Vacation rentals in Mayville

We enjoyed our tiny cabin! It was close to Fredonia yet felt remote and private. Though tiny, it was a perfect size for my daughter and I. Great communication, and everything went exactly as expected.

Laurie was very accommodating. Her place was very comfortable for a friends’ get-away. Location was perfect. The house had everything we needed to cook in, and was close enough to places to go out. Ample towels and extra blankets, etc. We enjoyed the outside screened in porch since it unfortunately rained during our stay. Thank you.

Absolutely amazing place. Clean, comfy, on the water. parking, spacious. fire pit. unbelievable local town with amazing people. awesome local restaurants. HIGHLY recommend this listing.

Celebrated my daughter’s 13th birthday here! Having 2 units was awesome for the girls! Close to the beach. House was equipped with beach supplies, grilling and cooking supplies. And it’s pet friendly! Would absolutely stay again!

Loved this place! Super cozy. Small but not cramped. Incredible view of the stars at night and enchanting views of fog rising off the lake in the morning. The location is very quiet but not at all out of the way. It’s obvious that a lot of care and attention to detail was put into making this little island a unique and memorable experience. My new bride and I especially enjoyed the hunt for painted rocks in the garden. And being able to take one as a keepsake (we chose the mushroom painted rock) was a great touch to remind us of that special time at the start of our lives together. Rodney was very friendly and responsive and even left us a personalized welcome letter and complimentary bottle of wine for the first night of our stay. Would absolutely recommend this place for a couple’s getaway!

This was a last minute booking when our winter cabin reservation had to cancel. It turned out great! Beautiful, comfortable, very well stocked log home that had everything we needed and more! Pond was skateable at edge and the hill next to the house was perfect for sledding. Our grandkids had a ball! Dianna quickly responded to all our inquiries and they even made it possible to get a campfire started . Thank you!

Great central location to wineries. Good places to eat in Westfield. Driveway and front yard well illuminated by streetlight.

Grew up in the area and came back to visit family. Stayed here for a quiet weekend break and this place was clean, comfortable and had all the amentities. It was quiet and easy to unwind. I highly reccomend this gem.

Dawn’s property provided the perfect location for a surprise Birthday/Valentine’s Day getaway for my husband! Checked off all of our boxes, and we loved every minute of our stay! We loved it so much, we didn’t want to leave, and will definitely return! If you’re looking for a quiet, serene, private, out of the way space to relax, regroup, and reconnect with people you love, this is where you want to be! Thank you, Dawn & Gary for such an amazing experience! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️