Vacation rentals in New Buffalo

My spouse and I stayed the night at the Creekside Cottage it was perfect for us the kitchen was clean and perfect open concept we kayaked, made a fire, roasted marshmallows, then went in and ended the evening with unsolved mysteries we look forward to staying again soon this is our New go to spot for our PA trips. Host was responsive house was very clean and comfortable, more than enough room for a couple or family. It was close to shopping and we had Cracker Barrel for dinner which I highly recommend.

The house was huge. Beautifull and well stocked kitchen. Outdoor was peaceful and enormous yard where we could run and play. My whole family can't wait to go back.

Beautiful house that was even nicer than the pictures! Super clean and you can tell Matt takes pride in keeping this home in great shape. Definitely something for everyone, as both the adults and teenagers had a fun and relaxing time. The game room was a great bonus for the kids and we all enjoyed the perfect outdoor setting and clean hot tub. We brought our ATV and had a blast on all the trails reachable from right in the back yard! Matt was very responsive and we couldn't have asked for a better rental experience. Highly recommended and we definitely plan to be back!

I had an amazing stay! The place was exactly as described—clean, cozy, and in a perfect location. The host was incredibly responsive and thoughtful, making check-in seamless and the entire stay comfortable. I’d absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great experience!

Very spacious and pretty place for my sisters bachelorette weekend in! Kitchen was fully stocked. View and hot tub were the best part! The host allowed me to come extra early to decorate and responds within SECONDS with all my needs and questions. Thank you!

Perfect location for our family of 4 to stay during a wedding in the area

We had a fantastic stay! The view was absolutely breathtaking—one of the highlights of the trip. The house itself was spotless and beautifully designed, with thoughtful touches throughout. The added fire pit out back was a perfect way to unwind in the evening under a sky full of stars. Highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a peaceful and memorable getaway.

Very remote place we seen a lot of wildlife from the house and when we walked the trails..Dave and Barb were very helpful with everything thank you for sharing this beautiful place with us we hope to come back soon..

My friends and I had a great stay! Quiet, clean, and not far from downtown Lancaster and many other things to do in the area. Would definitely recommend.