Vacation rentals with a fireplace in West Milford

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated fireplace rentals in West Milford

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

A cozy living area features a stone fireplace as the focal point, with a flat-screen television mounted above it. Natural light enters through multiple windows, complemented by warm wooden accents and a spacious brown sofa adorned with a plaid throw blanket.

Cabin in Greenwood Lake

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 230 reviews

Get some R&R at the Rustic Retreat!

Welcome to The Rustic Retreat! This pet-friendly 2BR, 1BA cottage in Greenwood Lake sleeps 7 and features a renovated kitchen, open layout, fire pit, and shed bar. Walk to the lake or explore Warwick for shops, dining, and wineries. Enjoy summer kayaking, fall foliage, and winter skiing nearby. With WiFi, smart TV, and room for 6 cars, it's the perfect year-round escape. Experience the charm of lake life and the beauty of the Hudson Valley! IG @Rusticretreat22 Short Term Rental Permit #21-0422

Superhost

An open living area features a stone fireplace surrounded by natural light from large windows. A comfortable seating arrangement includes a light-colored couch and a wooden coffee table on a decorative rug. High vaulted ceilings enhance the spaciousness, with the kitchen visible in the background.

Home in Sterling Forest

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Aster Place

A beautiful and cozy home nestled in the Forest Hills section of Greenwood Lake, just over an hour outside of New York City. Boasting nearby activities in each season, including wineries, skiing and lake activities, this is a perfect year-round retreat. located 1/2 mile from our quiet community beach allows for a serene daily chill by the water. Town center is a short drive away, or 15 minutes from all that Warwick has to offer, you will enjoy this perfect setting for your lakeside getaway!

Top guest favorite

A modern living space features an artificial green wall, providing a natural feel. A sleek stone fireplace sits below a mounted flat-screen TV, which displays a serene sky. Soft seating options create a comfortable area for relaxation.

Home in West Milford

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

The Wine & Wilderness Hideaway [Cal King •1hr NYC]

*COZY UP IN OUR SPRING OASIS NOW! Nature’s haven, indulge in seamless spacious single-level living! Minutes away from Mountain Creek Spa & Water park, Warwick wineries, breweries, creameries & apple picking, scenic hiking trails, serene lakes, enchanting parks, & indulgent restaurants. Open concept, Chef's kitchen, Dishwasher, Washer & Dryer, 2 BR, 2 Bath, Cal King bed w primary BR attached to private Bath w soaking tub a retreat to relaxation. Huge patio & fireplace create everlasting memories

Guest favorite

Feet are seen dangling over a gently flowing stream, with a snowy landscape surrounding the banks. The cabin is glimpsed in the background, its vibrant green color contrasting against the natural elements and the soft glow of early sunlight filtering through the trees.

Cabin in Vernon Valley

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 425 reviews

Serenity Cabin, the historic waterfall cabin!

Escape to a magical paradise where the sound of a babbling stream & chirping birds create a symphony of serenity. Nestled on 18 acres of pristine wilderness, this secluded retreat offers endless opportunities for exploration & adventure. Wander along the streams and discover hidden waterfalls, all while immersing yourself in the breathtaking beauty of nature. Located 5 minutes from Mountain Creek, Warwick drive-in, Appalachian trail, & activities like goat yoga, horse riding, & TreEscape adv.

Top guest favorite

An A-Frame home is nestled among trees beside a gently flowing river. Warm lighting spills from the windows, illuminating the surrounding greenery. A cozy seating area with chairs is situated near the water, creating an inviting atmosphere for relaxation and connection with nature.

Cabin in Yulan

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Waterfront Cozy A Frame - Enchanting River Cabin

Enchanting River is a magical 2BR 1Bath A-Frame home secluded on 4 acres of serine forest nestled beside beaver brook running right below the house. This magical get away is just 2 hours from NYC. If you need a break from the hustle of every day life; this is the place to be surrounded by nature & let yourself unwind. As dawn turns to daybreak, there’s nothing more pleasant than being drawn from slumber by the sound of gushing water & bird chirps echoing through each surface of the property.

Top guest favorite

The living area features a modern design with light-colored walls and a cozy sectional sofa. A stone fireplace is surrounded by stylish furnishings, including a wooden coffee table. Natural light enters through large windows, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere.

Home in Sterling Forest

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 164 reviews

Beautiful Lakefront Haven! Beach, Views, Kayaks!

Experience summer at the Lake! Escape to this beautiful 3BR home in Greenwood Lake with incredible lake and mountain views. Enjoy our neighborhood beach to swim, free kayaks, and paddle board, or fish, just steps away! You'll love the huge deck, cozy living area, firepit, ping-pong, & well-equipped kitchen. Ideal for families and friends, this tranquil hideaway promises memories that will last a lifetime! Nearby boat marinas, wineries, breweries, restaurants, hiking, & more! 1 hour from NYC

Top guest favorite

A spacious living room features a large sectional sofa with soft upholstery, arranged around a brick fireplace. Floor-to-ceiling windows provide abundant natural light and offer views of the surrounding landscape. A ceiling fan hangs above, enhancing the open and airy atmosphere.

Home in Sterling Forest

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Coldwaters: hike, wineries, lake & mountain views!

Beautiful, comfortable home perched high on a hill across from Greenwood Lake, offering gorgeous views in a spacious, stylish setting, with lake & beach access. 5 minute drive to village restaurants & shops, and 15 to nearby Warwick and Tuxedo, this is the perfect setting for a relaxed & fun getaway no matter what your plans. You'll never want to leave, but you'll always remember you stayed! Book the guest house for an additional 2 bed, 1 bath apartment with kitchen! Permit #: 21-07657 A

Guest favorite

A charming log cabin is nestled among trees, featuring a stone patio with two green chairs. A wooden deck leads to a door, with a view of the lake in the background and a stone chimney adding character to the cabin exterior.

Cabin in Sterling Forest

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 434 reviews

"Cabinessence" on Greenwood Lake, 60 mi from NYC

"Cabinessence" is Year Round Comfort in a Chestnut Cabin by Greenwood Lake with a little touch of "glamping". Hiking, biking, strolling, paddle boarding, kayaking , canoeing. Restaurants, shopping, Drive-in movies, antiquing in nearby Warwick. Fall color, apple picking, gas fireplace (in season). Winter, ski, snowboard, tubing. Spring is watching the natural world wake up :) Hanging at the cabin- year round- is special here! Every season has its magic! ( + Covid Enhanced cleaning!)

Guest favorite

A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed adorned with decorative pillows. Wood paneling and a macramé wall hanging create a warm ambiance. Soft curtains frame the entrance, while two bedside lamps provide gentle lighting. A comfortable chair sits nearby on wood flooring.

Cottage in Highland Lake

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Rustic Chic Lake view cottage 50 miles from NYC

Cozy lake view cottage 50 miles from NYC. Nestled in nature with swimming, fishing , hiking and biking with beautiful lake views. 5 beaches to choose from. Lovely walking or jogging around the lake, Appalachian trail nearby. Highland Lakes is a very scenic, peaceful area easily accessible. 3 of the best golf courses in the US , Mountain Creek water park and resort minutes away.Apple and pumpkin picking comes fall. Beautiful village of Warwick NY is nearby with restaurants and shopping .

Superhost

An aerial view captures the ECHO cabin nestled among lush greenery, with private access to serene waterfront. The structure is framed by trees, highlighting the expansive lawn leading to the lake's edge, providing a tranquil retreat surrounded by nature.

Cabin in Wantage

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

ECHO cabin - lakefront peaceful modern house

ECHO cabin is quiet waterfront property with your private access to the lake, amazing views, wood burning fireplace, outdoor grill and fire pit Only 60 miles from NYC 15 min drive from Mountain creek ski resort, waterpark and downhill biking 5 min drive from tiny Sussex airport for private planes and skydiving 5 min drive from Sussex town, local restaurants, diners and Arco supermarket 5min drive from free tennis courts Local hand pick fruit farms, horse ranch and alpaca farm

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen features a round table surrounded by four wooden chairs. The walls are tiled in white, and a stainless steel stove is visible alongside a countertop with kitchen appliances. A vibrant painting of sunflowers adds a splash of color to the space.

Apartment in Warwick

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 399 reviews

Warwick Village Apt w Off St Parking

2 minutes to Warwick Village Farmers Market Our lovely apartment has earned 5 star reviews from over 300 guests. You'll love this private suite w private entrance Large kitchen, bedroom & stunning sun room loaded with plants Loved by gardeners, bicyclists, runners, artists, writers, diners, & shoppers. Visit Brew Pubs & Wineries, Woodbury Common, West Point, Catskills, Mt Peter, Mountain Creek, Heated bathroom floor & large shower Beautiful gas stove 300 MBPS Washer & dryer

Top guest favorite

A view of the exterior of the property is framed by lush greenery, featuring a stone wall with a potted plant. Beyond, expansive views of the lake and surrounding mountains are visible beneath a clear sky.

Home in Sterling Forest

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews

Spectacular Lake Views from Every Room & Garden

Our property boasts unparalleled views of Greenwood Lake and the mountains beyond. Our private garden features a seasonal waterfall cascading into a lily pond with fish and frogs. The shaded patio offers panoramic views and a gas grill. During the winter months, after skiing at nearby slopes, unwind in the claw foot tub or retreat to the cozy ambiance of our living room, with exposed wooden ceilings, a welcoming fireplace, a smart TV, a record player and board games.