Thanks Ben – I think you mixed up the private and public review bits :-)
"“What a beautiful flat Jackie and Colin have. We had a lovely time staying there. It was very cosy and homely and we felt very at home for the weekend in Edinburgh. Everything was there what you needed! I even ironed my shirt before going out! The location was perfect being right in the shadow of Arthur's seat! The flat was also lovely and clean prior to our arrival and Jackie and Colin's housekeeper was at hand to give us the keys! Top marks from Ben and Ailbhe!”
actually I'm not at all particular and uppity. Look at the reviews I've left for other people and the reviews they left for me. This is the first ever bad review I've left, and I thought long and hard whether I should. I'm simply a seasoned traveler and a host, and therefore believe reviews are important and help inform people's choice. As I said, your place is fine, and clean, but I was disappointed and there were things that would prevent me from recommending it. So I felt it important to say so.