Monthly Rentals in Compass Cay

Cute house. Great location, everything is just a few minute ride away with a golf cart. Highly recommend!

Centrally located allowing easy travel to the north and south end of the island. Very close to the airport. This is one of four units in a single one story building. Interior was simple but sheets and bed were very comfortable. Interior was better than the pictures showed. Washer and Dryer were great to have for cleaning clothes and towels. Had fast WiFi and a functional kitchen. No surprises. We needed a couple things during our extended stay and the host was very responsive and helpful. Nice porch area out front along with a patio area halfway to the beach. Beautiful beach with chairs and kayaks available for use. Fresh water spigots next to the door to easily wash off the sand when you return.

If you want something far away from mass tourism, this is a perfect place. You Will be around Bahamas people with a great peace of leaving. The area is beautiful and Margaret is the person to be in touch with to organise your trip and activities (swimming pigs, kayak, rent a car, etc) :)

Anita and Theo were incredible hosts. This was our honeymoon and our first time to Staniel Cay. We initially booked at SCYC but they did not have availability for our entire trip. Next time we visit we may skip the yacht club and go straight to Anita’s. The bed was probably the most comfy bed we’ve ever slept in. It’s super clean and they have everything you would need for an extended stay. They graciously helped us with transportation which we felt was above and beyond. Additionally we rented their golf cart and boat. Both which were far nicer than anything at the YC. Although the island is small and we’re in good shape but will tell you that a golf cart is truly going to be the way to see the entire island. Thanks Anita and Theo! See you again soon :)