Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Sag Harbor

A very nice and spacious house, quietly located in the countryside. In 5 minutes on foot you are at the water. The neighborhood is very quiet and in the morning you can hear many birds. Communication in advance was great. Even a toaster's wish was granted. The rooms are nice and the beds very cozy. There were three of us and we had good space. The kitchen is very well equipped with everything you need. There was even water available upon arrival. In the living room there is a large TV with Netflix.

Kristin was a great host. Everything was as described. Great location to shopping, restaurants and ferry in Greenport. We would definitely stay here again.

Ellen's place was wonderful! It had everything we could think of needing and even some stuff we didn't think about, but was nice to have. The backyard is wonderful for lounging and the beds were comfortable with great linens. The kitchen was so well stocked, as a serious home chef, I had everything I needed. Definitely recommend!

We needed to get in a half hour early just to make sure we were dressed and ready for a nearby wedding. Juan could not have been more helpful or accommodating. House is very clean, as pictured, and is very nicely decorated.

We needed a dog-friendly ranch style to home with three bedrooms and two bedrooms close to Sayville, where we would be celebrating Thanksgiving. I was lucky enough to find this rental which was clean, comfortable and ideal for our two-night stay. Adam was attentive and easily accessible via text. I would highly recommend this lovely home.

Book this house!!! We loved our stay here! In town for a wedding and we were so happy we actually got some time to spend at the house because it was so beautiful. The yard was so peaceful for coffee in the mornings and the view of the vineyard in the back was awesome. We brought our dog with us and he also loved the yard. We would definitely book this house again! Loved it!!

Alexis was a tremendous host-always available & great to interact with. The house was perfect, had anything & everything needed and was extremely comfortable. I would highly recommend her home to anyone visiting Shelter Island.

This will be the 4th time I have stayed at Theresa's beautiful home. We always have a great time. The home is clean, beautifully decorated and has everything one needs to enjoy themselves on vacation.I highly recommend it.

Nancy's place looked just as great as it does in the pictures. Very up to date, stylish, with all the comforts one needs. And looking out the large windows at the green backyard and fire-pit was spectacular, like it was from a home magazine. (Could not actually use the fire pit as it was rainy and cold to start, and then just chilly but I was too busy too). Nancy was extremely responsive to my questions and requests and even anticipated some I might have had. When I had trouble figuring out the locks when I first arrived she must have heard me struggling and was at my side after a few respectful minutes, much appreciated in the cold rain that day. Felt very comfortable and relaxed in the unit. The outside is very green with grass and forest and flowers; just walking around the neighborhood was therapeutic for me! Nancy also gave great guidance on local restaurants and shopping and it was excellent, just like being local. Thank you very much Nancy, a most relaxing and pleasant stay.

We stayed for our honeymoon - long weekend and first time Hamptons visitors. Very clean, organized and cozy space with nice decorations. All amenities listed were available. We really enjoyed the hot tub and firepit, very peaceful and private area. You should have a car to get around to restaurants, shops, and other outdoor activities. Lots of areas were walking, bike, and scooter friendly. There were so many beautiful views of the water!! Would stay here again, great value.

Perfect place for my husband and I, our twins and my dad to stay for a family wedding. Would love to come back and just explore the awesome area in the future!

Bright upstairs apartment with charm. It is actually bigger than it appears in the pictures. It was very clean in a very quaint and quiet neighborhood. The kitchen was fully stocked. It was very convenient to reach the desired Hampton neighborhoods. The exterior could use a power wash, but perhaps this is because we are just coming out of bad weather. One thing was missing, but KC responded immediately and had the item delivered. Communication was easy and relaxed. Thank you KC. We would stay here again.

Love my time at the wavecrest! Will definitely comeback and stay longer :)

We had a great time at Vanessa’s apartment with our dog. Vanessa was always responsive and very helpful along the way. Centrally located between all of the surrounding towns and the apartment had everything you needed! The nature of the complex does allow for some outside noise from neighbors but the apartment complex was very peaceful and well kept. We hope to be back in the summer time to explore more of the beaches!

I stayed with husband and two children at Jill’s lovely house and we had a wonderful time. Rain and all, we were able to enjoy her cozy home and relax by the fireplace. Jill’s recommendations for local places was extensive and so helpful! She was always very responsive and lovely. I highly recommend staying here and we can’t wait to come back!

Amazing views! Beach. Glamping. Camp store and great pizza place.