My wife Sue and I do not like to cause trouble but we do like to be treated fairly. The construction project was in the garage of Josh's building so he must have been aware of it. One of the doormen told us it was a 3 month long project that still had a while to go. As we were gone from the apt a lot we decided to stay even though the noise was quite loud from 9am to 5pm. Because the noise had us leave earlier than we wanted some days and arrive home later on other days we thought a discount would be fair. We did not know we needed to contact airbnb, didn't want to file a formal complaint as we liked the apt when the construction noise wasn't happening and we thought Josh would handle it. He didn't respond to my request for a discount nor did he suggest I contact airbnb. Again as we mostly believe in Karma we didn't even write negative review.