Ally's Guidebook

Ally
Ally's Guidebook

Simple island needs😎

The store on the island with everything you need! Convenience, liquor store, surf shop, and ice cream!
12 locals recommend
The Cottage Island Market
14 Plum Island Boulevard
12 locals recommend

Breakfast/brunch🍳☕️🍩

A breakfast/brunch favorite on the island. A 12 minute walk from the house!
40 locals recommend
Mad Martha's Cafe
51 Northern Blvd
40 locals recommend
A breakfast/brunch favorite on the island. A 12 minute walk from the house!
The best spot on the island for a to go breakfast sandwich!
Plum Island Kitchen
134 Northern Blvd
The best spot on the island for a to go breakfast sandwich!
The most delicious bagels - many unique bagel and cream cheese options!
24 locals recommend
Abraham's Bagels
11 Liberty St
24 locals recommend
The most delicious bagels - many unique bagel and cream cheese options!
Delicious gourmet donut shop!
6 locals recommend
Changing Tides Café and Donut Shop
92 Pleasant St
6 locals recommend
Delicious gourmet donut shop!
The best iced coffees!
Souffles
14 Market Square
The best iced coffees!

Dinner🥂

Amazing seafood and raw bar. Good date night spot!
28 locals recommend
Brine Oyster • Crudo • Chops
17 State St
28 locals recommend
Amazing seafood and raw bar. Good date night spot!
Really nice waterfront location with great four season patio!
17 locals recommend
Tuscan Sea Grill and Bar
38R Merrimac St
17 locals recommend
Really nice waterfront location with great four season patio!
Fun, funky spot with eclectic menu
20 locals recommend
The Paddle Inn
27 State St
20 locals recommend
Fun, funky spot with eclectic menu
Mexican spot! Great food and margs!
25 locals recommend
Agave Mexican Bistro
50 State St
25 locals recommend
Mexican spot! Great food and margs!
Old town Newburyport bar and restaurant. Also a good later night spot with live music.
37 locals recommend
The Grog Restaurant
13 Middle St
37 locals recommend
Old town Newburyport bar and restaurant. Also a good later night spot with live music.
Yummy dinner spot right on the island with great food and drinks. 12 minute walk!
40 locals recommend
Plum Island Grille
2035 2 Plum Island Turnpike
40 locals recommend
Yummy dinner spot right on the island with great food and drinks. 12 minute walk!
Classic seafood window with picnic tables to enjoy your gourmet lobster roll or fried seafood!
30 locals recommend
Bob Lobster
49 Plum Island Turnpike
30 locals recommend
Classic seafood window with picnic tables to enjoy your gourmet lobster roll or fried seafood!
Yummy off the beaten path Mexican spot. Try the fried avocado taco and the churros!
Metzy's Cantina
5 Boston Way
Yummy off the beaten path Mexican spot. Try the fried avocado taco and the churros!