Vacation rentals in Otterbein

Awesome place! Glad we were able to stay here. Very homy and comfortable with a great view of the lake. Enjoyed having coffee with a great view in the mornings. Would definitely come back!!

This cabin and the area surrounding was even more beautiful than the photos. It overlooks a huge canyon that was fun to explore. The cabin itself was great and had all the amenities we needed to cook great meals. Was very impressed by the cooking utensils in the cabin, the view, Anna’s responsiveness, and the overall “bang for your buck” when it came to this property. Our group had a fantastic time. Lots of spaces in and on the property to relax and enjoy nature. Would highly recommend if looking to stay in this area.

Such a beautiful, private location. Easy drive to gas, groceries, restaurants. The house is gorgeous and feels very fancy. Plenty of room for our extended family. Grounds to walk with chickens, ducks, geese, trees and pond. Play area for children. Thank you for a marvelous stay!

Our mini vacation here was awesome. Having the water right there was so nice and the hosts had anything you would need. I would definitely stay here again. They were so nice and accommodating.

Extremely helpful due to the situation on why we needed such a big house. House was clean, kept all the guests comfortable and able to stay busy with darts, pool table, and hot tub. Host always responded in a reasonable time.

This was our third stay and we will continue to keep coming back. So peaceful and love being in the treehouse. Love the short trails by the water and large yard to play in. Thank you Christine!

Maryanna has an absolutely wonderful home to stay in! I felt right at home and really appreciated how clean and tidy everything was. She was also really great at keeping in touch if I had questions and also had quite a few local suggestions as far as food! Would 100% stay again anytime and it would be a pleasure!

Our stay was very nice. It was easy to get into Lafayette and to Perdue. Parking was easy and they accommodated me dropping a few things off earlier than appointed check in. There weren’t any paper towels or regular coffee but everything else was great and well appointed. Plenty of room for a small group to gather.

We love this area of Indianapolis and we’re excited to come stay for a wedding weekend. It was in the perfect spot. Parking was easy, the house is old and charming. The hosts are extremely helpful and responsive! We would definitely stay here again when in the area!