Guidebook for Shirley
Food Scene
Italian food... Pizza is pan style - delicious. The sausage pizza is probably my favorite. Patty is a classic LI community member. Be sure to say hi from the Airbnb on Baybright!
8 locals recommend
Onofrio's
421 Neighborhood RdItalian food... Pizza is pan style - delicious. The sausage pizza is probably my favorite. Patty is a classic LI community member. Be sure to say hi from the Airbnb on Baybright!
Tend Coffee
924 Montauk HwyGreat coffee and delicious pastries - scones, croissants, etc.
Excellent Greek Food - only outdoor seating. They actually deliver to the house!
10 locals recommend
Greek Bites Grill & Cafe
183 Montauk HwyExcellent Greek Food - only outdoor seating. They actually deliver to the house!
TJ's Hero Shop
328 Mastic RdGreat hero sandwiches
Ice Cream Cottage
1590 Montauk HwyGreat ice cream cakes and other specialties!
Paradise Ice Cream
410 Neighborhood RdGreat soft serve with hot fudge sundaes and vintage style candy shop!
Essentials
King Kullen
405 William Floyd PkwyThis is the closest.
Stop & Shop
999 Montauk Hwy7-Eleven
1481 William Floyd PkwyParks & Nature
Smith Point County Park
1 William Floyd Pkwy There is a hiking trail and fishing spots all around.
Werthein National Wildlife RFG
21 Montauk HwyWildlife Refuge
Drinks & Nightlife
Tiki Joe's Smith Point
1 William Floyd PkwyArts & Culture
Manor of St. George
Shopping
Smith Point Bait Tackle & Marine Supply
396 William Floyd PkwyFishing gear
Entertainment & Activities
Pumpkin Patch Farm Stand
142 Long Island AveFink's Country Farm
6242 Middle Country RdAnimal Farm Petting Zoo
296 Wading River RdLong Island Skydiving Center
133 Dawn DrSouthaven County Park
761 Victory Avekayaking
Top 5 water parks in America according to travel channel and it's just 20 minutes away!
140 locals recommend
Splish Splash Water Park
2549 Splish Splash DrTop 5 water parks in America according to travel channel and it's just 20 minutes away!