Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Whitefish Bay

This is our second stay at Jeff’s place and it is one of our favorites. It’s always very clean, the back yard is beautiful and perfect for dogs, and Jeff is fantastic with communication. The house has a great layout and super comfy furniture, and there is plenty of seating and a fire pit outdoors. Just an absolutely fantastic stay.

Beautiful home, spacious, with a very fun basement for a "movie night." The hosts were incredibly welcoming and helpful, and the entire home was clean and tidy. Loved the stay and would be happy to be a return guest here!

Kristen was a great host. I had a question about the heating and she got right back to me. The house is cute and perfect for our family stay. I would have preferred a 2 night minimum stay as we had to book an extra night we didn't use

Nice house with a great backyard for our dog and attached garage! Lots of room. Convenient location. Minimal furnishings/decor, but comfortable. No shampoo/conditioner, bar soap or body wash, kitchen staples (no foil, plastic wrap, oil, coffee, etc.) so if you're staying for any length of time, you might want to plan ahead and bring your own. Otherwise a good value for the money!! Vijay was great to work with and very responsive!!

Marla’s place looked just like the pictures; everything was clean and well stocked. We were visiting family in a neighborhood nearby, but the house is conveniently located near many restaurants and right up the street from the airport. The basement with the pool table was a win for entertainment at the house.

Joanie was an amazing host excellent communication beautiful spacious home..10/10 definitely will book again!!

This was our 2nd stay at this beautiful home. We love the time we get to spend at the house, watching movies (they have so many great options via Roku and DVDs & VHS too!) or playing games (many options at the house too), or reading on the back porch which is so beautiful and peaceful. Tom was very quick to respond when we had a question about the fireplace. We highly recommend!!

We spent a weekend at Jennifer's excellent rental while in the Milwaukee area for a sports event. She was a great communicator, super helpful and responded immediately each time that I reached out with a question. This rental is more spacious than the photos depict and super quiet despite the in-the-city location, located on a gorgeous peaceful one-way street with upscale historic homes. I would love to return to stay here again!

Great location with easy in-and-out access. Entering through the side door was seamless, with no flights of stairs to worry about. The lock system was simple to use and made check-in a breeze. Mike was responsive, and the space was exactly as described. The shower was fantastic as well! I would definitely stay here again — I loved it!

The place was exactly as advertised and the host provided all of the information we needed about the place and about the area, like parking instructions, without having to ask. If you're not from the area, you should know it gets loud late on Fridays and Saturdays, but we knew that and it didn't bother us. I would definitely recommend, the location is very central to most things you'll probably want to be doing in Milwaukee.

Thank goodness for places like this! Spotless, comfortable, just the right amount of amenities. Garage parking! Food & drink options within walking distance.

The location is great for walking to many parks and restaurants and is in a nice and quiet neighborhood. It was very clean and the host was responsive to any questions. My family and I thought the beds were very comfortable! It is a duplex but we didn’t hear the neighbors at all and didn’t have any issues with parking.

We’ve stayed here three times since December 2024 and have three more booked through August. This is our home away from home when we go back to visit our Milwaukee friends. Great host!!

Would definitely return to the property!

The place was clean, quiet, and safe. It is an amazing location if you are traveling to go out on trails and see nature. Our son left behind a book and the host offered to mail it to us! Very kind of him. We had a great stay.