Vacation rentals in Carthage

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Carthage

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A two-story building is positioned amidst a grassy yard, featuring a staircase leading to a spacious second story deck. Lush greenery surrounds the premises, while a few trees stand nearby, contributing to the tranquil rural setting.

Apartment in Fairland

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

The Nigh Place, Studio Apartment, King Bed, 55"TV

Welcome! Enjoy the country views from your exclusive second story deck or relax inside of your isolated, spacious, and peaceful studio apartment. Complete with a King size bed, loveseat, recliner, 55” TV, full kitchenette, walk in closet and private bathroom. Updated, clean, and secure. Arriving late? Solar and motion detector lights along with a lighted electronic key pad for ease of access. Please note there are 23 steps with rails on both sides and a landing area half way to the apartment.

Superhost

A comfortable gray sectional sofa is accented with a bright yellow decorative pillow. A navy blue coffee table sits centrally, contributing a modern touch. A framed art piece adorns the wall, while light wood flooring complements the spaciousness of the room.

Apartment in Greenfield

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Quaint & Walking Distance to All The Fun!

Our place is recently renovated and walking distance to all of the amazing amenities Greenfield has to offer. Within half a mile of our place you will find beautiful Riley Park, a FREE community Splash Pad, a just renovated public pool with waterslides, the historic Old Log Jail Museum, the famous James Whitcomb Riley Boyhood Home and Museum, and all of the locally owned eateries and boutiques of downtown Greenfield. Start or end your days with a walk on our serene 5.6 mile paved Pennsy Trail.

Guest favorite

A charming historic home with a two-story structure displays a combination of deep purple and mustard yellow siding. An American flag hangs from the porch, which features decorative woodwork and inviting entry steps surrounded by landscaped gardens.

Home in Greenfield

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Updated Historic Home, in the Heart of Greenfield

A one-of-a-kind historic gem located three blocks from Downtown Greenfield on Main Street and only a 35-minute drive to downtown Indianapolis. Enjoy the entire downstairs of this completely upgraded late 1800's wooden frame home featuring all original wood flooring and beautiful antique furniture pieces. Filled with modern luxuries; including 3 flat screen tv's with streaming services included, an upgraded 8 burner gas stove, dishwasher, full-size washer and dryer, and outdoor barbecue grill.

Top guest favorite

A two-story blue house is highlighted, featuring a welcoming front porch with two chairs. The well-maintained yard includes neat shrubbery, and a tree provides shade nearby. A driveway is visible to the side, along with the hint of surrounding residential structures.

Home in Rushville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Small Town Charm

Have fun with the whole family at this stylish place. This home was completely renovated in 2024. Perfect for family time, catching up with local friends and family. Also pefect for business travel or temporary housing for relocations to the area. Our city offers small town charm often found in rural midwestern towns. The home features 4 bedrooms with 5 beds (1 king, 2 queens and 2 twins) 2 1/2 baths, full laundry, very large, open living/kichen and dinning space and 2 cozy outdoor spaces.

Top guest favorite

A charming red guest house is visible, set against a backdrop of lush trees. The structure features an upward sloping roof and a large garage door. Green grass lines the gravel driveway, leading towards the entrance.

Guesthouse in New Castle

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

Private Country Loft Guesthouse with Chic Decor

Private guest house on 30 acres of beautiful country ground. Guest house includes high speed WiFi through T Mobile, garage parking (one standard vehicle), fully equipped kitchen, washer and dryer, endless views and lots of wildlife. Enjoy sitting on your private back porch and watching birds, deer, wild turkey and more during the day and sipping your favorite wine by the private campfire at night. Owners live on the property and are happy to make recommendations for activities and dining.

Top guest favorite

A comfortable living area is highlighted by a caramel-colored sofa and two armchairs with decorative cushions. A wooden coffee table sits in the center, complemented by a woven basket and plants. Art prints hang on the wall, and a large TV is mounted nearby.

Home in New Castle

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

Entire Home with Modern Conveniences - New Castle

This home has been equipped with everything you need for a relaxing stay. Unwind in the evening while watching your 65” TV. The updated kitchen offers plenty of space for cooking dinner.The first bedroom features a King size bed and room darkening window treatments. The second bedroom offers a designated office space w/ high speed internet and a trundle bed. To start your day well, the bonus room offers a coffee bar with Nespresso and wellness area complete with treadmill and yoga space.

Top guest favorite

The two-story home features a covered upper deck with a flag, inviting outdoor space for relaxation. The exterior is clad in a combination of siding and trim, set against a grassy landscape. Stairs provide access to the upper level, enhancing its welcoming appearance.

Farm stay in Fairland

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Waters Edge Racing Stable

Built in 2013, Water's Edge is a secluded, warm, & rustic 2nd story home sit above a horse barn turned epic R.E. office w/ perhaps the best view in the county! Enjoy the sunrise over the pond from the 12'x30' deck, or the animals grazing to the south. The Farm Stay is entrmt central boasting of a lg open living room/full kitchen with a wood pellet stove for your enjoyment on those cold winter nights! Not to mention catch&release fishing, corn hole, tetherball, volleyball, or bonfire!

Superhost

A fully remodeled camper is positioned in a spacious grassy area, surrounded by trees. Several chairs are arranged around a stone fire pit, providing a cozy gathering spot. The camper's exterior features large windows and an awning, enhancing the outdoor experience.

Camper/RV in Knightstown

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 79 reviews

40' 5th Wheel Camper

40 foot fully remodeled camper. The camper is parked on the back of our property behind our privacy fence over looking a forest valley. Enjoy the country setting while still having 150 mb wifi. 5 minutes to Knightstown, 45 minutes to Indianapolis and 10 minutes to I70. Camper has a tankless hot water heater, dishwasher, washer and dryer. Living room couch folds down into a bed and room for an air mattress. The middle of the camper has a futon that folds down into a bed.

Top guest favorite

An expansive yard is featured, bordered by mature trees and lush grass. A concrete driveway leads to the charming bungalow-style suite on the right, showcasing a well-maintained exterior with traditional features. A neighboring structure and a natural landscape complete the tranquil country setting.

Guest suite in Indianapolis

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews

THE CUMBERLAND/Indianapolis, Indiana

"Country Living with City Convenience" 15 minutes from the town of Greenfield 15 minutes from The Academy Volleyball Club 23 minutes from Gainbridge Fieldhouse / Lucas Oil Stadium / Convention Center 25 minutes from downtown Indianapolis 28 minutes from Ruoff Music Center 29 minutes from Indianapolis Motor Speedway 30 minutes from Clowes Memorial Hall (Butler University) 31 minutes from Indianapolis International Airport 35 minutes from Grand Park Sports Campus

Top guest favorite

A well-maintained exterior view of a modest structure featuring a green roof and light-colored siding. The entrance is framed by a wooden deck with a railing, accompanied by landscaped stones and decorative elements, including small sculptures and shrubs. Natural light highlights the inviting entryway.

Farm stay in Greens Fork

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

A country night under the stars!

Get away from it all when you stay under the stars. Join us for a peaceful country stay, close enough to drive to nearby shopping and dining, and far enough to hear the crickets and see the stars. Your cozy place will include a kitchenette, coffee pot, microwave & TV. The dining area inside or on the attached deck, full size bed & full bath with shower. Only 3.9 miles from Interstate 70. Should you choose to use 100-foot zipline to exercise your pet.

Top guest favorite

A spacious bedroom is featured with a plush area rug and sloped ceilings. A large bed, adorned with a textured blanket, is accompanied by a comfortable armchair and a side table. Natural light filters in through a window, illuminating the room.

Guest suite in Greenfield

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 201 reviews

Greenfield CountryCottage-minutes to downtown Indy

Beautiful, relaxing country cottage room is a perfect place to stay for your business trip or vacation. We provide clean and comfortable furnishings, along with a kitchenette and coffee bar. You will have total privacy, including a private driveway and entrance. Relax on the balcony with your morning coffee or after a busy day. Our room is located on a 2nd story with a private stairway to the entrance. Special discount on stays 3 days or more!

Guest favorite

A small green house stands among trees, featuring a wooden deck at the entrance. Two white chairs are situated on the patio, and the structure has multiple windows that allow natural light to fill the interior.

Tiny home in Indianapolis

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Cozy Tiny House Nestled in the Trees

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. In a charming tiny house surrounded by trees and birdsong, you can unplug and relax without going too far off the beaten path. Only a 15 minute drive from downtown, we’re conveniently located between Fountain Square, Irvington, Beech Grove, and Wanamaker. Curl up with a cup of tea and a good book, sit on the patio and watch for deer, or take a walk around our fledgling 9-acre permaculture farm.