Restaurant

Brewster's Italian Cafe

87 locals recommend,

Tips from locals

Sandy
August 4, 2022
Yummy Italian restaurant in downtown New Buffalo. Amazing outdoor eating space. Be prepared to wait - like most area restaurants, no reservations. Brunch menu is amazing!
Meghan
July 15, 2022
Great Italian food. Love the outdoor seating option. brewstersitaliancafe.com
Donna
July 25, 2021
Wonderful Italian food in downtown New Buffalo. They do take reservations - ask for the outdoor garden if that appeals to you!
Tina
June 8, 2021
**Great atmosphere year round.
Former Member
September 19, 2018
Nice bar, friendly staff and good Italian food

Unique things to do nearby

Lake Michigan - Stand Up Paddle Boarding
  1. Paddleboarding
  2. 3 hours

Locals also recommend

Location
11 W Merchant St
New Buffalo, MI