe area. The location is on a short dead end Street so you don’t have a bunch of cars driving by. The house itself is beautiful. It is bigger than it shows in the pictures. The yard is bigger and the deck is bigger than the photos show as well. The kitchen is incredibly well stocked. I can’t say a single negative thing about it or offer anything to improve. I’m still amazed at what we got for the price that we paid. And the hostess is wonderful. Very quick response time for any questions that we had.

We needed to get in a half hour early just to make sure we were dressed and ready for a nearby wedding. Juan could not have been more helpful or accommodating. House is very clean, as pictured, and is very nicely decorated.

If you are looking for a place to stay in Westerly, look no further! The home had all the amenities, and the dogs loved the spacious, fenced-in yard. The property was also close to downtown and the beaches in the area. We'll tell our friends about this place and gladly stay there again!

The host was very accommodating and adjusting to some of the changes my family had. The home is well enough stocked for like simple cleaning for the weekend and had plenty with extra linens and pillows. In side the house was fill with stuff to do with their amazing arcade room. They have a very big back yard and deck that’s is closed off. Overall, me and my family loved our stayed and definitely was comfortable.

We had an amazing Memorial Day weekend at Heather’s place! The house was perfect. It was clean, comfortable, and stocked with everything we needed for a relaxing getaway. Heather was a fantastic host, super responsive and thoughtful, making sure we had everything we needed for a stress-free stay. You can tell she really puts care into every detail. We couldn’t have asked for a better spot and can’t wait to come back!

Ian was terrific from the beginning. Always answered our questions . Th location of the house was fantastic and the home itself beautifully kept. Comfortable beds. Great layout and kitchen was spotless. I would not hesitate to stay here again. Our family really enjoyed it. Thank you Ian for making our stay a memorable one.

Abby and Curran are genuinely nice hosts. Their place is ideal for people who enjoy old homes, New England, and coastal life. The suite has a comfortable queen sized bed and an arm chair and sofa, perfect for reading and reflecting. The sofa also folds out into a bed. Chickens and rabbits welcomed us home after time away exploring Milford and the surrounding area. Americana at its best.

Viviana’s place is in a great location, lots of room and squeaky clean. We were very comfortable and felt welcomed. She was very proactive and responsive. Would come back again!

Nice little apartment definitely only enough space for 2 but that’s what was advertised so can’t complain about that. It’s a quit neighborhood didn’t even hear cars driving by. Simple but modern.

Erica was super nice , responsive and great person to do business with . The description of the unit was spot on . super clean bed was extremely comfortable . The shower was wonderful with a powerful water pressure . local to great restaurant's It was perfect for my needs, and will strongly recommend this lovely place. Best wishes Mike

Perfect for a weekend getaway with the pup! Place was peaceful and a short walk or drive to parks, beaches, or town. Aunt Clare was friendly and attentive. Would book again!

This is our second time staying at Jennifer’s home and we love it so much!! Jennifer’s home is beautiful, very comfortable and the decor is well done. The lawn and garden were prestine. We enjoyed sitting on the deck having a drink and sipping a cup of coffee. Our granddaughter loved the flowers and playing in the backyard. If she could she would've picked all of the beautiful flowers. Lol! This is a really extraordinary property and you couldn't ask for a better host. Jennifer is an amazing host!!

Our room was easy to access and enter. I felt like I had bombarded them with so many questions when I first arrived, but they were friendly and assured me it was not a problem and responded so quick. The room was very nice and I felt right at home. We asked for recommendations for breakfast and went to one of their recommendations. The food was delicious. I would highly recommend staying here, they were friendly and patient with all of my questions.

Second time we've stayed here, and just as wonderful as the first. Clean, quiet, and relaxing. All the basics provided in case you've forgotten anything. Really great place to stay as a home base while catching up with friends and family. Owners are very personable, and we enjoy chatting with them when we see each other outside. Will definitely be booking this place again anytime we return to CT!

I had an amazing stay. The house was nice and very clean with everything I needed. The host was responsive and got back to me within minutes to provide me with items I needed or answer any questions I had. Overall it was peaceful and I highly recommend staying here.

Clean and cozy cabin. Close to Mystic without being right in the thick of it. We enjoyed a night by the fire with a friendly local fisherman. It worked nicely for our short trip to the area.

The location was great it’s so peaceful and calm. Paul was great he responded in a timely manner and helpful. I look forward to returning and spending more time on the marina.

Was exactly as advertised

The cabin is lovely, with a great wrap-around deck overlooking a bucolic scenery complete with a river and cascades. Jessica was always helpful and responsive and the house is comfortable with a very well equipped kitchen which is unexpected in an Airbnb. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would love to return!

Second time staying at this cabin. Absolutely wonderful, peaceful and amazing place. Cozy and private cabin in a beautiful wooded area but super close to amenities and lots to do in the general area. Highly recommend if you’re looking to stay in Old Lyme. Thank you Keith!

This was the perfect, quaint little spot—clean, cozy, and thoughtfully stocked with everything you could need. The neighborhood was beautiful and peaceful, and having a safe, designated parking space was a huge plus. The host was incredibly sweet and respectful of privacy, making for a seamless and relaxing stay. Highly recommend!

Paul was very responsive. When we got there our room had not been cleaned. We got in touch with him and he immediately switched our room to a clean one which was fine. He was very apologetic and even brought us a bottle of prosecco. The place was cute, modern, and clean. Can't really walk to anything because it's off a busy road but it sits on the river with a beautiful view and many chairs to sit in and enjoy. We made a fire in the fire pit and cooked on the grill one chilly night. It was very nice. Close and convenient to many attractions in the area. We had our dog with us and she enjoyed it too.