Hotel vacation rentals in Tisbury

Find and book unique hotel rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated hotel rentals in Tisbury

Guests agree: these hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

The exterior of a three-story resort building features a stone façade, multiple balconies, and well-maintained landscaping. A brick fence and pathway are visible in front, providing access from the road. The sky appears cloudy, suggesting an overcast atmosphere.

Resort in Falmouth

Captain's Quarters, Cape Cod

AVAILABLE JULY 11-18, 2025 Captain's Quarters in Falmouth Heights, is one of the few resorts to have the Ocean across the street. From the balcony you can enjoy the sunset, relax in the Jacuzzi, or enjoy the night life that is within walking distance. The Martha's Vineyard ferry is about 1/2 mile from the resort. Shopping, restaurants, and movie theater are close by. This unit is on the second floor and has two bedrooms, 2 baths. Kitchenette and living room.

Superhost

A spacious lobby area features a cozy seating arrangement with a light-colored sofa and patterned chairs. A large coffee table is centered on a soft area rug, surrounded by warm wooden beams and greenery. Natural light floods the space through expansive glass doors.

Hotel room in Edgartown

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

THE FRANKLIN HOTEL~NEW Pet friendly Standard Queen

Located on Upper Main Street in Edgartown, the Franklin Hotel is a short stroll from the heart of the historic village and its famed island beaches. A fresh take on the nautical style with modern, luxury finishes will provide all you need for work, play and relaxation. The Franklin grounds offer distinct seating areas including the covered patio, perfect to enjoy three season island breezes. The chic design of our 18 guestrooms will delight every sense.

Superhost

The exterior of The Coonamessett is displayed, featuring a charming red building with white trim. A flagpole stands prominently, while a landscaped area with colorful flowers and a fountain adds to the welcoming ambiance. The setting conveys a relaxed coastal atmosphere.

Hotel room in Falmouth

Maritime vibe with knotty pine & iron-frame beds

The Coonamessett offers two (2) comfortable 1st-floor King junior suites that are both ADA accessible. One large space features a plush king bed and a lounge/sitting area with a sofa and dining table as well as a private bath with a walk-in shower. These 475-510 square foot rooms also include a 43" Smart TV, Bluetooth radio, mini-fridge, individually-controlled AC and heat (window AC units used in the warmer months), and free wireless internet access.

Superhost

A corner room features expansive windows allowing natural light to fill the space. A spacious bed with a patterned coverlet is positioned near a dark wood dresser and a TV. A comfortable armchair in a vibrant hue adds a pop of color to the serene interior.

Private room in Oak Bluffs

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Lovely King-sized guest room in beautiful home

Bright well-appointed corner room on 2nd floor with king bed, dresser, 4 windows, closet, desk, AC window or fan. Full bathroom across the hall which may be shared with another guest on same floor. Farmhouse on private dirt road in wildlife preserve close and beautiful meadow wetlands, creek, pond, close to the beach and within 25 minute walking distance to Oak Bluffs in Harthaven. 7 minutes to 13 bus line to both Edgartown and Oak Bluffs.

Guest favorite

A soft, inviting bedroom is highlighted by a spacious bed dressed in white linens. Two decorative lamps with ornate bases sit on either side of the bed, illuminating plush pink pillows against a light-hued headboard. A framed mirror above the bed reflects natural light.

Hotel room in Falmouth

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Park Side Queen Room @ Frederick William House

This beautifully appointed room with private bath & sitting area, includes bike rentals, cable, free WIFI, overlooking gardens & park. We are located on the Shining Sea Bikeway in Falmouth, across the street from Goodwill Park, a short walk to the Steamship Authority. Guest are welcome to take bikes over to Martha's Vineyard for day excursions. Beach passes are available, 139 private & public beaches to choose from.

Superhost

The entrance of Holiday Inn Falmouth is presented, featuring a modern white building with a peaked roof and ample windows. Colorful shrubs and well-maintained greenery frame the pathway, while two flags are positioned near the entrance, inviting guests into the property.

Hotel room in Falmouth

4.65 out of 5 average rating, 91 reviews

Near Falmouth Beaches + Pool. Dining. Bar.

Escape to Cape Cod at Iris Hotel Cape Cod—just minutes from beaches, bike trails, and ferries to Martha’s Vineyard. Unwind in the indoor pool, hit the gym, or grab dinner at the on-site restaurant. You’re close to downtown shops, waterfront walks, and the Shining Sea Bikeway. With free Wi-Fi, parking, and all the essentials, this laid-back coastal stay is perfect for beach days, lobster rolls, and easy Cape vibes.

Guest favorite

A bright and airy queen room features a plush bed adorned with a textured blue throw and geometric pillows. Light walls complement the patterned wallpaper. A wooden dresser with green accents and a clothing rack are positioned nearby, while a door leads to additional space.

Hotel room in Oak Bluffs

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Fully reno’d, overlooking the blue harbor

Our intimately sized Queen rooms feature a plush queen bed, private bath with compact shower, 43" LED Smart TV, and Tivoli Bluetooth radio. Other features of this very affordable room include individually controlled AC and heat and free wireless Internet access. Please note: rollaway beds may be available at an additional cost, please contact the hotel directly to inquire about reserving one.

Guest favorite

A bright room features a queen bed covered with a light quilt, accompanied by a twin daybed. A small wooden table and chair provide a workspace. Wall art and framed pictures decorate the space, with a window allowing natural light and an air conditioning unit for comfort.

Hotel room in Vineyard Haven

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Vineyard Harbor - Unit 223

Vineyard Harbor Motel offers comfortable rooms, a private beach and an incredible location. We are situated on the harbor in Vineyard Haven within walking distance to the ferry, unique shops, great restaurants and perfectly placed to explore the island. Vineyard Harbor Motel is the perfect location from which to explore Martha’s Vineyard.

Superhost

The living area features a comfortable seating arrangement with two red armchairs and a dark blue sofa. A round wooden coffee table is centered, complemented by a glass dining table with chairs nearby. Natural light is offered through large windows, adorned with soft drapes.

Resort in West Yarmouth

New place to stay

The Cove 1 week 9/12-9/19/25

The Cove at Yarmouth in West Yarmouth, Massachusetts (Cape Cod). This is a timeshare resort and is full of amenities. Conveniently located in the heart of Cape Cod. One week only for 2025, Check in 9/12/25 check out 9/19/25 (Friday to Friday). For 2026 and 2027 dates will be in June (6/5/26-6/12/26, 6/4/27-6/11/27)

Guest favorite

A comfortable bed is dressed in a light-patterned coverlet, flanked by a vibrant red pillow featuring an anchor design and a decorative pillow with the word 'ahoy'. A mirror with a mermaid decoration hangs above the headboard, with soft blue walls enhancing the space.

Hotel room in Hyannis Port

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

#8 location location location, pool private room

Private rooms, private bath, wifi, continental breakfast daily at Salt Winds. Walk to beach and town and enjoy all Hyannis has to offer. Island ferry one mile to both Islands, 1 hour drive to PTOWN. Parking, pool no glass in pool area, beach towels and chairs available. Other rooms available sorry no pets allowed

Superhost

A welcoming hotel exterior is shown at dusk, featuring soft lighting highlighting the architectural details. Neatly trimmed shrubbery and seasonal flowers are positioned along the pathway, contributing to the inviting ambiance. A sign prominently displays the hotel name, enhancing the overall charm.

Hotel room in West Yarmouth

4.61 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Beach, fire pit & s’mores at sunset

Cozy and budget-friendly, our tastefully appointed rooms are perfect for travelers seeking comfort and value. Conveniently located on the first floor, each room features two double beds and an activity table with chairs—making it easy to relax or get a little work done during your stay!