We’re sorry, some parts of the Airbnb website don’t work properly without JavaScript enabled.

Airbnb your place

Lake house vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Find and book unique lake houses on Airbnb

Top-rated lake house rentals in Lake Shafer

Guests agree: these lake houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A charming two-story lake house is nestled on a lush green lot, surrounded by trees. The exterior showcases light-colored siding, with large windows allowing for natural light. A spacious deck is visible, inviting outdoor relaxation and offering easy access to the serene lakefront.

Home in Rochester

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Wenopa (Two Moons) on a Lake Manitou Peninsula

Immerse yourself in the charm of the 1920s with a stay at this beautifully renovated Lake Manitou home. Lot has 300ft seawall and lake views on three sides. Enjoy a cozy stay with 3 bedrooms, remodeled bathroom, & loft with queen bed & office. Outdoors: Revel in the serene sunrise, or gaze at the stars. Spacious deck with Blackstone grill, fire pit, corn hole, 2-40ft boat piers, swim pier, paddle boat, 3 kayaks & tandem bike, Ideal for peaceful escapes or adventures. Close to town. Self-check-in

The screened porch is illuminated at dusk, showcasing a spacious seating area with a lounge chair. Large windows provide views into the interior, where warm lights and a dining space are visible. The exterior features a light-colored structure with a gravel path.

Home in Monticello

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Modern lake front house w/ HOT TUB for 10 people!

Visit Piper House to enjoy the lake life, beautiful views, hot tub, beach, dock swimming, private playground, fire pits and more in our NEW modern lake house. Easy getaway from Chicago (2hr)/ Indy (1.5hr). Impressive views from huge Lake Shafer lot with dock, beach, firepit & screened porch with outdoor living/dining room. No expense spared. It’s fully stocked, totally tricked out, and all about comfort. (For high-season May-Sept bookings, see https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/20663989/ instead)

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a modern lake house features a large wooden deck furnished with blue chairs. High windows reflect the sky, while stairs lead to the entrance. The surrounding area includes a fenced yard with additional seating and a charcoal grill visible on the deck.

Home in Rochester

5 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Lake house in Rochester

Relax in this newly updated lake house right on Lake Manitou. Enjoy the views from our huge deck with fire pit and grill or head down to the lower level for a covered patio with lakeside yard. Dock access for fishing, swimming, or kayaking or contact us if you have boating experience & interest in renting our pontoon boat. Golfing, hiking on the Nickel Plate Trail, shopping, and restaurants right at your finger tips. Lake Manitou is an all-sport lake with fishing, boating, kayaking and more.

The spacious living area features large windows that fill the room with natural light and offer views of the lake and surrounding greenery. A dining table with chairs is positioned near a cozy sitting area, which includes a sofa and armchair, enhancing the inviting ambiance.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Lakeside Bliss: Wonderful Lake Views & Access

Welcome to your lakeside retreat! Newly renovated 2bedroom, 2bath gem offers modern comfort and stunning lake views. Spacious living area flooded with natural light, fully equipped kitchen for easy meal prep, and dining area with breathtaking views. Both bedrooms boast cozy linens and plush bedding, ensuring a tranquil night's rest. Direct lake access for swimming, fishing, or basking in the sun on the private dock. Roll-away bed can fit in any bedroom and queen size air mattress available.

Top guest favorite

A stone fire pit is surrounded by circular pavers, with several blue lounge chairs positioned nearby. A grassy yard expands around the area, while the home features multiple large windows and a covered patio for outdoor relaxation.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

The Main Lake House

Located on Main Lake Freeman with gorgeous views and updated floor plan and style. Enjoy lake access with Pergola Patio,Propane Grill, Fire Pit, and gradual sandy lake access with Dock. Enjoy watching the Madam Carroll cruise by daily while cooking out. Probably the best patio for drinking morning coffee in the entire Midwest! Newly added Lakeside Garage and Game Room for your enjoyment. Under 15 Minute drive to Indiana Beach and under 10 minutes to beautiful down town Monticello, IN.

The exterior of the lakefront home is illuminated by warm lighting, highlighting the spacious covered deck and seating area. A circular fire pit is surrounded by several chairs, providing a cozy gathering spot, while the lush landscaping enhances the outdoor appeal.

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Beautiful Lake Home in Culver

Relax w/ family at this beautiful lakefront home. Enjoy the comfort/layout w/ 52' of lakefront. 28*16 covered deck-incredible views. Walk out basement w/ seating area & fire pit for smores. 20*20 pier with ladder and 12*6 lily water pad & 2 paddle boards. Boat lift available; 6,000 lbs-inquire for cost. Home renovated 2021. Off peak rentals for Culver Academy sporting events/town guests. Jun-Sep 5 night min; off peak 2 night min stay. Hot tub not included. Sleeps 10 adults 2 kids.

A lakeside terrace is visible, featuring several metal lounge chairs arranged around a fire pit. Shaded by trees, the area overlooks the water, providing a serene view of the lake. A dock extends into the water, enhancing the outdoor experience.

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Lakefront Cottage With Dock and Guesthouse

Charming lakeside cottage on Lake Maxinkuckee in Culver, Indiana. From desirable East shore, watch sunsets over the lake from a waterside hammock, or shaded patio. Dock reaching out into the sandiest bottom on the lake. Full kitchen to feed a dining room seating of twelve. Screened in porch in back for downtime. Three bedrooms in the main house and two bedrooms in the guesthouse; sleeps 12. Full laundry room in basement. Check out the area guidebook on this listing!

An open-concept living area features a mix of dark wood paneling and light cabinetry. A spacious kitchen equipped with modern appliances and a breakfast bar flows into a cozy seating area, furnished with a large couch and a decorative coffee table, all bathed in natural light.

Home in Monticello

4.6 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

#5 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach!

Discover our cozy two-bedroom bakehouse (5 of 5 units on lake property) just down the street from Indiana Beach, offering a perfect lakeside getaway. You'll love the convenience and charm of this retreat, where you can swim off the dock, enjoy various watersports, and relax by the lakeside fire pit. Make cherished memories as you take in the serene beauty of Lake Shafer. Whether it's a family vacation or a getaway with friends, our lakeside escape is the ideal destination.

An aerial view showcases a spacious lakeside home surrounded by greenery. A large deck extends over the water, furnished with chairs for relaxation. A private boat dock is visible, providing direct access to the lake, while the inviting shoreline adds to the serene atmosphere.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Mellow Yellow on Shafer

Bring the family to this beautiful, spacious home on Shafer Lake. 4.5 miles to Indiana Beach 3.3 miles to Tippecanoe Country Club 1.5 miles to Hollow Acres Gold Course 2.5 miles to Battle Ground Golf Club 9.4 miles to Altherr Nature Park 4.4 miles to Lake Shafer Boat Rentals 1.1 miles to The Boat House 9.8 miles to Whyte Horse Winery 4.5 miles to Whisky & Wine Saloon 10 miles to Sportsmann Inn 10 miles to Kopacetic Brewery 12 miles to Fruitshine Wine

A charming lake house features large windows and a welcoming porch, overlooking a bright yellow and blue water trampoline anchored in the lake. Lush greenery surrounds the property, with additional homes visible in the background. The overall setting offers a vibrant aquatic atmosphere.

Home in Rochester

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Making Memories on Lake Manitou

Come and make memories with your family, and those special friends who are also family. Enjoy endless hours of fun and sun on the spacious deck while looking out at the lake with waterfront access. Also, a personal pier is available for anytime fishing. Enjoy a spacious lake house right on the water where all the action is. You won't find a better location on Lake Manitou.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the cottage is shown, featuring a red metal roof and a spacious patio area. A glass sunroom extends from the main floor, overlooking the backyard, which has seating areas and a firepit. The dock along the canal is visible in the foreground.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Glass Porch Cottage w/Boat Dock

Glass Porch Cottage on Lake Freeman Canal. A dock is available for Fishing, Mooring Boat, Relaxing. A paddle boat is available to explore the area. Nearby PURDUE University, Indiana Beach, Whyte Horse Winery, Kopaecetic Brewery, Sportsman Inn Restaurant, Oakdale Bar, Prophetstown State Park, Wolf Park, Wabash and Erie Canal Delphi, plus many more.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Lake Shafer lake house rentals

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Waterfront lakehouse rentals

The open-concept living area features a leather sectional sofa facing a wall-mounted television. Sunlight streams through large windows, illuminating the hardwood floors. A dining table is positioned adjacent to a bright kitchen area, showcasing modern appliances and white cabinetry.

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Lakefront Family Fun | HotTub • Game Room • Kayaks

An open-concept living area is showcased with a modern kitchen featuring granite counters. A black sofa and a foosball table provide spaces for relaxation and entertainment. Natural light streams in through large windows, highlighting a vintage upright piano in the corner.

Home in Monticello

4.58 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

#4 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach!

A view of Lake Shafer captures the serene waters surrounded by trees. A swimming dock extends into the lake, providing access for guests. The scene is framed by a covered porch, inviting a sense of tranquility and connection to nature.

Home in Monticello

New place to stay

Firefly at Lake Shafer

The lakefront house is situated on a hillside, featuring multiple levels with spacious decks. A dock extends out over the water, equipped with blue chairs and a shaded area. Lush greenery surrounds the property, creating a natural barrier for privacy.

Home in Monticello

4.41 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!

A spacious wooden deck offers seating areas for relaxation, with two lounge chairs positioned to face the calm waters of Lake Freeman. The serene landscape is framed by lush greenery along the shoreline, under a clear blue sky.

Home in Monticello

4.56 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Monticello Vacation Rental w/ Private Boat Dock!

A spacious deck extends over the water, surrounded by lush trees. Outdoor seating areas are present, offering views of the lake. Large windows in the house reflect natural light, emphasizing a connection with the serene landscape.

Home in Monticello

4.44 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Lakehouse Retreat on Freeman

A serene outdoor space is illuminated by soft lighting along landscaped tiers, creating a warm ambiance. A fire pit sits at the forefront, with flames dancing against the night sky. The home is visible in the background, adorned with string lights.

Home in Monticello

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Beautiful Lake Freeman Home w/Great View/Boat Dock

Pet-friendly lake house rentals

A living area is presented with a dark sectional sofa and ottoman positioned near a stone fireplace. A flat-screen TV is mounted above the fireplace. Natural light enters through the windows, and a lamp beside the seating provides additional illumination.

Home in Monticello

New place to stay

Bailey Bungalow Lake house

A two-story blue house is set back from a gravel driveway lined with greenery. Large windows are framed by a welcoming porch, and American flags add a touch of character. The background features a glimpse of a serene lake and trees, enhancing the natural surroundings.

New place to stay

Peaceful home right on the lake!

A serene view of the house from Lake Freeman highlights its lush green lawn and surrounding trees. A wooden dock extends towards the water, with a gentle slope leading up to the home, which features multiple levels and an array of outdoor areas.

Home in Monticello

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Panoramic view on Lake Freeman!

Top guest favorite

A living room features a brick fireplace with a clock on the mantel. Two large windows allow natural light, framed by blinds. A cozy seating area is arranged with a dark armchair beside a small table. Potted plants add a touch of greenery to the space.

Private room in West Lafayette

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

Home near Purdue

An aerial view showcases the unique A-Frame cottage surrounded by greenery. A spacious deck invites relaxation, while a path leads to a fenced yard. The pier extends into the water, with white chairs positioned nearby on the grassy area, ideal for enjoying views of Lake Manitou.

Home in Rochester

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 68 reviews

Waterfront Cottage on Lake Manitou - Sleeps 10

A charming cottage exterior is highlighted by a welcoming front porch with two chairs. Wooden steps lead to the porch, which is surrounded by black railing. Lush greenery is visible nearby, complementing the light-colored siding and gray roof under a partly cloudy sky.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Indiana Beach's best retreat

A fire pit with a metal grate reflects the warm glow of flames, situated on a deck overlooking a tranquil lake. A vibrant sunset casts shades of orange and pink across the water, creating a serene and picturesque backdrop.

Home in Rochester

4.71 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Private Island Oasis

Private lake house rentals

A two-story lakefront home is presented, featuring large glass doors that allow for ample natural light. A patio area with seating is visible, complemented by a hammock and well-maintained landscaping. A grill is located nearby, enhancing the outdoor space along the water.

Home in Rochester

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Spacious Lake House with a view!

A spacious deck overlooks a manicured lawn that gently slopes towards the waterfront. The scene features a lush green yard and a private pier with docked boats, set against the serene backdrop of Lake Manitou.

Home in Rochester

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

The Silver Tuna - Lake Manitou

A spacious living area showcases large windows providing a view of the river. Comfortable seating surrounds a coffee table, with a television mounted on the wall. Natural light floods the space, highlighting the warm wood accents and inviting atmosphere.

Home in Monticello

New place to stay

Family Fun or Serene Setting?

A two-story home features a light gray exterior with contrasting dark shutters. A welcoming porch is accessed by steps leading from an inviting lawn, which is bordered by neatly arranged shrubs. A stone chimney rises from one side, enhancing the architectural interest.

3.67 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Welcoming West Shore Lake Home- Lake Access

Destinations to explore