Vacation rentals with lake access in Fire Island

Find and book unique lake access rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated lake access rentals in Fire Island

Guests agree: these lake access rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cottage in Putnam Valley

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 260 reviews

Lakefront Cottage near Hudson Valley

Named in the Top 30 U.S. Lakehouse Rentals by Refinery29 in May'21, this beautiful, secluded cottage on pristine Lake Oscawana has breathtaking views. Escape the city and enjoy the fresh country air! Extra-large great room, cathedral ceilings, loft bedroom, kitchenette, bathroom, fireplace, wall of double-height windows with spectacular lake views. Central AC/heat, hardwood floors, private large deck with BBQ. Dock nestled in a cove where you can swim or paddleboard. Only 1 hour from NYC.

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Mahopac

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Lakeview Guesthouse with Sauna

Art and light filled spacious studio with panoramic views overlooking lake Mahopac perched on a steep hill. A short 5 min walk down the hill to swimming/paddleboarding/canoeing. Walkable to an on-the-lake restaurant/ dining/ takeout options + boba tea! Drivable to farm fresh food markets, restaurants and art museums. Cedar dry Sauna on property for use. Nearby towns and hikes include Fahenstock Park, Pound Ridge, Cold Spring, Beacon, Ridgefield, or walk up the hill to trails of Volz park!

Guest favorite

Home in Putnam Valley

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Waterfront Lake House

Your ideal fall lakeside retreat! Your ultimate foliage getaway! Immerse yourself in stunning, panoramic views of vibrant foliage from every room. Our lakeside retreat offers cozy, rustic charm, a full equipped kitchen, and direct access to nature. Relax by the fireplace or on the deck as you take in the breathtaking colors of each season. Steps from the lake for kayaking, fishing, or tranquil sunrise views. Book now to experience a unique escape surrounded by nature's beauty!

Guest favorite

Cottage in Chester

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 255 reviews

Updated cottage "Beriozka" on Cedar Lake

Originally from Russia (hence the name “Beriozka” meaning Birch Tree) I live in Stamford CT. About 7-8 years ago I’ve discovered Chester/ Essex area and fell in love. I’ve been coming here during summer to enjoy river rides, during winter just to see snow on the ground of old towns and needless to say during fall – when all the beauty of nature unfolds. Then came an idea to have an own place here and when an opportunity came to buy this small cottage on Cedar Lake I’ve jumped on it.

Guest favorite

Apartment in East Lyme

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 217 reviews

Brand New Direct Lakefront - Panoramic Sunsets

Completely remodeled lakefront apartment offering sweeping views of Pattagansett Lake. Open floor plan, fully equipped kitchen and massive deck make for an ideal gathering place to catch up with family or friends. All three spacious bedrooms offer comfy queen memory foam mattresses, fresh linens and UHD smart TVs. Two full bathrooms, high speed internet and in-unit laundry. Picturesque natural setting yet close to town amenities, restaurants, beaches, casino and area attractions.

Guest favorite

Home in Putnam Valley

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Magical Lake House in Hudson Valley

Tranquil Lakefront Retreat. Tucked among the trees, this newly furnished lakefront home offers private waterfront access for sun-soaked days, hammock lounging, and starlit dinners. Soaring 20-foot wood-beam ceilings and a stone fireplace highlight the living room, while every room boasts stunning lake views. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, office space, fire pit, and private dock. Paddleboards are available upon request, making this the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure.

Guest favorite

Cottage in South Salem

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

Serene lake front cottage 1 hour from NYC

Serene minimalist cottage directly on Lake Oscaleta with spectacular waterfront and Mountain Lakes Park behind. Quiet, isolated and lost in the trees, you feel you are in Vermont or the Adirondacks. Yet it's only 1 hour from Manhattan, 10 minutes from restaurants. Kayak, canoe, fish, paddleboard. Cottage is elegant, cozy and winterized warm and the lake is effectively empty in the fall/winter/spring. Please note: because of an asthmatic child, we cannot accept any animals.

Guest favorite

Home in Putnam Valley

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Crystal Wave LakeHouse

Make some memories at this renovated, family-friendly Lakefront Oasis! Kayak, Swim, Boat & Fish on your own Peninsula with Lake Frontage on 3 Sides of the Property! Views of the Lake from Almost Every Window! Included is an extra 600 sq ft cottage that has been completely renovated for your enjoyment with a pool table. Utilized as a gaming room & yoga studio! There is a pullout sofa as well for extra guests with a bathroom a few steps away in the main house!

Guest favorite

Cottage in Putnam Valley

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Private Lake House 1 Hour to NYC & Near Westpoint

Escape to this private lake cottage. Just 1h drive from NYC, near lots of skiing & hiking Thunder Ridge (30mi) Mt Peter (30mi) Victor Constant (20mi) Campgaw Mountain (40mi) Enjoy panoramic lake views, 86in TV, ample board games, 5-jet shower, and indoor jetted Jacuzzi tub. Short drive to Bear Mountain & West Point. Legoland is 45 min away Pets are welcome! WiFi is extremely fast and we have free electric car charging

Guest favorite

Home in South Salem

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

4 Seasons By The Lake 3 bedroom Luxurious Home

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay offering 3 full bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Master bath has Jacuzzi tub and separate shower and second bathroom has full tub, shower combo. Games and pool table, Samsung smart appliances in the kitchen and washer dryer. Serene patio area with BBQ grill next to brook 10 min walk to lake beach like setting, playground, and seating. Please ask about last-minute discounts!

Guest favorite

Home in Brewster

5 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Lakefront Home 5 Bedrms, 3 Baths

Create your family memories at this newly renovated Lakefront and family-friendly home. This unique direct waterfront home sits on 1.5 private acres! The home features 5 bedrooms, 3 new baths, dinning room that seats 12 and a spacious 1st floor vaulted great room with sliders to the expansive wood deck with sunrise views over the lake. The home has been newly painted and can comfortably accommodate 12.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Montauk

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Montauk Waterfront Cottage

Cozy and large two bedroom cottage steps from the edge of Fort Pond. Cottage is very private yet on shared grounds. Water views, fire pit, paddle boards, kayak, and good vibes. Also available are a 3 bedroom house and a 2 bedroom cottage. We do live on the property full time and enjoy making our space a safe and clean environment.