Monthly Rentals in Rainbow Cay

We had an absolutely delightful time staying at Serendipity on Eleuthera! Eleuthera is insanely beautiful and the villa is just perfect. The view is even more spectacular than any photo could ever convey, and we really enjoyed being able to walk right out back to our very own private swimming area. Swimming right there at the villa may have been our very favorite aspect of the trip! The time and thoughtfulness that Jodi and her family must have spent, carving out that little nook to allow for amazing access to the Caribbean, is so impressive :) The villa itself was also outstanding. So squeaky clean and filled with absolutely everything you need to have a comfortable stay. Jodi also allows access to the garage as well, where there are inner tubes, snorkels, masks, water shoes, etc. to make your stay perfect. Re: location, the villa is a ~8 min walk to Rainbow Bay Beach, one of the best on the island, and is centrally located, making it an easy drive to so much more. We will be back!

Casa Libre was a great spot for us as we explored the island. We love listening to the ocean. The bed was comfortable and the kitchen was fully stocked. Ed and Dan made us feel right at home. I loved having a washer and dryer and it was in a very quiet neighborhood. We explored lighthouse beach, Spanish wells, harbor island, and Gaulding’s cay. The Cove’s Freedom restaurant was our favorite meal. Definitely worth it!

We had a wonderful time at Toni & Alex’s house. They were always reachable and thoughtful throughout our stay, making us feel well taken care of. The seaside view is absolutely stunning, and the pool was perfect for cooling off after sunny afternoons on the terrace. The house is well equipped with everything we needed, and it’s just a short 5-minute walk to the fantastic Rainbow Beach. The location is ideal for exploring the island, with easy access to all key spots. We will definitely be back!

Outstanding place highly recommended! Beautiful setting. Very well designed home with comfortable indoor and outdoor spaces. Mike was super in communication.