Monthly Rentals in Water Island

William's place was lovely. The only issues we had were with the frequent power outages which left us without water or electricity sometimes lasting as long as 5+ hours. My recommendation would be to make sure all your phones, tablets, etc. are fully charged and always fill several large containers with water. William and/or Doug always responded almost immediately to any calls or texts. We love to snorkel and came to the island to check out Honeymoon Beach and the turtles. If your goal is to swim with turtles you will not be disappointed. There were always 5-6 turtles of all sizes grazing right in the middle of the swimming area. Sadly, there isn't much else to see as far as fish or coral. We explored both sides of the bay there and only saw a few small fish and lots of rocks. We also snorkeled at the pilings at Flamingo Beach which was a little more interesting and saw a good variety of fish.

Before arrival, Evanton answered my questions and prepared me for arrival. Once I showed up, he greeted me and welcomed me to the island and instructed me of the check in process which was simple and easy. He offered all contact info and said he was available anytime. Over the past week, I would see Evanton in passing and he was always interested in how my day went and how I’m loving the area. He even offered his connections if I chose to stay on the island and needed employment. The price was great and the views were stunning. The remote location means a car is a necessity but also that the area is peaceful and calm. Would absolutely stay here again.

My boyfriend and I had an amazing stay! The place was clean, cozy, and exactly as described. The host was super friendly and responsive, which made everything really easy and stress-free. We’d definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great Airbnb experience!

From start to finish, April made our stay one of our most memorable vacations. Having visited the island multiple times, we knew exactly what we wanted—and this property checked all the boxes. Anything we needed or requested was promptly addressed by either April or her property managers. This property is truly one of a kind, offering both stunning sunrise and sunset views. The ocean breeze is strong but refreshing, keeping you cool throughout the day. We also opted to have April provision our groceries, and she went above and beyond—everything was neatly put away upon our arrival. Water Island has always held a special place in our family’s heart, and staying here made it even more unforgettable. We can’t recommend it enough!