Vacation rentals in Henderson Harbor

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Henderson Harbor

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

A spacious outdoor area features wooden picnic tables positioned on a stone patio, overlooking the serene water of Lake Ontario. Lush greenery surrounds the space, with trees providing shade, and a glimpse of the beach is visible in the background.

Cottage in Henderson

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Beachfront Lake Cottage - Kayaks, Prime Stargazing

Experience incredible sunsets over Lake Ontario at this beachfront and lakefront seasonal property. Watch the sun slip into the lake, then enjoy a fire on the beach and prime stargazing. Shallow water/ sandy beach, perfect for kids and launching kayaks. Plenty of space for activities on the lawn and beach. Play cornhole or bocce ball; use the shared kayaks and stand-up paddleboards; make your family and friends an amazing meal using the wood-fired outdoor pizza oven; relax and soak in the sun.

Guest favorite

The image displays a cozy interior featuring large windows that overlook a serene winter landscape. A comfortable seating area surrounds a fireplace, providing a warm focal point. A well-appointed corner is visible, ideal for relaxation and enjoying the scenic views.

Home in Three Mile Bay

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

1066 Hastings House

A romantic escape for no reason? Maybe a special Easter egg hunt for the season? For a small fee, I can fill plastic eggs, hide inside/outside for family fun! We welcome to the 1066 Hastings House, responsible 25 yr olds and up, 1-2 well behaved house trained dogs. Hosting, up to maximum of 5 guests. From the dining & great room, enjoy the sun rising. As the day draws to a close, snuggle up by the fireplace in the greatroom and enjoy the sunsets. Watch the lights of night wake up over the Bay.

Top guest favorite

A wide expanse of sandy shoreline is captured, with gently lapping waves at the edge. Lush trees line the beach, complemented by distant beach houses. The sky is overcast, casting a soft light over the scene.

Tiny home in Henderson

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Amazing Beach Getaway at a Tiny Beach House!

Experience and fall in love with tiny house living in our 1 bedroom 1 bath cottage. Located within walking distance to a beach access where you can enjoy and stroll the miles of white sand beach shoreline. The interior has a separate queen bedroom and bath, living space with queen sleeper, dorm fridge and microwave. The unique exterior boasts a large deck with a complete outdoor kitchen, living/dining space, useable shed with full size fridge and firepit. Hike, bike, swim, kayak and much more!

Guest favorite

Adirondack chairs in a light aqua color are arranged around a stone fire pit, offering an inviting seating area. A wooden dock extends into the calm water, surrounded by greenery and a clear blue sky, creating a serene lakeside view.

Cottage in Henderson

5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Stunning Lake-front Home at Snowshoe Bay

This stylish place to stay is perfect for group trips. It has 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and sleeps 11. The master bedroom is a balcony loft with a private bath that includes a deep soaking tub. Each bedroom and the living room have smart TVs. The high-end kitchen has everything you need for cooking or baking, including a dishwasher for clean-up. There is also an outdoor grill. Enjoy eating at the island in the kitchen, the 10-person dining room table, or outdoors by the firepit or on the deck.

Guest favorite

A serene view of a cottage resting on a rocky shoreline, surrounded by lush green trees. The calm lake reflects the building's exterior and nearby foliage under a clear sky. A small deck is visible adjacent to the water, offering potential access to the lake.

Home in Chaumont

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Sawmill Bay Getaway

Escape to your own slice of paradise with this 3 bed, 1.5 bath winterized cottage nestled on the tranquil shores of Sawmill Bay/Lake Ontario. Stunning lake views and the most amazing sunsets make this retreat perfect for family getaways or romantic escapes. We do not have a "beach" but have water access from the rock shore and are near public launches and marinas. Enjoy fishing, boating, kayaking, nearby restaurants, shops and a winery (across the street). Your Sawmill Bay Getaway awaits!

Guest favorite

An A-frame cottage is framed by lush greenery, featuring a dark wood exterior with a centrally located white door. An overhanging carport provides coverage for vehicles, while hanging planters add a touch of color to the entrance. A pathway leads to the cozy front yard.

Cottage in Sandy Creek

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 291 reviews

🌙 Olde Salem A-Frame Cottage 🔮 near Lake Ontario

You are steps away from witnessing the greatest sunsets along North Sandy Pond (across from Lake Ontario) when you stay at our relaxing, unique, and cozy A-frame - inspired by all things magical and earthy. Sit by the backyard fire, sip coffee by the electric fireplace, read a book in the bedroom nook, play board games, dance in the kitchen, and enjoy four seasons of nearby activities such as fishing, kayaking, boating, jet skiing, hiking, swimming, ice fishing, snowmobiling, and snowshoeing.

Guest favorite

Four wooden chairs are arranged around a firepit, located on a grassy area near a creek. Lush greenery surrounds the scene, providing a serene setting for outdoor relaxation and gathering.

Guesthouse in Ellisburg

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Retreat on South Sandy Creek

Enjoy private fishing access from your backyard on South Sandy Creek and experience world class salmon and steelhead fishing. You will have an entire apartment to yourself (unit attached to our barn) with your own private entrance stocked with toiletries and linens. 5 miles from beautiful Southwick Beach on Lake Ontario, there are limitless options close by for boating, kayaking, hiking, off-roading, snowmobiling, ice fishing and skiing! 18 min from Pulaski, very close to Tug Hill.

Guest favorite

A clear view of the peaceful waterfront is provided, showcasing calm waters reflecting the blue sky. A wooden dock extends into the water, surrounded by lush greenery, including a tree and neatly trimmed bushes, creating a serene outdoor space.

Cottage in Henderson

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Lake Cottage Perfect for Fall Summer & Fall Fun

Your waterfront getaway in scenic Henderson Harbor awaits. Now's the perfect time to enjoy all fall has to offer in Northern New York. Book a quick romantic getaway, family getaway, or spring trip! Our cottage has front-row seats to the most beautiful sunsets, a new crib dock giving easy access to boating & fishing, and nearly 100' of pristine waterfront for enjoying Henderson Harbor's waters. Whether it's calm and quiet to escape the daily grind or fun & excitement, we have it!

Top guest favorite

The guest room features two twin beds made with rustic log frames, accented by patterned throws. Light wood paneling covers the walls, and a ceiling fan hangs above. A small nightstand is placed beside one bed, with a lamp and decorative items displayed.

Guesthouse in Chaumont

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Peaceful Getaway

Kick back and relax in this peaceful space. Guest house has two twin beds, private bathroom, microwave, toaster, Keurig, small refrigerator. WiFi access, outdoor grill with outdoor dining and seating area all under a 16x24 pavilion. This property offers incredible views, fish jumping and canoe and kayak access. End your incredible day fishing off the dock with s’mores at the fire pit. Hunters and fishermen welcome. Plenty of parking so bring your motorized toys! See you soon!

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area features a comfortable leather sofa and armchairs surrounding a circular coffee table. Large glass doors open to stunning lake views, while a flat-screen TV is mounted above a modern fireplace. Natural wood paneling enhances the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Henderson

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Lake front •Year round hot tub•Gorgeous sunsets

Nestled on beautiful Lake Ontario stands this beautiful year round cottage designed in and out to give you a luxurious lake vacation! Come inside and sit by the fire and enjoy the stunning views with waterfront deck complete with a New 8 person hot tub that is available year round, gas grill, smokeless fire pit, outdoor dining area with automatic awning & lounging area. We guarantee you will not want to leave! Only a 5.5 hour drive from NYC! Pet friendly 🐶

Top guest favorite

A single-story house features a blue metal roof and large windows, surrounded by a grassy area. A wooden deck leads to a private outdoor space with blue chairs and a fire pit, while trees provide natural shade near the water's edge.

Home in Sandy Creek

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

The Henderson House

Welcome to our house. We offer 2 bedrooms both with queen size beds. The property is located within 5 miles of two marinas, along with The Elms Golf Club and is located on Lindsey Creek, that has access to North and South Sandy Pond, as well as Lake Ontario via canoe or kayak. Amenities include: washer, dryer , fully equipped kitchen, bedding, towels, wood . A great multi season property. We offer a one canoe for use. We also have wi fi and tv.

Guest favorite

A stunning sunset casts vibrant hues of orange and pink across the sky, reflecting beautifully on the calm surface of Lake Ontario. Soft clouds create a textured backdrop, complementing the tranquil waters that stretch into the horizon.

Home in Dexter

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Hazel's Lookout - relax with stunning sunsets

A perfect retreat for individuals, couples, or small families, our house boasts views of the most beautiful sunsets on the pristine waters of Lake Ontario. Whether you're looking for a peaceful stay or access to many types of adventures our house is a perfect location for both! . With ducks diving for fish right out the back door, you’re likely to spot a variety of wildlife, often including bald eagles, deer, and cranes.