Vacation rentals with lake access in Pymatuning Reservoir

This was our fourth stay at Jeff and Anne’s beautiful lake home and it just gets better every year. So peaceful and the surroundings are just spectacular. Jeff was quick to respond to our questions and made sure we had everything we needed for another wonderful vacation.

Mark is very responsive to the texts and any questions about the local area. He is very friendly and laid back. Off the main road, the lake scenes from front balcony are super nice. There is a local dock for fishing, swimming, or launching a canoe. Some good restaurants and a meat-seafood market are nearby for grilling. He supplies everything, so just bring the family or friends to start your relaxing stay. The house was clean and well stocked. This was our second stay.

Wonderful place!! Home has all amenities with huge full windows & high ceilings overlooking the lake in a great small community of 50 private homes with lovely & friendly neighbors. Proximity to Jamestown & Chautauqua institutions was great. Use of bike paths in adjoining Camp Chautauqua(100 acre site with 100 mobile trailer homes & 20 small fixed homes ) was great Also private tennis/pickelball court available at no cost on premises & large pool on adjoining camp property available as well as 2 boat docks.Great & safe for young children as community is private with no through streets & most kids & people use golf carts. There is adjoining campsite playground on lakefront which is great for young children. Bring a boat or kayak along & use Chautauqua institutions nearby for nightly entertainment as well as day lectures , art instruction courses sailing school, variety of day courses & lectures with great theater & opera productions. only 3 miles away.

This home was so peaceful and beautiful! It was a perfect weekend getaway! My wife was looking for a place to relax and celebrate finishing Nursing school this week, and this home was the best choice! It was super cozy and the hot tub was incredible. We had an amazing time.

Donald’s house was the perfect location for our winter weekend getaway in GOTL! The house is even more beautiful in person, and it is kept very neat and tidy! Donald was extremely responsive any time I reached out! He is an excellent house with a gorgeous home in the heart of Geneva! I can’t wait to stay again!👌🏻❤️

We had a great weekend stay! I only wish the weather had cooperated so we could sit out back with a fire. We had just enough space for 3 adults and baby with a pack n play so it worked out perfectly! Thank you!

Great place to stay for kids. The house has a large foot print for multiple families stay in. The remodeling was very pretty and bathrooms were nicely kept with clean new tile and tub. We will rent again.

The place was great and very comfortable also a good location

As soon as we walked in the door, we felt immediately at home! This was one of the best Air B&B stays that we have ever encountered! My wife was so impressed with how thoughtful the decor was and the welcome basket was yet another detail that we did not expect. The lake view was beautiful and even though the weather wasn't the best, it was the type of place that you could just relax and spend the day right there. Maripat and Tim were truly "Super Hosts" and it was evident with their home and their great communication. They literally thought of everything that you could possibly need and anything else was pretty close by. We had the most relaxing and stress free getaway that we've had in awhile. If our travels take us back to western NY again, I can guarantee that we will be trying to stay at this beautiful place on the lake. If we could give this 12 stars...we would!

David the host was incredibly responsive and helpful before and during our stay. The apartment was spotless and so cozy. The location was perfect, within walking distances to boutiques and restaurants. If the weather was nicer we would have taken advantage of outside activities with the lake being right there. We loved the added touch of the host providing a welcome basket with snacks. We would absolutely stay here again!

Wonderful home, was clean and the host was personable and respectful. great location and helpful hints to some great places in the area to eat! would love to be hosted again.

Leanne’s place was so cozy and a great stay for a weekend spent skiing at Peek n peak resort! She was so kind and always responded quickly to any questions we had. She was flexible for our check in and check out times which is really appreciated! Would definitely recommend staying here.

One of the best Airbnb’s I’ve stayed at! I would recommend this place to anyone who enjoys being in walking distance of everything and anything you want. Very clear instructions were sent out before arrival and the place was spotless. The loft was very spacious and fit everyone comfortably. Thank you for an awesome stay!

just stayed with my 2 daughters had a great and relaxing time.very nice and clean place with amazing water view from inside and out I recommend anyone to go there.definetly worth the price for the view and everything offered

The condo unit was very nicely decorated and very clean and comfortable. We had issues with how to operate the Roku Tv. Debbie was very attentive and helpful. She and her son came to the condo to assist with the tv. It was late in the evening. Debbie answers all messages within minutes. Great place to rent!

We love staying here while we are attending the Findley Lake Harvest Festival. The space is perfect, nice and clean, wonderful amenities, peaceful and private for a great night's stay.

such a nice cottage. perfect for our girls getaway. very comfortable. good restaurants near by. view of the water so peaceful.

This was our 2nd stay here, and experience was just as great as the 1st! Ideal cottage for relaxing at the lake! Exceptionally clean and had everything that we needed. Enjoyed the fireplace while watching the wildlife activity on the lake! Tina is one of the top airbnb hosts that we've had the pleasure of dealing with!

5th time staying here to visit our daughter at Edinboro University. We feel right at home each time we go. Cozy, comfortable cottage with all the amenities we need for a great stay! Karen is an excellent host! We will be back👍

Jan’s place is by far the best Airbnb I’ve ever stayed in. Such a cozy home with everything we could ever need and beautiful lake views. Jan made it so easy for us to just roll in and immediately relax. Only wish we could have stayed longer!

We love Molly’s little cottage on their wonderful farm. It is so peaceful and the surrounding area is so beautiful and private. I don’t think we’ve ever stayed in a more well equipped kitchen….anything you could possibly need is provided! The hosts are so friendly and responsive, while also completely respecting your privacy. We definitely hope to stay again in the future. Truly one of our favorite airbnbs! =)

Spotless, cozy, and exactly as described. Great location, responsive host, and thoughtful touches. Highly recommend!

This little cottage was adorable! It’s within 15-20 minutes of Erie. We went to splash lagoon, the mall and to the kids museum. There’s an AWESOME playground within walking distance of the cottage. Several great restaurants/diners within a mile of the cottage. Host was very accommodating and responsive. Overall the place is a gem! We will definitely be staying again.

This is a lovely little cottage for 2 people, but can sleep more with the sleeper couch and the attic loft. Love it! This was our second stay.