City Island vacation rentals

Our stay at Starlight Serene was everything we hoped it would be! John was very responsive and helpful, especially as this was our first time using AirBnB. The pictures are very accurate, there were plenty of towels, linens, and a VERY well equipped kitchen - much more than we expected (or I have in my own house, I think!). Lots of nice bonuses to this place - my kids loved the firepit and there was wood on hand as well as a s'mores kit; the hot tub was warm and ready when we arrived. You are at the narrower end of the lake, but still a beautiful view with plenty of wildlife. The location is great - roughly 30ish minutes to Bear Mountain, Legoland, and the Palisades Center (which had tons of rainy-day fun for kids). We even rented a pontoon boat from Murphy's Cove Marina - Richie was really wonderful to us and our kids and they loved their first time boating and fishing on the lake. Thanks for a great experience John!

An overall outstanding experience. Pristinely clean, comfortable furniture, cozy bed & bedding - can’t say enough great things about this place and the hosts. We will definitely be back!

Stefan and Taís’ home was beautiful! They were so friendly and helpful, and everything was as described. Spent most of our time hiking the neighboring areas and enjoying the lakefront! Great for all who love nature. The quality of the home AND the great hosts will both be reasons I will one day be back

First of all I would like to thank Carmen for letting me stay at her beautiful home. I enjoyed the time I spent at the air bnb even though it was a very busy weekend for me. Carmen home was clean and comfortable, also a very convenient location close to so many places. The home is also pretty spacious I was able to have a nice family dinner and gathering there. I would definitely recommend staying at this beautiful air bnb, Carmen was a great host Thankyou again.

This was the perfect cozy getaway. Everything we needed was available. Lizbeth was a perfect hostess. Great suggestion, and very accommodating.. I felt right at home.. I plan on coming here again

Danny and Lisa were great hosts! Me and my husband enjoyed our babymoon in this relaxing and quiet location. The views are stunning and it was nice to be surrounded by nature! The place was so clean and beautiful. We would definitely love to return for another relaxing weekend to recharge :)

This was the best Airbnb I ever stayed in , very clean , perfect location, easy to get in , it really was Great i recommend this place to anyone comming skiing/ snowboarding for a couple days

The place was exactly as described spacious , luxurious and just felt better than home. The views and space given for this unit is exactly needed. The pullout was very comfortable as well. I have 0 complaints I will be back again. The room the amenities was worth every second of my life. Thank you. !

Nice cozy cottage one block from the beach.. spent many hours walking the beach and found many beautiful shells and sea glass on our walks. Cozy cottage perfect for us and our dog in a quiet and beautiful neighborhood.