Monthly Rentals in Carroll County

This was our second stay at Horseshoe Hideaway and won’t be our last. The location is perfect for visiting family that live close by, the house is always clean and comfortable with everything we need and the neighbors are great (even brought us a basket of fresh eggs from their chickens, when we arrived). We can’t wait till next year when we hope to get back to Indiana for some more time on the river.

Such a peaceful and relaxing stay. I’m from Michigan and my partner is from Chicago! We drove up and loved how easy check-in and check-out were. Sitting by the creek felt like I was releasing old trauma, very healing and in tune with nature. It was my first time in the cabin. We adored the friendly cat by the fireplace. We also took a quick 45-minute trip to Indiana Beach and really enjoyed our stay!

Such a beautiful house with awesome history. It is obvious how much time and talent was poured into restoring this special home. Loved the arts and craft.

great location for peace and quiet, adding this to my list of must stays for future trips