The Guest House - Sugarloaf Beach Key West

Entire home in Sugarloaf Key, Florida

  1. 8 guests
  2. 2 bedrooms
  3. 7 beds
  4. 2.5 baths
Hosted by Island Time
  1. Superhost
  2. 8 years hosting

Listing highlights

On the beach

This home is right on Sugarloaf Beach.

Self check-in

Check yourself in with the keypad.

Beautiful area

Guests love this home’s scenic location.
Some info has been automatically translated.
A truly one-of-a-kind beachfront retreat offering a private sandy beach and dock with boat dockage. This tropical escape delivers a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere that makes you feel as if you’re on your own private island in the Florida Keys.
Enjoy sweeping ocean views and direct access to a natural private beach—ideal for kayaking, paddleboarding, or simply unwinding beneath the swaying palm trees with a book in hand. Perfect for guests seeking both adventure and total relaxation.

The space
**Must be at least 30 years of age to book this accomodation** (at managements discretion ok to book under 30 / does not apply to families)

Our guests are our top priority, and we are dedicated to exceeding their expectations. Your host is available 24/7, 365 days a year, ready to assist with anything you need—from providing extra towels to recommending the perfect restaurant.

Events & Property Use
Any events, including photo/video shoots, corporate stays, weddings, or similar gatherings, must be pre-approved by management. A venue fee will apply.

Beach & Environmental Notice
During the hotter months, significant amounts of seaweed mixed with natural ocean debris may accumulate along the beach and surrounding shoreline. Please contact us if you’d like current seaweed conditions.

House Guidelines
Pets are welcome with a $250 per pet fee ( aggressive breeds not permited).
Indoor furniture may not be taken outside.
Deck furniture must remain on the deck.
No cutting on tables, chairs, or any household surfaces.

Property Highlights
Private beach
430-foot dock with a 5-foot draft, suitable for larger boats
Two large bedrooms, each with the option to be closed off or divided for added privacy
Unlimited use of kayaks

Guest access
*During Hotter Months, Extreme amounts of Seaweed will accumulate on our beach*

*Onsite caretaker is available to assist with any guest request.

Upon check in, guest required to provide vehicle information (tag #, color, make & model)

Other things to note
*Self check in

*During Hotter Months, Extreme amounts of Seaweed mixed with debris will accumulate on our beach, it will be raked as needed following environmental guidelines.

*Must provide a full list of guests that will be staying & ID's if requested

Q. Where are you located ? How private is the location?
A. We are at 15760 Old State Road 4A Sugarloaf Shores , FL 33042.
We are 5 miles from the 17 mile marker off US 1.
Mile marker 1 is the southernmost point in Key West.
We are on a private cove, basically giving you the feeling that you're on your own private island.
We offer private gate access, with security cameras outside of the house. We have a private dock and a private white sandy beach used only by guests of both our vacation homes.

Q. Does your house have pots, pans and all the necessary items to cook?
A. We have a full setup for cooking which includes pots, pans, utensils and seasonings. We also have a blender, a toaster, a microwave and brand new appliances.

Q. Do you have a coffee maker ?
A. Yes, we have a Keurig coffee maker at each house with a few pods.
In the Main House we have a Nespresso original coffee maker (small cups ).

Q. How’s the weather and seaweed ?
A. Seaweed and pollution is a huge problem here in South Florida. Due to global warming and the deforestation and pollution in Brazil, there has been more seaweed than normal on our beaches in the Florida Keys.

Q. Is there a supermarket? Can we have groceries delivered to the house ?
A. Yes, there is a convenience fee to go shopping for you prior to your arrival if needed. When you get to the house everything will be in the refrigerator ready for you. The closest supermarket is 22 miles away. There are a few small convenience stores within 10 miles.

Q. How far are the restaurants and do they offer delivery service ?
A. Sugarloaf Lodge is 5 miles away and offers dinner. Baby’s Coffee and Bayfront Market is 7 miles away and offers great coffee and good subs.
Mangrove Mamas is 7 miles away and offers lunch and dinner. Square Grouper is 10 Miles away and offers lunch and dinner.

Key West is 20 miles away where you will find many restaurants and bars offering great selections. Tom, our caretaker, can offer suggestions if needed !!!

Q. Do you have a grill ?
A. Yes. We have two gas grills, one per house.

Q. Do you offer housekeeping service ?
A. Our housekeepers do a complete and thorough cleaning after each guest leaves. Should you need additional cleaning, our housekeepers can come every other day. We have sufficient clean towels, blankets and sheets for guests and have extra available if necessary. We also have a full washer and dryer in each house for your use.

Q. Can we rent boats and wave runners and/or can we bring our own?
A. Yes, we can help you rent a boat and/or a wave runner and have it brought to our dock. Please note that we are not responsible for the boat nor the wave runners rented.
You can bring your own boat and/or wave runner and use our dock which is 430 feet long with a 3-4 foot draft (dock currently does not have water or electricity)
You are responsible for your own boats and WaveRunners (ownership is not liable for any damage caused to any vessel while docked at our property). The ocean can turn in a minute so PLEASE watch the weather report.
We would recommend you launching your boat and wave runners at Sugarloaf Key Marina which is 5 miles from our house and approximately 10 miles by boat. If you have a large boat and can’t go through 2 ft channels, our caretaker can help you get through and direct you to the house .

Q. Do you have shampoo, conditioner, toilet paper, paper towels and a hair dryer?
A. Yes , we have one hair dryer per house and we have a few of each of the other items at each house . If you are staying more than 5 days and are not using the extra maid service, I would recommend bringing a few extra of these items . We set the house up with enough toilet paper and paper towels to get you started but guests are responsible to supply the rest.

Q. What activities and amenities do you have for the beach ?
A. We have games like horseshoes and corn hole as well as games for kids. We have hammocks, chairs, lounge chairs and one umbrella at the end of the dock. We recommend bringing large umbrellas, balls or anything else you enjoy playing.
We are on an island so PLEASE BRING sunblock lotion, aloe vera, bug spray with deet. Night time during summer can get pretty bad with bugs like mosquitoes and no-see-ums so make sure you spray yourself. Please always wear footwear.

Q. Are there bugs and Mosquitos ?
A. Yes, you are on an island and between mangroves. Between 5-8pm bugs can get real bad during the Summer in Florida. NO-SEE-UMS are hard to see but you will definitely feel them.
Please wear bug spray when you are outside, especially at night.
PLEASE KEEP ALL DOORS CLOSED AT ALL TIMES !!!

Q. What time is check out and check in?
Check out is at 10:00AM. Check out is strictly enforced - an additional $50.00 will be charged for every hour up to four hours. After four hours an additional full day will be charged.
Check in is at 4pm unless you call and make arrangements with the property manager (Cadmier) prior to check in.

Q. What is expected prior to checking out?
A. Please put all bed sheets, towels and blankets in one area so that the cleaning service can take them to be cleaned. Please leave the house in good condition. If possible leave a load of towels washing.

Leaving the house with excess trash and in a unsanitary condition would be subject to an additional cleaning fee of $350.00 and up.
Please remove all garbage and open food containers in the refrigerator and freezer. If it’s new and unopened and you don’t want to take it with you, leave it in the refrigerator or freezer so employees can take it if they want. Please make sure to speak with the caretaker if you have any concerns .

Q. Are pets allowed ?
A. Yes, small to medium dogs.
There is a $250.00 pet fee. Non aggressive breeds only. (Failure to advice of pet staying in the house will cause an additional cleaning fee of $350.00 and up)
Q. Can I invite people who are not staying at the house ?
A. No one day visiters permited unless aranged ahead of time with Cadmier, the property manager.

Q. What about water conservation and rinsing off sand before entering the house ?
A. The keys bring their water in from Miami and it’s very expensive. We get text messages from the county if there is overuse of water at our houses so please conserve water.

We are committed to the conservation and protection of all our resources. We are constantly looking for ways to improve our efforts. Water is one of our most important life resources. Please help us protect and conserve this vital source. Here are some ways you can help:

TURN THE FAUCET OFF WHILE BRUSHING TEETH OR SHAVING
DO NOT USE TOILET AS A TRASH RECEPTACLE
BE SURE ALL FAUCETS ARE TURNED COMPLETELY OFF
REPORT LEAKY FAUCETS AND REUSE TOWELS

We have showers on both sides of each house. Please use them to remove any sand before entering the house. We also have vacuums at each house if needed.

Q. Will we see sea turtles and key deer?
A. We have sea turtles that come to our shores to lay eggs during certain times of the year. Please do not disturb them or their nests. Bright lights at night make them lose their sense of direction as they confuse them with the moon that normally guides them. The county can fine us if lights on the back porch are not turned off. Please be advised that lights on the porch must be out by 10pm. You can use flash lights or bring lanterns for your use.

Key deer sometimes come on our property, please do not feed them or disturb them. Same goes for any wild animal you may see. Please do not leave food or trash outside as the deer or other animals can get to it.

Q. What is the parking situation ?
A. Green House guests please park next to your house and Grey House guests please park next to yours. Please try to keep the circular driveway clear. Large boats could be difficult to get through our gates, please discuss with Cadmier in advance.

Q. Do you have paddle boards and kayaks for use?
A. Yes, please share them with guests staying next door. Also please rinse them after each use. .

Q. Is scuba diving, snorkeling, swimming and fishing allowed?
A. Yes, they are all allowed. Please bring your own gear as we do not offer them on the property. You can fish or swim off our dock at your own risk . We have great reefs for snorkeling and scuba diving.
Our area is one of the best in the world for Tarpon fishing. You can catch dolphin (not flipper), snapper, grouper and hogs fish as well. During the right season we also have the best lobster and stone crab right off our beaches. Please respect the space of other guests. Do not leave any garbage on dock as it blows into water and causes great harm to our sensitive ecosystem.


Q. Do you have a pool?
A. No, not at this time but we will in the near future.
Q. Do you have air conditioning, ice and freezer storage ?
A. Yes, the houses do have air conditioning. We ask our guests not to lower the A/C below 72 as it can freeze up with the warm weather outside. If you have any problems with the A/C please notify the caretaker as soon as possible.
We have a 300lb ice machine in our shed and a large freezer as well. Please understand the ice machine and the large freezer are for both houses. If you're planning on doing a big fishing or boat trip we recommend you bring extra bags of ice .

Q. Is smoking allowed in the house? What about cooking smoke?
A. SMOKING IS NOT ALLOWED inside the house. We have smoke alarms and they are connected to the fire department.

Where you’ll sleep

1 of 2 pages

What this place offers

Ocean view
Sea view
Beach access – Beachfront
Kitchen
Wifi

Select check-in date

Add your travel dates for exact pricing

Rated 4.82 out of 5 from 131 reviews.

Guest favorite
This home is a guest favorite based on ratings, reviews, and reliability

Overall rating

  1. 5 stars, 87% of reviews
  2. 4 stars, 9% of reviews
  3. 3 stars, 3% of reviews
  4. 2 stars, 0% of reviews
  5. 1 stars, 1% of reviews

Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars for cleanliness

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars for accuracy

Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars for check-in

Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars for communication

Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars for location

Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars for value

Guest reviews mention

Where you’ll be

Sugarloaf Key, Florida, United States
This listing's location is verified and the exact location will be provided after booking.

Neighborhood highlights

We love our guests to enjoy our beach house. Please bear in mind that our property is situated in the Atlantic Ocean coast and from time to time we get debris and seaweed that wash a shore. Depending on the season and weather, seaweed and debris could accumulate within a few hours after cleaning.

Meet your host

Superhost
885 reviews
4.82 out of 5 average rating
8 years of hosting
Born in the 70s
I'm obsessed with: Exceeding expectations
Welcome to Island Time Hospitality, where we’re more than just a Florida Keys vacation rental company, buyer's/seller's agent, and property manager—we’re a team of passionate locals who are committed to sharing the unforgettable experience of the Florida Keys. We believe that every guest, prospective buyer/seller, and homeowner deserves to feel the same magic that drew us to the Florida Keys and has kept us here ever since.

Island Time is a Superhost

Superhosts are experienced, highly rated hosts who are committed to providing great stays for guests.

Co-hosts

  • Dane Arguello

Host details

Response rate: 100%
Responds within an hour
To help protect your payment, always use Airbnb to send money and communicate with hosts.

Things to know

Cancellation policy
House rules
Check-in: 4:00 PM - 11:00 PM
Checkout before 10:00 AM
8 guests maximum
Safety & property
Exterior security cameras on property
Nearby lake, river, other body of water
Carbon monoxide alarm