Monthly Rentals in Plum Island

We loved visiting the Beach Cottage on Benson! Amy and Jay were perfect hosts and made us feel welcome. The movie theater and back deck were very cool and the cottage was clean and included everything you will need.

Rosemary was a pleasure to do business with. She was quick to respond to any questions or requests that I had. Her home was comfy & spacious. The next time I book with her, I've since learned how accommodating she is & will pack minimally. There are plenty of toiletries provided in the bathroom, some outdoor patio chairs stacked so no need to bring the camping chairs I had packed! She even had beach towels which I missed on her amenities (it's on there, my fault for not reading that part!) which was convenient because I won't need to pack those either. She had a washer & dryer, any kind of kitchen item you could need, the cutest coffee & tea bar w/ a Keurig. Her home & hospitality exceeded my expectations in every way possible! My only input (which I hate to even mention as it wasn't an issue for us!) would be that the living room ceilings are low so be cautious if you're over 6ft tall altho I'm unsure of the actual height of them. I would eagerly rent from her again, Thanks Rosemary!

Charming, picturesque. Clean and lovely to stay in. Would stay again!

We had a wonderful time at Kathleen's place. The location is absolutely perfect. You're close to town but it's also peaceful and relaxing when you're sitting on the deck in the back. The bedroom has an amazing view of the lake. My favorite part was waking up in the morning and seeing that view. Kathleen was always responsive and even went out of her way to let us know things like there was an umbrella in the closet on a rainy day. She was so thoughtful and kind. We felt right at home and definitely plan on going back in the future.