Vacation rentals in Lake Mills

#301 Private Apartment in Historic McFarland House

*** Our 2nd Floor is being remodeled throughout 2025 adding 4 more units to the old McFarland House This newly remodeled unit is located in the attic of the Historic McFarland House, built in 1857 in the community that bears its name. Nestled in our small suburban downtown, this unit is perfect for travelers visiting the Madison area or nomads making a pit stop in the mid-west. Only 8mi to campus or a quick commute to the capitol, McFarland is an easy exit off multiple highways and interstates.

1898 Farmhouse on 75 acres - MJ's Farm

Nestled down a winding country road, relax and unwind on a traditional Wisconsin farm surrounded by a 2,296 acre Wildlife Area. Our farmhouse is licensed by Dane County & a short 20 minute drive to Madison! You will want a car so you can explore, the UW Campus, Allient Energy Center, WI State Capitol, Madison Farmers Market and much more. Relax, unwind, grill, play horse shoes or sit by the fire pit. Enjoy your privacy but know there is a farm manager close by and I am happy to help

Lake Ripley Getaway

This is the perfect place to unwind, located at the crest of a quiet circle, in a wooded lakeside neighborhood. Whatever you’re looking for, you can find it all in this beautiful and tranquil getaway. Vacationers can enjoy skiing, biking and exploring the gorgeous CamRock trail system. Lake Ripley, the sparkling gem of Cambridge, is loaded with fish for summer fun or ice-fishing. Shop our adorable downtown, with a thriving art scene. Our quaint little town is a slice of heaven in a busy world.

Entire Lower Level, Countryside Garden Suite

Welcome to our home! We have upgraded our Garden (lower) Level to host travelers much like ourselves and long-term guests. The view of our backyard is incredible! You will find yourself lost in the country, yet less than ten minutes from all the excitement that Madison has to offer. Along with a private drive and entrance, you will have 1,000 square feet of comfort all to yourselves. This property is perfect for a quiet getaway we all need from time to time. All designed with you in mind.

YurtCation

YurtCation is a relaxing getaway with lake frontage and nature trails. There is another yurt about 300ft up the same driveway. There are a total of two yurts and two homes that have access to the same 17 acre lake. Each yurt is off the grid and has their own queen-sized comfy bed, wood stove, Weber grill w/charcoal, fire pit, firewood, fresh water, canoe, and clean Porto Potty. Pet Policy: Max two - Must be in your sight and supervised at all times or $500 fine and check out immediately.

Waterfront modern cabin w/ kayaks

VERY romantic getaway for 2! Enjoy your own private dock, welcome to tie off your own boat or rent locally. Complimentary use of 2 kayaks. Beautiful modern riverfront cabin near Lake Koshkonong's eateries and entertainment. Soak in the gorgeous Wisconsin summer with water activities at your fingertips. The rest of the year take in the pristine wonderland views in our enclosed balcony. Only 30 minutes from Madison's world class culinary experiences, performance arts, sports & festivals.

Cozy Lake Cottage With The Best View & Pontoon!

Location, Location, Location! Incredible views! Retreat to this cozy Lake Koshkonong cottage with vaulted ceiling and southern exposure. Enjoy spectacular sunsets and views of the 10,000 acre lake from the north shore. Fish, hunt, boat, ski, swim, snowmobile, or simply soak up the sun and take in the view from this quiet retreat on a dead-end street. Fresh paint, bedding, and furniture make this little gem very comfortable. Great Walleye ice fishing right in front of this property!

The Poet's Palace, an upscale, downtown flat.

This modern, yet eclectic apartment, has all the comforts of home. The decor is clean and chic, with just enough quirk! Located in downtown Fort Atkinson, some of the best restaurants, shops, and pubs are just outside your door or within a short stroll. Outdoor recreation opportunities are abundant, with the Glacial River Bike Trail, Fort River Walk, and numerous parks also within walking distance.Try your hand at fishing or launch a kayak from one of Fort Atkinson's public docks.

Charming Milkhouse Cottage, minutes from Madison!

Welcome to The Milkhouse Cottage! Serving as an original milkhouse from the late 1800s on our pre-civil war farmhouse property, you will feel the timeless elegance of the original character and the beautiful french cottage decor. Perfect for couples, travelers, or business persons -- come and unwind in the scenic heartland countryside and rustic elegance, all with the convenience of location -- we are a quick 15 minute drive from the airport and all that Madison has to offer!

Vast Lake Koshkonong Views from Pier, Deck, & Home

Our 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom House is located directly on the shores of Lake Koshkongong. The back deck overlooks thousands of acres of lake with endless lake views. Just steps off the deck, one can enjoy the grassy landscape leading to the lakeside fire-pit. Then continue out onto the end of the 140 foot top notch pier. The pier (seasonally of course) includes a bench on the end and stairs into the water so that you can take a refreshing swim on our sandy bottom shoreline.

Studio on the Prairie Fen

Kick back and relax at the Studio! The Studio is a 400 sq ft unique suite in the lower level of our home. A private locked entrance opens up to a sunny space with great views of a wetland beyond the backyard. Private patio to enjoy morning coffee and the sunrise. A great place to unwind and enjoy nature's beauty! We have binoculars if you love bird watching, and bikes to ride or hike the Glacial Drumlin Trail just 0.1 mile from the front door. Lic LICHMD-2021-00621.

Rock River Rest quiet cottage 25 min to Madison

Escape the city to a cozy waterfront retreat. Nestled among centuries old Oaks along the Rock River, enjoy our 1920s cottage and private backyard directly on the river. Relax while watching wildlife out the picture window and listening to vintage vinyl or jump in the car for an easy commute to UW-Madison/Epic. The cottage is ideal for a romantic getaway, remote work or artist retreat. Located 30 min from Madison or a short drive from MKE + Chicago.