Lake side house rentals in Turtle Lake

My 3 daughters and I came for a quilting getaway. The house was spectacular and clean. So peaceful and private. The perfect place to recharge. We all enjoyed listening to the birds in the morning off the lake. There were a few boats to watch as they fished. The deck seating was ideal for having some meals

Had a great stay & can't wait to go back again!

Thanks for having us! Beautiful view!

My wife and I just stayed at FishTail Lodge! It was Perfect! Pictures were exactly how the cabin appeared. Tom is an amazing host who responds to any question quickly. Check in and Check out was easy. The Cabin is in a Wonderful location and is spotless. There is so much to do within the property itself. From Relaxing at the fire pit, to the screened in porch or on the pontoon. There is a pool table, darts, and ample games and movies. The beds are amazingly comfortable. We have rented other cabins in the past, I would say, without question, this is the best place we have rented in every aspect. If you are reading reviews in order to help decide if this is the place. . . This IS the place! Rent it! You won't be disappointed.

We had an amazing stay! The home was spotless, cozy, and beautifully designed—exactly like the photos, but even better in person. One of the highlights was definitely the hot tub—clean, private, and perfect for relaxing after long days of exploring. The host was incredibly welcoming and responsive, providing clear instructions and thoughtful touches throughout our stay. Everything we needed was there—from soft towels and comfy beds to a well-stocked kitchen. The location was quiet and peaceful. Whether you’re here to unwind or adventure, this spot is a perfect home base. We wouldn’t hesitate to come back and highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a relaxing, comfortable, and memorable stay!

This was a home away from home with all the amenities we needed & then some. Reisa was a very attentive host. We are hoping to stay again at the end of summer when we visit again. The massage chair was definitely a bonus! Didn’t get a chance to use the kayaks but for sure at our next visit.

This place was absolutely perfect for our large family! Everything that was described as the resort having was available to us. Kayaks, paddle boards, boat tubes, lots of toys for children, outdoor play area for kids, great pool platform, and dock. We loved the location. It was peaceful and quiet, but so many things to do. A wonderful outdoor fire pit with wood available for burning and roasting sticks. The kitchen was fully stocked with all appliances and cooking utensils that we needed. We literally would not have needed to bring anything. We also brought our own boat up and the access to put in and get to the B&B was simple and easy and it worked out perfect for us. The only possible thing I could think of is if you are wanting to get to the big side of the lake versus the smaller peaceful one be aware of the size of your boat, as it may not fit under the train bridge. This place was absolutely PERFECT for our large family. You will not be disappointed with this place! HIGHLY RECOMM

Our stay was everything we were looking for plus some additional amenities! It's hard to find a place that can accommodate our dogs and feels safe for our 2 year old but this cabin was fun and relaxing for everyone. We will definitely be coming back

Perfect property with a wonderful host! Cabin was immaculate and has everything you could need. Nicely appointed with several special extras. It is a very scenic and centrally located property right on the lake. We saw deer, loons, and various wildlife every day. The sunrise over the lake can't be beat! Our group of four had plenty of space and all were quite comfortable there. We plan to go back! Exceptional!

Our stay at Keith’s was great! Views of the water were wonderful. Check in was easy with the keypad, kitchen was well stocked, Keith was quick to respond when we couldn’t find things or needed help with the grill. As noted in the pictures and his description, one of the bedrooms does not have a door on it, and the walls don’t go all the way up to the ceiling. It gets all the noise of the living room/kitchen but it worked for us. We loved the kayaks and Keith even had a child life jacket! The water quality in the lake varied - not as appealing as I was hoping for swimming on our first two days but we had fun kayaking around the lake and after it rained on our last night, the water was much clearer the day we checked out. Note that part of check out is put all towels and sheets into the washer and start the washer. I don’t love that because inevitably I realize one has been forgotten and then have to figure out how to stop the cycle and add an item, but this is minor. Great stay!

Pretty sweet spot. Very low-key which is right up our alley. Will return again 👍

Stayed here for our daughter's college graduation weekend. It was great for what we needed for the weekend and close to the campus. The neighbors of our location were super friendly. We would stay here again!

This cozy little cabin was such a perfect little slice of heaven! Once the clouds cleared, we had the most amazing views of the sunset over the lake through all of the large picture windows that covered the entire lake side of the cabin. The gas fire stove was perfect to warm up the cabin quickly in the mornings as we were there when the temps got down into the 30s at night and we opted to keep the heat low overnight. If you plan to do meals in the cabin, take note that there is limited space for pantry items-easy access mobile storage that can be stowed on top of the refrigerator and under a bench is highly recommended. Additional tips would be to bring several gallons of drinking water, as the well has (at of the time of this review) unresolved hydrogen sulphide gas that causes the water to smell like rotten eggs.

It’s a roomy lake cabin with lots of spots spread out or get together! It’s has a beautiful view of the lake and very comfortable beds and furnishings! We enjoyed our time together with our granddaughter. There are plenty of places around the area to explore 😀

A perfect and serene spot to relax, while still being very walkable to downtown Hayward.

We loved our stay here and everything was exactly as we had hoped. We highly recommend and look forward to staying again.

The house has stunning views and was absolutely perfect for our annual fishing trip. The lake access was a bonus. There was plenty of space for everyone, the beds were comfortable and seating was ample. I would absolutely utilize this home again.

Quaint and beautiful cabin setting. Lots to do around the area especially for avid climbers, hikers and nature explorers. The sauna was a blast and the beds were extremely comfortable. The aframe was very cozy and a great place to unwind and unplug. We will definitely stay here again when we’re in the area. Kayla and Josh were extremely responsive and flexible.

Fantastic meet in the middle location for an annual cousins weekend! Love having 4 separate sleeping arrangements, 2 bathrooms, fantastic kitchen and coffee bar! Not to mention the spacious dining room table for meals and playing games. Spacious upper-level deck with the cozy and easy gas fire pit! Paver steps to the lake with another beautiful landing and wood fire pit! Good restaurants, shopping and winery with live music all so close make it so simple to enjoy a little of everything. Fantastic, responsive, and helpful host just minutes away with messages on the app. Can't wait to repeat our visit. We felt at home and LOVED our stay at the cottage on Lake Wissota. Thank you!

We really enjoyed our stay. The property was beautifully decorated, clean, and had everything we needed. Loved the plants! We hope to stay again.

We came up for trout fishing, and Jim was helpful by having a map ready and some of the local spots within minutes of the place, and great fishing. Having the owners close but still very private with the way it is all set up was nice, able to walk out the door and wander the trails. Jim had firewood all split dry and ready to go even kindling perfect for the nice fire just out the side doors. Great stay and great host.

This is one of my favorite cabins I’ve been to. The only downside being that you can’t really walk down to the water. Everything else was fantastic. It was the perfect size for two of us and our dog. Lots of wildlife: we actually watched two snapping turtles lay their eggs by the fire pit. The surrounding towns are very cute, and Interstate Park is great for hiking.

We loved our stay! It's a charming and clean house in a perfect location! They have everything you need for a relaxing stay. The porta potty was very clean and smelled great! We woke up to deer and turkeys. We will be going back for sure!

I book a home rental every year, at least once, and have had varying experiences. Brian's place had all the kitchen equipment/supplies that are sometimes missing. The lot is flat so we can see the kids in the lake from the porch and the lake is nice and shallow for swimming with our little ones. We had plenty of room and the bedrooms are set up for the perfect sleeping arrangements for our crew. It was easy to get in and Brian was always available when something came up. We appreciated Brian's suggestions for dining and touring and hope to do more of that next year. The only feedback that we all agreed upon was the couches are very slouchy toward the back and the chair was almost unusable. Maybe some foam under the cushions would help? The other seating was beautiful and very comfortable. It felt homey and was decorated very nicely. We hope to book again for next year!