Places to stay in Lumberton

Loved Shane’s place! Exactly what I was looking for. Wanted a quiet place for the weekend to relax that was peaceful and this hit every expectation!

Sugar Aisle was perfect for my family! The kitchen was fully stocked with every small appliance I wanted - meals were so easy to prepare with everything right there. The location was great and we could walk everywhere we wanted to go. The heated pool was a hit with the kids and they were in it whenever possible! They also spent lots of time on the 2 bicycles provided riding around the island. My family has been vacationing in OIB for 20 yrs and this was one of my favorite trips! I would stay here again in a heartbeat! Stephanie was incredibly responsive to any questions or concerns I had and the entire trip could not have gone better. I would highly recommend this as a great place to stay!

Our host gave us great instructions. The house and yard are very well kept, clean, and had everything we would need. We only had to get food. Spacious, safe, and the game room, grill, hot tub and fire feature were wonderful. We were able to host family we were visiting and enjoyed our stay. Highly recommend.

What a nice cozy place right on hole 1 of pinehurst #5. We watched golfers go by and we're loving the hustle bustle of any golf tournaments played at the course. The place is minutes away from the pinehurst clubhouse with 18 hole putting area and the famous cradle 9 hole course. We came for golf and enjoyed every bit of our stay but would have loved the place otherwise as well. Things were convenient around

This place is so comfortable and peaceful. We loved the screened in porch, spacious bedrooms and living area. Can’t beat the location for sure. We would definitely stay here again.

Richard’s place was absolutely wonderful. Very well kept, welcoming, and felt like home. It’s so comfortable you forget there’s no kitchen. I wish I had my 3 yr old niece; the toys, the books, the backyard playground… we loved it. The owner was very responsive and appreciates communicating. I loved it. The neighborhood is super quiet and peaceful, surrounded by restaurants and 2 lights from Fort Liberty. This is one you’ll enjoy.

We had a wonderful stay at this quaint poolside cottage while driving from Pennsylvania to Florida with our four dogs. It was the perfect overnight stop—clean, fresh-smelling, and super comfortable. The bed, sheets, and pillows were high quality, and we appreciated the soft towels and well-stocked coffee bar. The fenced yard was a huge bonus for the pups, and the flowers around the property added such a charming touch. Communication with Reeves was seamless. We only wish we could’ve stayed longer!

Check-in was super easy, and the host was very responsive throughout. The space was clean, comfortable, and had everything I needed for a short stay. One quirky note—the bathroom was almost half the size of the entire place, which made for an unexpectedly spacious shower experience! Overall, a smooth and pleasant stay.

Justin was an amazing host and very accommodating! His place was in a great location and was just like the pictures.