Cottage vacation rentals in Crooked Lake

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Crooked Lake

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A cozy cottage is depicted, featuring a welcoming front deck with seating under a shade structure. Stairs lead from the yard to the entrance. Lush greenery frames the property, and the nearby rocky pathway provides access to the water, enhancing the outdoor space.

Cottage in Middlebury

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 268 reviews

Stone Lake Cottage Middlebury IN Boat Fish getaway

Located on beautiful Stone lake in Middlebury, IN. Crafts Amish antique auction fish swim lake relaxing. Bedding, towels, and personals/toiletries are provided. 2 queens, 1 twin, 2 double beds. Includes 3 BR/4 baths (detached 3rd BR CLOSED in winter), room for 6-8, AC, Smart TV, streaming services , WiFi, fireplace, lake, pier, kayak, paddle boat, grill, fire pit, dishwasher, toys for swimming, fishing, and 5 miles from Shipshewana/Middlebury. Min primary guest age is 21. Motel hotel

Top guest favorite

A serene lake view is captured during sunset, with vibrant orange and pink hues reflected on the water. The surrounding trees frame the scene, while a private pier is visible at the foreground, inviting guests to relax and enjoy the natural beauty.

Cottage in North Webster

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Webster Lakefront Updated Studio with Pier & Deck

Lakefront! Simple, practical, purposeful lakefront cottage with pier. Ideal for those who dream of waking to a lakeview. Enjoy lake/boating activities, playing yard games, fishing along shore/pier, or just unwind while relaxing on the deck watching a sunset. See FAQ in Guest Access section Studio. Stairs. No beach area. No swimming at the pier. No smoking on property. Only registered guests permitted on property, no visitors. Located on the east side of the lake, quiet wooded neighborhood.

Top guest favorite

A welcoming entry features a set of stairs leading up to the cottage, flanked by white railings. A decorative American flag is displayed on the front porch, surrounded by landscaped areas with pebbled ground and greenery.

Cottage in Rome City

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 234 reviews

Lakeside Sylvan-Lake Rome City Cottage

Welcome to Sylvan Lake in Rome City, IN. Sylvan Lake is an all season ski lake wonderful for all boating, fishing, skiing, tubing, wave runners and even a swim from the dock. You have 60 feet of lake front with two docks to bring your lake toys or rent a pontoon for the day/weekend or week. Full size kitchen, washer and dryer, two big smart tv's with cable and wifi. Small shed for storage, large deck, canoe for 3, fire pit & gas grill.Wedding, family, golfing or weekend away? Lakeside Sylvan!

Guest favorite

Sunlight filters through trees, casting gentle shadows across the lush lawn. A serene lake reflects the sky, with a canoe and dock visible in the distance. A swing set and seating area are positioned to enjoy the tranquil views.

Cottage in Howe

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 684 reviews

Cozy Nest - Lakefront, Dock, Kayaks, Pet Friendly

The Cozy Nest is an adorable three-bedroom, pet-friendly cottage with amazing views of a quiet, no-wake lake. Enjoy the stunning view while your cares melt away in the hot tub. The kitchen is fully stocked and ready for your use. Fiber optic wifi will keep you connected. There are two bicycles available for exploring the surrounding countryside as well as a canoe, 3 kayaks, and paddle boat to use on the water. Shipshewana is a quick 15-mile drive away through beautiful Amish countryside.

Guest favorite

A hot tub bubbles gently on a spacious deck, framed by lush greenery. Comfortable seating arrangements, including a hanging chair and dining area, are positioned to enjoy views of the lake. String lights add a touch of ambiance against the clear sky.

Cottage in Wawaka

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 355 reviews

Cozy Lakefront Tiny Home w/ Hot Tub

Included in your stay are: 2 kayaks 2 paddle boards Hot tub - available year round Paddle boat Fishing poles Gas grill w/ propane Fire pit Private dock Pickle ball paddles/balls for Martin Kenney Memorial Park *See amenities section for complete list. This cottage rests on the shores of Diamond Lake in Wawaka, IN. The lake is a quiet 10 mph lake perfect for fishing, kayaking, swimming or just enjoying time away. Come enjoy this relaxing retreat with great views and a cozy atmosphere.

Guest favorite

A quaint cottage features a pink façade with a covered porch supported by white columns. Lush greenery surrounds the property, with large trees providing shade and a well-maintained garden visible in front. Barn-like structures are seen in the background.

Cottage in Topeka

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews

Honeyville Cottage

Escape from the hustle of daily life in the heart of Amish country. Step into this quaint cottage and leave your worries at the door. Soak your cares away in the cast iron claw foot tub or relax on the patio watching the neighbors horses run. Bicycles are available for a stroll through back country roads. Play games around the kitchen table. Take a trip into town for fresh baked Amish goods, a traditional Amish dinner or shopping. At night you can grab a blanket and lay under the stars.

Top guest favorite

A serene view of Long Lake is presented, showcasing expansive waters under a clear blue sky. The surface of the lake reflects the sunlight, while lush greenery borders the landscape, offering a tranquil atmosphere conducive to relaxation.

Cottage in Pleasant Lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Long Lake Cottage

Long Lake Cottage is on a 10 mph lake that is a pretty peaceful spot to relax. Enjoy bonfires, kayaking, fishing, and grilling at our place. Long Lake is a part of the Pigeon River chain that you can kayak along through multiple lakes. Less than 10 minutes from Angola (Trine University, Pokagon State Park, groceries, etc.). We hope you enjoy your stay! We have a strict cancellation policy, but we will refund you 100% of your stay if you do need to cancel 14 days before your arrival.

Guest favorite

A tranquil lake scene at sunset is captured, showcasing the water's mirror-like surface reflecting soft hues of pink and orange. Lush trees line the horizon, and hints of clouds add texture to the serene sky.

Cottage in Howe

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Peaceful, relaxing and cozy vintage style cottage

Nestled in the heart of Amish country, this charming cottage has everything you need for a relaxing getaway at the lake. Vintage style cottage features a private back yard with a fire pit, deck with a picnic table and grill for your enjoyment. Free firewood, two kayaks and canoe for boating on the no wake lake. The property is located across the street from the lake, it includes lake access and a shared pier. Visit Shipshewana and enjoy all this quaint small town has to offer.

Guest favorite

A serene lakeside view is captured, showcasing a boat dock equipped with a covered area. Paddle boards and colorful floats are visible on the calm water, with lush trees framing the scene. The surrounding landscape includes residential homes and clear blue skies.

Cottage in Wolcottville

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 99 reviews

Cozy Lake-Front Cottage on Westler Lake

Our lake front cottage is on our property as a guest house. You have access to kayaks, paddle boards, paddle boat, fire pit and floats. This cottage is newly rebuilt with a beautiful view of the lake. Boat dock available. If you have access to a boat, there are five lakes in the chain. You can be on the lakes for a couple of hours and never see the same thing. The bunk bed in the 2nd bedroom is two full beds. Clearance for top bunk is slim. Recommend children for top bunk.

Top guest favorite

A serene lakeside view is presented at dusk, featuring calm water reflecting soft colors of the sunset. A fire pit is positioned on a grassy area adjacent to the water, while a wooden dock extends into the lake, perfect for leisure activities.

Cottage in Albion

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Beautiful Skinner Lake View Cottage

Private vacation home with a beautiful view of Lake Skinner. Waterfront access for fishing or taking the paddle boat out (seasonal). This cottage has all the basic amenities to make your stay comfortable. From the warm fire place to the spacious deck and 3 seasons room, you can enjoy this place anytime of the year. The full kitchen makes this place perfect for a week long getaway! A short twenty minute drive to Auburn and under an hour drive to Fort Wayne and Shipshewana.

Guest favorite

An open concept living area features a light-colored sofa paired with a wooden coffee table. A decorative plant sits on the table. In the background, a dining table with white chairs is visible along with modern kitchen features, all illuminated by natural light.

Cottage in Syracuse

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Sunny channel front cottage on Lake Wawasee

Huge open concept with plenty of light. Take a .23 mile walk to our private beach, lounge by the pier, or rent a boat and head to the best sand bar in the Midwest. Lake Wawasee is the largest natural lake in Indiana. It offers great skiing and fishing, 3 restaurants you can enjoy by boat and the best sunrise/sunset boat cruises you can imagine. The house is only 5 minutes from either Syracuse or North Webster to check out the local shopping boutiques and farmers markets.

Top guest favorite

The charming stone cottage is framed by a blossoming pink tree in the front yard. A well-maintained path leads to the entrance, showcasing the natural stone facade and numerous windows. The surrounding greenery enhances the inviting exterior of the home.

Cottage in Rome City

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Stone Cottage on Kerr Island

Welcome to the little stone cottage on beautiful Sylvan Lake. We are located in Rome City, IN. This adorable house, originally built in 1930, was remodeled and completely renovated in 2018. The updated kitchen features tiled backsplash, gas range, oven, and fridge. There is a microwave and Keurig for your convenience. The bedroom has a queen-sized bed, a small wardrobe for hanging clothes, and a dresser. The bathroom features a tiled shower.