Skip to content
Italian Restaurant

Nick & Toni's

40 locals recommend · Estimated price 3 out of 4
About this place
It is, in fact, not debatable that Nick & Toni's is the best restaurant on Long Island, a position at the front of the pack that has been hard-earned over a run of almost three decades and counting. Perhaps the most impressive thing about the East Hampton mainstay is that it feels as fresh as it ever has, leaning heavy on seasonally available ingredients and the deft touch of a chef, Joe Realmuto, who understands the virtue of combining impeccable skill and casual restaurant. And since you asked, yes: that is Paul McCartney over there by the pizza oven.
136 Main St
East Hampton, NY 11937
Hours of Operation statusClosed · Opens 6:00 PM
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
Brunch, Dinner
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
Dining Options
No Delivery
Powered by Foursquare

Tips from locals

July 25, 2019
Wonderful food! Get there early if you don't have a reservation and eat at the bar.
February 13, 2019
Great food...people watching
Sarah Katherine
Sarah Katherine
January 16, 2019
Hands down the best Martini every had on any continent. Charming restaurant famous for its clientele, and for its amazing service.
November 02, 2018
Incredible food and great scene.
Suzanne And Davey
Suzanne And Davey
June 22, 2018
Love the atmosphere and food! You never know who you will run into. Paul McCartney is a frequent guest. Get there early and please make a reservation!
Book on Resy