Restaurant

New York Pizzeria

29 locals recommend

Tips from locals

Liam
May 10, 2022
This place is crazy busy all summer long, but their pizza and staff are all top notch. It's just a four minute drive from the cottage, so it's a great place for a quick pickup meal, though they do offer plenty of indoor seating as well. Make sure to order some garlic knots with your pizza, and for dessert, the tiramisu is excellent.
Michael
September 2, 2020
We all have that craving now and again for a good slice. NYP is our local favorite and they do a lot more than just pizza! Great quality salads, wings, calzones and pizza pies!
Susan And Thomas
July 24, 2015
best pizza and subs around personally know the owner
Jeremy
September 16, 2022
Best pizza and wings in town!
Patrick
May 17, 2022
Best spot to grab a pizza to-go to bring back to the cottage. Call and order ahead, by the time you drive to town it will be ready. Good solid pizza that a true New Yorker would give a thumbs up to.

Locals also recommend

Location
68 Main St
Fort Plain, NY