Lake house vacation rentals in Lake Ontario

Location was perfect for getting to Montezuma wildlife refuge. View of the lake was beautiful. House was clean and comfortable. Peaceful setting over looking the lake.

Our group had the loveliest stay, and Rich was a fantastic host. Was so nice to meet him and his pups! Felt right at home and was able to have a private reunion with friends on the water. The location and space was beautiful. Appreciated having a grill and kitchen full of appliances! Would gladly stay here again.

This place was spacious & beautiful! The outside area & dock was perfect for all of us! The kitchen was stocked w/ many plates, pots & pans. Would definitely come back !!

Beautiful home! Everything was neat and clean. The host responded to all my inquiries promptly. We enjoyed our stay!

The house and Kurt were great. Everyone in our group was able to get their own bed. Drive to Turning Stone for golf and the casino was very easy.

I would highly recommend staying here and plan to return. The home is well equipped and comfortable with breathtaking views. Thank you Greg for sharing your home .

Great place to stay with a very nice view. Nice and peaceful area.

Jonathan's place was very comfortable and the kitchen was well stocked with cookware and miscellaneous items. We visited in the winter, so we didn't get to experience much of the outside but it looks like it would be incredible in the summer. As a host, Jon was great and very accommodating to our needs. We really enjoyed our stay and are considering coming back.

Jill's place was perfect for celebrating a special occaison! The location is picture perfect and there is everything you could ask for! Great communication and very clean and organized! We highly recommend for anyone travelling to Seneca Lake!

The stay on Little York Lake was perfect! Everything was clean, the location was perfect, the house had many extras and the kayaks were a big hit! Loved every second of it! Best place we’ve stayed by far!

Great place with beautiful view. The sunset on the lake was particularly great! So happy we chose to stay here.

Lacey’s place was so lovely. It is so beautifully designed and welcoming—the perfect Lakehouse! There was cornhole and board games for the kids, kayaks, life jackets, a beautiful bunkroom, and a beautiful view of the lake. We didn’t want to leave!

What a special place! Contemporary and well decorated, this home checked all the boxes for us. We enjoyed the hot tub, s’mores at the fire pit and had a BBQ. The bathrooms are clean and beautifully designed. The hosts also left a cute goody bag for us! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Catherine is a wonderful host. Her house is very cozy with beautiful view . There is a very nice Amish supermarket 15 minutes by her place. The house is super clean and very comfy beds. Most hikes were about 30 to minutes drive. It’s a beautiful and very peaceful place. Highly recommended

Beautiful home in a lovely setting. Truly a home away from home!

We had an amazing stay at Sean’s place. The host was fast to respond and very helpful. The location was beautiful and we loved being able to have a fire or two while we were there. The house was perfect and everything was very clean! I would definitely stay here again!!

I can't say enough great things about our stay! The hosts were awesome to deal with...always accommodating and available, the location was perfect...right on the water/ice, the residence exceeded our expectations and had everything we needed. The location is perfect with a short walk to exceptional fishing. No need to scramble trying to find parking...its all right there for you. We enjoyed a weekend of ice fishing with family and friends and definitely plan on coming back this year. On a scale of 1 to 10...this is an 11! Highly recommend!

Our stay on the lake was wonderful. The housing was perfect and met our needs. This would be a great house to rent during the summer months. WE had a little trouble locating the house initially as it is located among other houses and the drive down to the house is not clearly marked. If you are coming from the south you need to make a turn almost opposite the way you are coming into a steep drive to the housing. It needs to be better marked, maybe with an arrow and house number. The house could also us a little address sign on the walkway for clarification. HOWEVER, the stay was great and getting information to the person in charge was easy. The accommodations were very good. The view was wonderful. The water frontage is a bit steep but there are steps to bring you to the water. In all this is a wonderful home for vacation with amenities about 15 minutes away. I would give Nancy or Eric a call again.

An amazing place to stay, would definitely recommend more for warmer weather. The view was beautiful as well as the location of the house itself. The house felt very comfortable and was suitable for 5 people, though you could probably fit 2 more. Everything was provided well. There are a couple things to do in the area but they are drives. Overall great experience!

Eric’s place was great! We had everything we needed for our week long stay! The house was also VERY clean. This may sound silly, but I’ve stayed in many vacation homes, and you can always tell how clean a place is by the small details, like coffee maker, drawers, etc…I was so pleased to find that the coffee pot and filter had been run through the dishwasher before we arrived! the kitchen was spotless and well stocked. It’s the small things, that really make a difference in your comfort level! Eric was also very accommodating and responsive to a special request we had! This is a great house, and we would definitely stay again!

Great stay on the lake. Tom was a very flexible and responsive host.

It was a lovely stay and easily accommodated our group. A nice space to all be gathered together with a nice view!

Stayed here with 7 girlfriends and had plenty of room. House was beautiful and being on the lake was incredible! Hot tub was clean and large. Bob was very responsive and flexible with check in. All the girls saved the listing as we all loved it!

Great place for our group consisting of 4 adults and 4 kids. Parking adequate for our 2 cars. Appreciated the location and all the amenities.