Vacation rentals in Guys Mills

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Guys Mills

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A wooden sign stands at the entrance of Pat Crawford Beach, featuring white lettering against a dark brown background. Surrounding the sign, green grass and shrubs enhance the setting, with a view of the sandy beach and lake visible in the background.

Cottage in Edinboro

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

The Cove, cozy cottage by Edinboro Lake

ReneeRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

The Cove was a delightful stay for my husband and I. I especially appreciated that this location was pet friendly and a great place to bring our dog. Lots of space, quiet, and cozy. We also appreciated her responsiveness to the front porch lights being burnt out- this was taken care of immediately the next day and we extremely grateful for the care shown by our host. Would absolutely book again!

Top guest favorite

A serene view out of the window showcases a calm lake at dusk, framed by lace curtains. Soft twilight colors reflect off the water, with silhouettes of trees and nearby structures visible along the shoreline.

Apartment in Findley Lake

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Becker Rentals

LeahRating, 5 stars2 months ago

Leanne’s place was so cozy and a great stay for a weekend spent skiing at Peek n peak resort! She was so kind and always responded quickly to any questions we had. She was flexible for our check in and check out times which is really appreciated! Would definitely recommend staying here.

Top guest favorite

A wooden dock extends into Edinboro Lake, with a covered boat slip visible at the end. Calm waters reflect the surroundings under a cloudy sky, while green trees frame the background. A no parking sign is positioned near the entry to the dock.

Cottage in Edinboro

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 261 reviews

The Hickory Hut

KellieRating, 5 stars3 days ago

The house was absolutely adorable. I especially loved the coffee bar and the decor in the master bedroom. The house was very clean , comfortable and roomy. The hostess was easily accessible when we needed to contact her upon arrival . We only stayed one night but we definitely will keep them in mind for our future trips to Edinboro .

Guest favorite

A tranquil outdoor space is depicted with several gray Adirondack chairs arranged around a stone fire pit. The dark wooden A-frame home is visible in the background, flanked by tall trees and a grassy area, suggesting a peaceful retreat.

Chalet in Findley Lake

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 186 reviews

Lakeside Lodge—Secluded Family Getaway Sleeps 10

SharonRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Laurie was very accommodating. Her place was very comfortable for a friends’ get-away. Location was perfect. The house had everything we needed to cook in, and was close enough to places to go out. Ample towels and extra blankets, etc. We enjoyed the outside screened in porch since it unfortunately rained during our stay. Thank you.

Top guest favorite

A two-story lake-front home is visible, surrounded by lush greenery. A spacious porch extends from the upper level, offering a view of Lake Erie. The exterior features light-colored siding, with a driveway leading to the lawn and water beyond.

Home in Conneaut

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Relax at The Cliffside Getaway!

JamesRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Jill was an excellent host, and her place was perfect for a short getaway. She provided everything we needed for our lakeside trip. The views were spectacular, and the location, between Conneaut and Ashtabula, was ideal for accessing restaurants and wineries. We enjoyed the Easter decorations, the fireplace, and the hot tub. The beds were exceptionally comfortable, and my wife slept soundly. The heated mattress was also a welcome addition during the cold weekend. While we wish we could have experienced it in the summer, it was still a beautiful weekend getaway. I really appreciated you opening your home to us and I hope to come back again in the future! Thank You

Top guest favorite

A private deck area is visible, featuring a woven chair and a patterned rug. Beyond the deck, a green lawn extends towards a distant blue house, framed by trees. Clear skies are overhead, enhancing the tranquil outdoor setting.

Cottage in Mercer

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Charming Farm Cottage

MirandiRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Sean went above and beyond to make our family feel incredibly welcome, and he was willing to accommodate a particular request that we made so that we could personalize our time in Mercer for our family. We are so thankful for being able to bring our family to Sean‘s place, and we will always hold it as a special place in our families’ memories!

Guest favorite

The exterior of the home is showcased at night, featuring large windows that reflect warm light. A spacious wooden deck is adorned with string lights, enhancing the inviting atmosphere. Swing seats and benches offer comfortable outdoor seating among lush greenery.

Home in Ashtabula

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Nature's Nest: A peaceful and relaxing get away

LeighRating, 5 stars6 months ago

We had an amazing stay! The home was incredibly well-supplied with everything we needed and more – from kitchen essentials to cozy blankets. The hosts clearly put thought into every detail, making it easy to settle in and relax. The location was perfect: set in a quiet, friendly neighborhood surrounded by nature, which made it feel like a real getaway. We loved sitting on the porch in the mornings, enjoying the peace. The proximity to local sights and Lake Erie was also a huge plus. We highly recommend this place for anyone looking to unwind in a comfortable, serene environment!

Guest favorite

An inviting seating area is positioned alongside the water, with two chairs and a small table visible. Natural light streams through an open doorway, enhancing the serene lakefront view. Wooden walls and a striped rug provide a cozy and rustic ambiance.

Cottage in Findley Lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Hidden Cove

CindyRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Had an amazing quiet get away! Everyone in town was friendly and helpful! The cottage was clean, well stocked and had more than we could have imagined. Looking forward to a future stay when the weather is warmer! We had everything we needed and more to recharge our batteries.

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Mercer

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Mermaid Inn romantic house on the lake

Leigh AnnRating, 5 stars6 months ago

Anna thought of everything someone might need for a “home away from home.” The place was beautifully decorated with everything seemingly brand new. It was a very comfortable and peaceful place to hang out. Being outside was so relaxing. We enjoyed the pond and the backdrop of woods with changing autumn leaves. It was the perfect location being so close to the outlets and restaurants too.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Guys Mills vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Guys Mills

Guest favorite

Apartment in Conneaut Lake

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

Lovely, Two Bedroom Apartment with tons of space

MichaelRating, 5 stars1 week ago

The pictures honestly don’t do any justice to how stunning the place really is. It felt like home from the moment we walked through the doors. Geryll was very responsive and helpful. A short way to the lake, and a stunning view

Guest favorite

A large covered deck is showcased with a bright sun casting rays over the scene. Comfortable seating options, including white lounge chairs and a larger dining table, are visible. Lush greenery surrounds the area, enhancing the outdoor space.

Cottage in Linesville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Pymatuning Lake Cottage - Walk to the Lake

DakotaRating, 5 stars8 months ago

Matt’s place was perfect for my family and I we enjoyed the privacy while being close to everything we were there to do! Very responsive and made us feel at home will definitely stay again in the future.

Guest favorite

A covered balcony is observed, featuring two woven chairs facing a small table. A lantern sits atop the table, and the expansive view of the lake is visible through wide-open doors. The scene is set in soft evening light, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.

Home in Jamestown

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Cead Mile Failte

AndreaRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Visiting Mary’s while the lake was frozen over was neat! We were able to see fishermen and their huts out in the middle of the lake. Mary even provided binoculars so that we could look out across. The windows out the back window facing the lake were perfect for viewing. There’s even an upstairs room with a deck and a view as well! We also took full advantage of the fireplace. It made our visit super cozy which was exactly what we were hoping for! We’re definitely keeping this place in mind for another trip - we’d come back in winter and also for summer to use the deck and other amenities available outside!

Guest favorite

An indoor swimming pool is highlighted by natural wood beams and stone accents. Soft lighting from hanging fixtures casts a warm ambiance. Lounge chairs and a round table with a water bottle are positioned nearby, creating a welcoming space for relaxation.

Condo in Clymer

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Home Away From Home at Peek n Peak

SarahRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We had an amazing stay here! Perfect for ski in and ski out!

Top guest favorite

Home in Saegertown

5 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

French Creek River Lodge

JessicaRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Had a wonderful stay! Gene was a great host! The home and surrounds are beautiful! Can’t wait to return during warmer weather to enjoy the outside amenities. Views of the river in the snow were gorgeous. We loved the decor, books and the special touches for guest like the gorgeous flowers, drinks and breakfast food:) Highly recommend!!

Guest favorite

A scenic view of a lakeside area showcases individuals relaxing on the shore, with some wading in the water. Several beach chairs and umbrellas are visible, along with a wooden bench overlooking the lake. The surrounding landscape features green grass and trees in the background.

Cottage in Edinboro

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

Entire Cottage Sleeps up to 8

CynthiaRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

This house was the perfect getaway! The location was close to town and the highway but in a nice quiet neighborhood. The space and amenities were exactly as listed and all the kid friendly additions at the house were great! The hosts were very friendly and responsive. Would definitely recommend and would stay here again!

Guest favorite

A wooden deck offers a view of a flowing river framed by colorful autumn foliage. Trees with yellow and green leaves line the water's edge, while a distant building is visible across the river. The atmosphere is calm, with cloudy skies overhead.

Home in Warren

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

Cozy Conewango Comfort

JaimieRating, 5 stars1 week ago

We enjoyed our stay at Nancy’s house. It was perfect for traveling with our infant to visit family in the area. We had last minute travel changes and Nancy was great to get it ready and allow us to get in the same day we booked. We will definitely be looking to book again the next time we are in town!

Superhost