Treasure Cay vacation rentals

Christy was an amazing host and was very responsive to communications. The property was hygienic, the amenities abundant, and in pristine condition. If you're looking for some time in paradise, the area is amazing and will fulfill your needs.

Great unit with nice furnishings and great view of the pool. Beautiful beach. Very comfortable place to stay!

The place was very clean. It felt like a home away from home. Great area. I was not ready to leave.

We packed a lot of family into this house, and it worked. We had a great time. The sunroom provides a quiet escape from the great room. The guest house out back became the spot for nappers in the afternoon. The walk to Ocean Beach was so easy that the big kids were comfortable going back and forth solo within a day or two (to go between family at the house and on the beach). The kitchen worked well for us. The basic dry goods (spices, oil) helped us throw together dinner for a hungry crowd within minutes of arriving. Overall, GTC was chill and lovely, and this house was the perfect home for our visit. Billy and Erin were friendly and helpful, making it that much better throughout.

We loved our stay! The location is absolutely beautiful as the house is just a 30 second walk from the beach. Martha was wonderful and helped us get a rental car. The house is very clean, probably one of the cleanest Airbnb homes I’ve been to. I was surprised to see there was no information left of detailed restaurants, outings, etc. We basically had to figure that stuff out by googling, which is fine but this is something that stood out as something that could have helped. If you rent here, you will definitely need a car and we didn’t know this until we got there. Other than that, the location is 10/10 if you are looking for true beauty and peace.

Great location with exquisite views. Very well decorated and stocked. Prefect spot to enjoy the island.

We had an incredible stay at Tucked In on Abaco Island! The house was wonderful—clean, well-designed, and surrounded by stunning water views in every direction. It felt like the perfect island escape. Our host, Matt, was fantastic—friendly, responsive, and full of great tips and local recommendations that enhanced the trip. Whether we were relaxing at the house, exploring the island, or just soaking in the views, everything about this stay was memorable. I would 100% recommend Tucked In to anyone looking for a peaceful, scenic getaway in the Bahamas. We can’t wait to return!

We really enjoyed our stay here. The house was walking distance to the beach and a very short golf cart ride to a beach we called "The Point." The king size beds in all the bedrooms were really appreciated. Geoffrey was very informative and responsive to us if we needed anything. The water pressure was very weak in the entire house. This was likely out of the owner's control, but it did make showering and doing dishes difficult. The kitchen could also use some bowls (there were none), baking sheets, and a few other cooking utensils (spatula, cooking spoons). It would also be nice if there were beach chairs for renters' use. We made it all work with what we had though. The dock at the house was large and had deep water, so it was perfect for our boat! All in all, we had a great stay at this very nice and clean home.

Paul’s Airbnb was absolutely fantastic! The place was spotless, beautifully maintained, and located in a stunning beachside setting. The comfort of the home made it easy to relax and unwind after a long day on the island. Paul was an exceptional host—proactive, thoughtful, and incredibly helpful. From the moment we booked, he provided great recommendations for food, groceries, transportation rentals, and ferry options, ensuring we had everything we needed for a seamless stay. His hospitality truly made a difference, and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend staying here—thank you, Paul, for making our trip so enjoyable!

This condo was just perfect! Beautifully decorated and clean! Thank you Heather for going the extra mile for us! We really appreciate you and will no doubt be back!!

My stay at this Airbnb was fantastic! The condo was clean, cozy and beautifully decorated. The Ed and his wife were extremely accommodating and provided great recommendations for local attractions and restaurants. The location was perfect, close to many shops and cafes. I had a wonderful experience and would highly recommend this Airbnb to anyone visiting the Marsh Harbor, Abaco Bahamas area.

Alan’s condo is very convenient and the dock was right outside the door, with dock lines available for use. Everything in the unit was fresh and new. I would highly recommend, especially if you come by boat, or plan to rent a boat from Treasure Boat Rentals.

The pictures do not do this place justice with fantasic views views from any window! Well furnished and very comfortable. The staff were all very friendly and accommodating. Would highly recommend for a nice relaxing beach vacation stay!

We had an amazing stay at Matthew’s beautiful condo in Treasure Cay. It was super clean, comfy, and had everything we needed. The beach is literally just steps away – white sand, clear water, and barely anyone around. Great spot to relax and unplug. Matthew was friendly and helpful too. The pool area and the bar/restaurants were also steps away, with great service. Would definitely come back!

super awesome place right on the best beach in the abacos. walk or golf cart to everything. rent a center console from dive guana. Paul was great from start to finish and we hope to get back there soon.

Had a great stay. Vinisha was helpful and flexible with our changing schedule. Comfortable bed and fully functional and clean bathrooms and kitchen. Would definitely return and recommend

Great spot, walking distance to the beach. Well stocked with kitchen supplies for cooking in. Having the golf cart makes getting around much easier!

Great location near the pool and beach. Very clean and well appointed villa. Fabulous host! The Host was proactive (sent us the rules and check-in instructions several days prior to our visit, so we didn’t have to ask), and was very responsive to any questions we had (he responded within minutes). We’ve booked several Airbnb rentals and this, by far, was our best experience.

We LOVE Treasure Cay and Benjamin’s place was perfect for us to stay in for our annual family vacay. It was clean and conveniently located to everything! Benjamin is a personal, friendly and very accommodating host. We look forward to returning g!

The location of this Airbnb was perfect! Right in treasure key, just steps away from the beach. Tara was extremely responsive and helpful. If you need ANYTHING, ask Tara. She made our stay effortless and memorable. She had a driver meet us at the airport and brought us to the house (Raymond). Some of the friendliest people I have ever met!!! Make sure you check out Cafe La Florence across the street! Food is amazing 😊 Can’t wait to come back in the future! Tip: Bring a good amount of cash with you, no ATMs on the island.

My sister and I came for a much needed girls trip. This stay was so relaxing! The villa had everything we could have needed during our stay. It was so beautiful! Comfortable and quiet. The beach is stunning and the pool area is great on breezier days. Communication with the host was fantastic, including willingness to help book other services. We appreciated the little touches to welcome us. Thanks for a wonderful stay!

We had an absolutely wonderful stay at Treasure Cay!!! The house was nice and clean, had a nicely stocked kitchen for cooking, and was a short walk from the (gorgeous!!!) beach. We were there toward the end of November and it was a quiet neighborhood which is what we prefer. We took some snorkel gear but appreciated having more sets there as well as life vests for four. Our host gave tips before we got there about the area attractions which was helpful. He was also quickly responsive to any questions we had. When we inadvertently left the lights on in our rental car and had a drained battery Brian was understanding and helpful and soon had someone show up with a charger. It's a laidback area with friendly people, we spent hours walking and sitting by the beautiful water. Check out Florence's Cafe, and take a ferry or boat to some of the nearby cays. We explored Green Turtle and Elbow Cay/Hopetown lighthouse. The long dock in Cherokee is also worth visiting. 10/10 recommend!!!

Sharon was very responsive. The villa is exquisite. Gorgeous view of the teal waters of the Sea of Abaco from the deck. When we arrived we had no issues with self check-in and getting acquainted to the property. The house is extremely well-appointed. It is fully equipped for cooking for large groups and has higher end appliances and a wine fridge! Don’t bother bringing spices as there is a full spice drawer! The crew did a fantastic job cleaning as the rooms are immaculate. Each shower had a bar of Dove soap still in its box and other amenities. For the area, only about half of the restaurants have reopened since Hurricane Dorian so a stop in Marsh Harbour for provisions is a must. Great stay! Great hosts.

Was here for 2 months and it was very enjoyable. Great place. Comfortable and peaceful. Had one problem the first day and Jeffrey andMyummi were right on it and it was fixed promptly. Comfortable house with all the amenities. I will be back. Thank you. Barbara Finelli