Vacation rentals in Potter Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Potter Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

The living area features vaulted ceilings, providing an open feel. A sectional couch and armchair are arranged around a central ottoman, with a dining table nearby. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, offering views of the outdoors.

Home in Mukwonago

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Relaxing Lake House Getaway on Phantom Lake

Located on the lake with access to both Upper and Lower Phantom lake. Directly next to the public boat landing for easy access to the water to enjoy time on the lake. This newly furnished 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home is the perfect space to enjoy the lakeside views and everything you would need for a comfortable stay! Each room has a view of the lake to enjoy at all times of the day. Stamped concrete patio with gas fire pit to relax outside. Close to many things that might bring you to the area.

Top guest favorite

A spacious outdoor deck is featured, overlooking a lush green backyard. Visible are various plants and garden elements, along with a patio umbrella. Stairs lead down from the deck to the garden area, providing access to the vibrant surroundings.

Guest suite in Waukesha

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Tucked Away

For those in need of a "home away from home" while on the road working or just passing though on your travels. This private, quaint backyard parking/entrance mini apartment located in Waukesha's "Historic District" is for you. Enjoy large outer deck as weather permits. Stairs are required outside to enter. Walking distance to lively downtown area. Easy access from this location to Madison (65 miles) and Milwaukee (12 miles). Located near Carroll University and Waukesha Memorial Hospital.

Top guest favorite

Adirondack chairs are arranged around a crushed stone fire pit, overlooking a serene lake at sunrise. The warm orange glow of the sun reflects on the water's surface, surrounded by a misty atmosphere and silhouetted trees.

Cottage in Mukwonago

5 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

Charming Phantom Lake Cottage

Come relax at our cottage located directly on Phantom Lake and not a channel. This 2 bedroom, 2 bath, plus sleeping loft area home is comfortably furnished and a perfect space to enjoy all lake life offers year round. Free public boat launch located nearby with our private pier/dock and anchored swim raft available for use on a seasonal basis along with multiple kayaks and paddle boat on site. Attached composite deck and crushed stone fire pit area are perfect spots to enjoy the outdoors.

Guest favorite

A modern great room features a leather sofa paired with a plush recliner, both accented by decorative pillows. A wooden coffee table sits on a patterned rug, while a bar area with two stools and wall-mounted artwork enhances the space. Natural light is provided by recessed lighting.

Guest suite in Wind Lake

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Secret Garden Getaway

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway in the lower level private garden apartment of our family home! Includes full kitchen; large great room with big screen TV, sleeper sofa, air hockey, and foosball table; large patio outside surrounded by beautiful gardens; 2 bedrooms with king size beds and private wooded views; generously sized bathroom with full bath. A mere 30-40 minute drive from Lake Geneva, downtown Milwaukee, and more! Come enjoy your stay at our garden cottage space!

Guest favorite

The open kitchen features modern appliances, including a dishwasher and sink with a spacious countertop. Natural light fills the adjoining living area, which is equipped with a large smart TV and comfortable seating, creating an inviting space for relaxation.

Townhouse in Waukesha

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Cozy 2BR charm | Big Yard, Fire pit, Replenishing!

Cozy gem sleeps up to 5. Renovated Interiors w/ large balcony overlooking serene yard. Enjoy an eastern sunrise during your morning coffee, or a starry night next to the warmth of a fire. 1 mile from 94 - 20 minutes from Milwaukee. Fully stocked kitchenette. Gas burning stove/oven, microwave, coffee maker, full size fridge/freezer, in unit washer/dryer, wifi, smart tv, wireless printer, private large balcony w/ heater for cooler nights. Perfect space for a couple or traveling profesional.

Guest favorite

The historic home, designed in a Queen Anne Victorian style, features a white exterior with intricate woodwork. Large windows reflect soft evening light, while a spacious porch offers a welcoming entry. The surrounding yard is open, with mature trees that provide shade and a natural ambiance.

Home in Wales

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Charming, Updated and Historic

This is truly a memorable, charming, and welcoming place to stay. You will have the home to yourself. You will love the warm feel, woodwork, and historical prominence of this home. It is very charming throughout and is on a large 1.5-acre estate size lot. The price quoted here is for 1-2 people and a 1 Bedroom suite with 1.5 Baths. Under this listing we can open up to three suites and accept six guests. If need more there than 2 guests and 1 suite we are happy to make you a custom offer.

Top guest favorite

A living area features a stone fireplace and large windows providing views of Lake Beulah. Comfortable seating surrounds a wooden coffee table. A dining table is visible, alongside decor elements that create a cozy ambiance. Natural light floods the space, enhancing the connection to the outdoors.

Home in East Troy

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Lakeside Getaway

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful, home on Lake Beulah. With the gorgeous lake and surrounding nature, you will feel you are hours up North, minus the long commute! Wake up and enjoy coffee on the deck. Bring your boat or grab a floaty and soak up the sun as you spend the day on the water. Wind down while you watch a stunning sunset from your own pier. Enjoy a show at the nearby Alpine Valley. Countless memories are just waiting to be made. Come play hard and relax even harder

Guest favorite

A cozy seating area features a large brown sectional couch accompanied by a light wooden coffee table. A small dining table with black chairs is present, with natural light streaming in through two windows. A lamp adds warmth, while a piece of artwork decorates the wall.

Guest suite in East Troy

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Mini Moon Hideaway

Central to both peace and quiet and lively fun. Nestled in a small lake neighborhood with lots of fresh air and foliage. Take a morning walk on the neighborhood stretch to Lake Beulah and rent a paddle board/kayak for the day. Ride the train around the city or unwind on a hike through Kettle Moraine State Park. Ski or catch a concert at Alpine Valley. Make your way to the charming East Troy Village Square for Spirits and a bite to eat. The adventure and relaxation is endless...

Guest favorite

A pontoon boat is docked beside a wooden pier, reflecting the soft hues of a sunrise on the still waters of Lake Tichigan. A single chair is positioned near the water, inviting relaxation while taking in the serene lakeside view.

Home in Waterford

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Lakefront Cottage, Cozy Modern Farmhouse ~Dog OK

Our modern farmhouse-style cottage on Lake Tichigan is fully renovated. RARE, featuring two en-suite bathrooms - say goodbye to waiting times! Our cottage offers an idyllic escape with stunning lake views from every room.. Sleeps 8, pet-friendly, fully stocked kitchen. Enjoy shared lakefront, pier, and pontoon rental (May-Sept). Perfect for groups—check our profile to rent both cottages on the same premise! 30 mins fr. Alpine Valley & Rock Snow Park 30 mins fr. Mke 1 hr fr. Chicago

Top guest favorite

A tranquil outdoor area features a wooden deck with comfortable seating and a small table. Lush greenery surrounds the space, leading to a serene lake visible in the background under a clear blue sky. A canoe rests on the shore near the water's edge.

Cottage in Burlington

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 78 reviews

The Butterfly Cottage

Your summer get-away is perfect at The Butterfly Cottage on Honey Lake! Relax and enjoy the serenity of the lake and all the natural beauty of the season! This is a cozy cottage on Honey Lake, just 4 miles from downtown Burlington and 13 miles from Lake Geneva. Alpine Valley for concerts, fishing on Honey Lake or nearby Browns Lake as well as shopping in Lake Geneva are the highlights of the season! There are hiking/walking trails all around as well as rustic roads to explore.

Top guest favorite

The historic Italianate farmhouse displays a light brick facade adorned with large windows. Lush greenery frames the entrance, where steps lead to a front door flanked by decorative lanterns. Potted plants add charm to the inviting walkway.

Farm stay in East Troy

5 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Historic Johnston Home,1868 Farm/Romantic Getaway

Following a 3 year restoration, this farm property is ideal for a couple's romantic getaway. Built in 1868 by the Johnston Cookie Company family, the Italianate farmhouse has relaxing areas with country charm outside and is steeped in old world elegance inside. The Historic Johnston Home is in the Kettle Moraine area of WI with hiking, biking, kayaking, boating and snow skiing minutes away. Step back in time, relax, unplug and rejuvenate!

Guest favorite

A serene seating area features two light-colored armchairs and two matching ottomans arranged around a small wooden side table. A potted plant sits atop the table, complemented by a standing lamp nearby. Natural light filters through a window adorned with sheer curtains.

Home in Burlington

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews

Charming Retreat Steps from Lake & Downtown Gems

Experience timeless charm in this 1901 home adorned with modern décor, nestled within walking distance of parks, coffee shops, the serene lake, and sought-after wedding venues. Immerse yourself in the allure of nearby apple orchards, skiing adventures, live concerts, diverse dining options, scenic nature trails, tranquil lakes, and renowned breweries in the heart of "chocolate city USA." Your perfect getaway awaits!