Vacation rentals in Cayuga Island

Great place for our family of 7. Loved the place and will stay again if we are in the area. Very close to everything we walked to everything the 5 days we were there. Kids loved the pool and hot tub! He always answered right away when we had questions. Overall Very nice house and guy.

It was a beautiful, clean, and easy-to-find home. The location was perfect—walking distance to our Dad's place. We would love to go back again. The host was responsive and provided all the necessary information we needed in a timely manner.

This space was truly inviting and everything we had imagined— and then some! It came equipped with everything that you may need. We love this place as it’s within walking distance of the gorgeous beach, local cafes, restaurants and bars. Peaceful to sleep and cozy inside. Felt like a true beach house! Loved the movies, games and thoughtful items that were included. Loved the heated floors in the bathrooms and the large fireplace. Especially loved that our fur babies were welcome too! Many establishments in the Crystal Beach area are pet friendly! What a bonus! We shall definitely be back again :) Thank you so much for a memorable and comfortable weekend stay!

Awesome place! The pictures don’t do it justice, the view is beautiful. Elaine and Peter were great hosts. This place was fully stocked, towels, linens, ziplock bags, paper towel, utensils, cooking stuff, you name it. Lots to do too, the beach is right there and they had paddle boards and kayaks to use. We travelled with two young kids and Elaine went above and beyond setting up the pack and play and high chair for us before we arrived. 10/10 would recommend!

This is a lovely, cozy place with a perfect location and host. Everything was as described, easy check in and wonderful communication. The location could not be better for staying in Niagara on the Lake. Parking was a huge plus. Comfortable beds, well equipped kitchen, nice shower and bathroom. Sindy has made wonderful choices in decoration this amazing period home, including subtle and appropriate holiday decorations. We were honored to stay in this historical treasure!

It was a very clean and tidy place. Thank you so much! The place matched the photos exactly. We had a great holiday. Merry Christmas and happy holidays🎄☃️🎊🎉

The 3 Bears Vineyard was just wonderful. We had our girls trip here and everything was great! Spacious kitchen, cozy TV room and wonderful hot tub! Close to Niagra Falls & Niagra on the lake with loads of fun things to do and wine to taste. Definitely would stay again, thank you so much to our host V ! Great help with activities and super responsive! 10out of 10 stars!!

Tim's cottage was lovely. It was so clean, had everything I could possibly need, and was in walking distance to everything (downtown Ridgeway, downtown Crystal Beach, Bay Beach, a park/playground, restaurants and cafes). I absolutely loved my stay and would stay here again in an instant!

We had an amazing stay at Shelley's place! The home was spotless and exactly as described. When we needed to ask questions, Shelley responded right away. The location of the home is amazing, overlooking Lake Erie, with many amenities including a grocery store, restaurant and even an LCBO on site! The beaches on site were also beautiful and very clean. Travelling around the site was easy with the use of the golf cart provided as part of staying at Shelley's place. Highly recommend!