Vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Peaceful apartment space in beautiful farm house

Our lovely farmhouse is minutes from Lake Lemon, Griffey Lake, Indiana University & many spots in Bloomington. Conveniently not far from I-69, we're 20 minutes away from Nashville. This is a basement apartment with private bedroom, private bathroom, large living/dining area, & kitchenette. Shared front door & ~10 steps inside main floor. The ranch is 50+ acres with 8+ acres of woods for hiking, pastures with cattle, a heated pool & patio area, & a beautiful front porch looking over the ranch.

Hideaway Hollow - A Woodsy Getaway

Hideaway Hollow is a cozy, private guest suite in Bloomington, Indiana. Located on the north side, it is just fifteen minutes from the heart of downtown Bloomington, IU stadium, and an hour from Indianapolis. Nestled in the forest, the suite offers a covered porch with a private entrance, a spacious living room, a kitchenette, and a master bedroom with a full bath. Suitable for up to four guests, come to enjoy the serenity of country living, the comforts of home, and easy access to the city.

Cataract Lake Getaway - Cozy Lofted Cabin (#3)

This brand-new cabin on a private road is a serene setting perfectly blending rustic charm and modern comfort. Only a half-mile from Cataract Lake, quick and easy access to boating, fishing, kayaking, etc. awaits! Numerous nearby attractions are sure to provide great experiences (Cataract Falls, Exotic Feline Rescue Center, Terre Haute Casino, state parks, brewery/winery, local shops/eateries, etc.) And of course, simply enjoying time in and around the cabin itself is a fulfilling getaway!

Waterfront getaway *cozy & peaceful*fishing*swings

Welcome to your perfect lakeside escape! This newly renovated boho-style cottage offers a peaceful retreat. Featuring an open loft layout, a covered porch, and a large deck overlooking two small serene lakes, this home is designed for relaxation. Enjoy evenings under the Pergola with swings or gather around the hillside firepit for unforgettable nights. Its location also makes it easy for you to get around. You're just: 10 min to I-70 hwy 20 mins to the airport 30 mins to Indy Downtown

Maria’s Haven

Welcome to “Maria’s Haven”💕 A beautiful cozy home in the heart of a beautiful small town. This home belonged to my mother, Maria, who passed away in 2020 to breast cancer. This home was truly her “Haven”. Take a walk to the local diner, museum, Gosport playground, local shops, or to our delicious Amish bakery. We are also just a few miles from the popular “Hilltop” restaurant as well as McCormicks Creek State Park. Our mission is to make you feel like you never even left home. ☺️

The 1938 Barn

The 1938 Barn is located in the ❤ of Covered Bridge Country in Parke County. You will love the rustic charm of this converted hay barn built in 1938. Come relax by the camp fire or explore our many Covered Bridges and local State Parks. The farm also hosts Henry's Market, a market garden providing fresh meat and vegetables which makes summertime an excellent time to visit! Please note: There is NO WI-FI, NO CABLE. We have a selection of DVDs. Limited cell service, AT&T works best.

Captain Bill's Guest House/seasonal swimming pool

Welcome to Captain Bill's Guest Lodge at Cagels Mill Lake! This gorgeous home offers modern amenities in a countryside setting. Perfect for bikers, boaters, fisherman, and anyone looking to enjoy lake life. Our guests are welcome to join us poolside at the main house. Our private pool is open only to us and our listed guests at our two Airbnb units. We're located seconds from the boat ramp and a short drive to Cataract Falls and Lieber State Park. Pool is seasonal.

Modern Nashville Home in the Woods

Welcome to Plāhaus - a modern home nestled in the woods of Brown County. Plāhaus is a space of solitude and relaxation for anyone wanting to enjoy the beauty of Brown County, without the typical log cabin decor. Enjoy the gorgeous view from the balcony, spend some time around the firepit, and venture into Nashville to check out the unique shops and restaurants. Come for a family getaway, a romantic retreat or simply to clear your mind from the everyday stresses.

Strawbale Bungalow. Bloomington Indiana USA.

Art and book filled. Located in Bloomington Indiana. My 1920s bungalow includes two guest bedrooms with queen sized beds, down comforters, feather/down pillows, line curtains and private bathroom. The guest area also includes a garden porch, private entrance, living room and, dining area with microwave, small refrigerator and handmade maple table. NO KITCHEN. The bathroom is between the bedrooms and includes a Toto washlet bidet and EO toiletries.